| Dave | ||
| C | J. Posada | NYY |
| 1B | J. Giambi | NYY |
| 1B | D. Lee | CHC |
| 1B/2B | C. Utley | PHI |
| 3B/OF | Mi. Cabrera | FLA |
| SS | Ha. Ramirez | FLA |
| OF/1B | A. Dunn | CIN |
| OF | Del. Young | TB |
| OF | H. Matsui | NYY |
| OF | C. Duffy | PIT |
| P | B. Webb | ARI |
| P | B. Sheets | MIL |
| P | J. Zumaya | DET |
| P | J. Duchscherer | OAK |
| P | C. Meredith | SD |
| P | A. Pettitte | HOU |
| P | AJ Burnett | TOR |
| P | J. Smoltz | ATL |
| P | J. Verlander | DET |
| P | E. Bedard | BAL |
| P | F. Liriano | MIN |