| Devin | ||
| C | J. Mauer | MIN |
| 1B | R. Howard | PHI |
| 1B | J. Thome | CWS |
| 2B/SS | F. Lopez | WAS |
| 3B | T. Glaus | TOR |
| SS | M. Tejada | BAL |
| OF | M. Holliday | COL |
| OF | J. Francoeur | ATL |
| OF | M. Ramirez | BOS |
| OF | D. Roberts | SD |
| P | C. Carpenter | STL |
| P | J. Schmidt | SF |
| P | Fr. Rodriguez | LAA |
| P | J. Broxton | LAD |
| P | J. Borowski | FLA |
| P | T. Jones | DET |
| P | S. Shields | LAA |
| P | C.C. Sabathia | CLE |
| P | F. Garcia | CWS |
| P | D. Bush | MIL |
| P | J. Papelbon | BOS |