| Al | ||
| QB | Brett Favre | GB |
| QB | Peyton Manning | IND |
| WR | Marvin Harrison | IND |
| WR | Terry Glenn | DAL |
| WR | Brandon Marshall | DEN |
| WR | Amani Toomer | NYG |
| WR | Isaac Bruce | STL |
| WR | Vincent Jackson | SD |
| RB | Frank Gore | SF |
| RB | Marshawn Lynch | BUF |
| RB | Warrick Dunn | ATL |
| RB | Samkon Gado | MIA |
| RB | Cedric Benson | CHI |
| RB | Domanic Davis | HOU |
| TE | Randy McMichael | DEN |
| K | Jeff Reed | PIT |
| DEF | DAL | DAL |