| Owner | Pos | Player | Team | Owner | Pos | Player | Team | |||
| 1 | Chad | WR | Charles Rogers | DET | 41 | Jake | QB | Chad Hutchinson | DAL | |
| 2 | Jon | RB | Marcel Shipp | ARZ | 42 | Jake | TE | Randy McMichael | MIA | |
| 3 | Chad | WR | Andre Johnson | HOU | 43 | Jake | WR | Andre Davis | CLE | |
| 4 | Joe | WR | Jerry Porter | OAK | 44 | Matt | QB | Jon Kitna | CIN | |
| 5 | Dave | WR | Donald Driver | GB | 45 | Jake | WR | Taylor Jacobs | WAS | |
| 6 | Steve | WR | Chad Johnson | CIN | 46 | Joe | PK | Jay Feely | ATL | |
| 7 | Dave | QB | Matt Hasselbeck | SEA | 47 | Adam | PK | Jeff Reed | PIT | |
| 8 | Chad | QB | Patrick Ramsey | WAS | 48 | Jake | WR | Reche Caldwell | SD | |
| 9 | Dave | QB | Tommy Maddox | PIT | 49 | Adam | PK | Phil Dawson | CLE | |
| 10 | Jake | QB | Byron Leftwich | JAX | 50 | Jake | PK | John Hall | WAS | |
| 11 | Chad | RB | Willis McGahee | BUF | 51 | Dave | DF | Buccaneers | TB | |
| 12 | Adam | QB | Carson Palmer | CIN | 52 | Rich | QB | Chris Redman | BAL | |
| 13 | Matt | QB | Marc Bulger | STL | 53 | Steve | RB | Adrian Peterson | CHI | |
| 14 | Jon | RB | Amos Zereoue | PIT | 54 | Jon | TE | Christian Fauria | NE | |
| 15 | Jake | RB | Charlie Garner | OAK | 55 | Scott | DF | Dolphins | MIA | |
| 16 | Joe | RB | Moe Williams | MIN | 56 | Joe | WR | Wayne Chrebet | NYJ | |
| 17 | Adam | RB | Larry Johnson | KC | 57 | Matt | TE | Doug Jolley | OAK | |
| 18 | Scott | QB | Kelly Holcombe | CLE | 58 | Matt | PK | Rian Lindell | BUF | |
| 19 | Rich | QB | Kyle Boller | BAL | 59 | Steve | TE | Teyo Johnson | OAK | |
| 20 | Rich | TE | Todd Heap | BAL | 60 | Chad | RB | Tony Hollings | HOU | |
| 21 | Chad | RB | Onterrio Smith | MIN | 61 | Rich | QB | Jeff Blake | ARZ | |
| 22 | Jake | WR | Quincy Morgan | CLE | 62 | Jake | TE | Jason Witten | DAL | |
| 23 | Jon | WR | Brian Finneran | ATL | 63 | Jake | WR | Marc Boerigter | KC | |
| 24 | Jon | RB | Lee Suggs | CLE | 64 | Jon | RB | Shawn Bryson | DET | |
| 25 | Jake | RB | Troy Hambrick | DAL | 65 | Scott | QB | Chris Simms | TB | |
| 26 | Scott | RB | Correll Buckhalter | PHI | 66 | Joe | DF | Giants | NYG | |
| 27 | Adam | RB | Stacey Mack | HOU | 67 | Dave | RB | Justin Fargas | OAK | |
| 28 | Dave | RB | Zack Crockett | OAK | 68 | Matt | PK | Jeff Chandler | SF | |
| 29 | Chad | WR | Josh Reed | BUF | 69 | Steve | PK | Josh Brown | SEA | |
| 30 | Adam | RB | Chris Brown | TEN | 70 | Chad | RB | Jamel White | CLE | |
| 31 | Dave | WR | Tai Streets | SFO | 71 | Jake | WR | Joey Galloway | DAL | |
| 32 | Steve | WR | Antonio Bryant | DAL | 72 | Rich | DF | Panthers | CAR | |
| 33 | Adam | QB | Rex Grossman | CHI | 73 | Dave | RB | LaBrandon Toefield | JAX | |
| 34 | Jon | WR | Todd Pinkston | PHI | 74 | Jon | PK | Jason Hanson | DET | |
| 35 | Rich | RB | LaDell Betts | WAS | 75 | Scott | PK | Doug Brien | NYJ | |
| 36 | Joe | WR | Ike Hilliard | NYG | 76 | Joe | RB | Dominic Rhodes | IND | |
| 37 | Rich | WR | Peter Warrick | CIN | 77 | Adam | QB | Jake Delhomme | CAR | |
| 38 | Scott | PK | Sebastien Janikowski | OAK | 78 | Jake | PK | Morten Andersen | KC | |
| 39 | Steve | TE | Alge Crumpler | ATL | 79 | Steve | RB | Jesse Chatman | SD | |
| 40 | Scott | RB | LaMont Jordan | NYJ | 80 | Jake | DF | Cowboys | DAL |