Welcome to Anne's & Neil's Restaurant Reviews!
In our many culinary travels in Manhattan, Anne and Neil have been
fortunate to sample several of the city's most satisfying (and some not so satisfying)
restaurants. We are writing this guide to help us remember all the wonderful meals
we have shared together and to provide you with our humble opinions.
PLEASE NOTE THAT THIS PAGE IS STILL UNDER CONSTRUCTION.
WE WILL CONTINUE
TO ADD RESTAURANT REVIEWS OVER THE NEXT FEW WEEKS.
How our ratings work:
- Anne's Ratings (from good to bad)
- * * * * * (I HAVE TO GO BACK)
- * * * * (YOU HAVE TO GO)
- * * * (REALLY GOOD)
- * * (PRETTY GOOD)
- * (OK)
- + (YOU CAN GO, BUT I DIDN'T ENJOY IT)
- - (DO NOT GO TO THIS PLACE)
- Neil's Ratings (from good to bad)
- I LIKED IT
- IT WAS GOOD
- EH . . .
Union Square Cafe
Anne's Rating = * * *,
Neil's Rating = IT WAS GOOD
� Union Square Cafe
A friend of Anne's (we'll withold his name to save him the embarrassment of
being associated with us, but in case you're wondering, it's Vadim Rubinstein)
gave us his hard fought 6:00 p.m. reservation for a Saturday night(!) for four
people on February 24, 2001. When we arrived, people without reservations were
being turned away, and the bar was crowded. Our genuinely cheery hostess asked
us (Anne, Neil, Dan the lawyer and Katie the dancer) to step aside, and
within minutes we were shown to our table in what looked
to be the smaller of two dining rooms on the lower level. The setting was
contemporary and elegant.
After choosing a red wine from a reasonably priced wine list, our waitress
made some helpful suggestions from the menu, including a few items that we ordered.
Anne had the porcini gnocchi (the name says it all), which was like "buttah" and
perhaps the best gnocchi and sauce combination Anne has ever eaten. Our waitress said
it was one of the signature dishes. Neil had the fried calamari, which was perhaps
the best fried calamari we have ever had. It was done to perfection, crispy and not
at all chewy.
Anne ordered the crisp-roasted lemon pepper duck, which came with a sweet chutney
and a flavorful medley of wild rice and vegetables. It was quite interesting
(in a good way). The duck skin was perfectly crisp, but
the crisping may have left the meat a little dry. However, the meat was infused with
a wonderful lemon flavor. Neil enjoyed the day's special - short ribs with
the bones removed - despite the threat of mad cow disease.
It came with horseradish mashed potatoes. He thought it was pretty good. Anne
had a taste and thought that aside from the tenderness the chef achieved with the meat,
the short ribs and potatoes were nothing special.
Our guests enjoyed a pasta appetizer. Dan had the duck, and Katie had the roasted
chicken. Both agreed the food was really good and the wine was very nice.
Overall: The appetizers certainly whetted our appetites for more, but the textures
of the food at this restaurant won us over more than the flavors of the main meat
entrees.
Sushi Zen
Anne's Rating = * * * * *,
Neil's Rating = I LIKED IT
A guest on our site asked how Anne could give Union Square Cafe such a glowing review
but rate it at only * * *. What does a restaurant have to do to get * * * * *? Well,
here's the answer: it has to serve amazing sushi and provide
incomparable service. This restaurant does both. It is packed at lunch (the
only time either Anne or Neil has had an opportunity to go), so make your reservations
ahead of time or be prepared to wait. Anne took her sister, Astrid, and Astrid's
boyfriend,
Patrick, here during the summer and was shown a lovely table in the Zen Garden out back.
The main dining room is very calming, showcasing a warmly colored relief of a
mountain range.
Now - on to the sushi. We are not sushi experts nor are we sushi daredevils. However,
after tasting sushi from various establishments -- from Go Sushi to
Sushisay, Teriyaki Boy to Hatsuhana, and Daikichi (yes, we admit) to Nobu, and everything in between -- we have
to say that the quality
of the fish, the preparation and the overall taste of the sushi here is one whole
entire notch above everything else. Anne's
favorites include the strawberry hand roll and the poorly named New Jersey roll, which
is made from melt-in-your-mouth fatty tuna. Neil is especially fond of the
Chef's combination, which includes an assortment of sushi. This little piece of
heaven serves sushi that tastes as if it has been just caught moments earlier.
Try it and you'll see what we mean.
Overall: This sushi goes to 11! You must absolutely try this place - and bring your expense account.
Ruby Foo's
Anne's Rating = * * 1/2,
Neil's Rating = IT WAS GOOD
� B.R. Guest Restaurants
Sometimes, at glitzy Manhattan restaurants, form reigns over function.�
At this sprawling upper West Side restaurant, however, the food can actually
stand up to its surroundings. Ruby Foo's can be described as an upscale theme
restaurant. (Notice the use of the passive voice.� Neil has commented that
Anne uses the terms "we" and "our" a little too loosely,
conveying her sentiments perhaps more than his.� Thusly, when possible -
and even though grammatically less desirable - these reviews will attempt to
present opinions in a neutral or passive voice.)� It's loud here; it's
boisterous - less Zen and more Chinatown, sans the dirt and fish aromas.�
The kind of place that makes Neil suspicious of the food.� The tables are
different colors and are painted with a single large Chinese character.�
The "downtown" location in Times Square (which Anne went to with her gal pal attorneys Ginny, Kellianne and Daphnee) is just as frenetic in decor
and atmosphere, but not as multi-leveled as its uptown sister, although candles
do put in a good effort in trying to calm the scene.� Reservations are a
must.� So is the blonde waiter for your table. Sit upstairs and experience
the grand red spiral staircase.
The sushi here is fun.� Anne had the eel and crab with mango and coconut
- a wonderful meld of flavors - all wrapped in a very thinly sliced skin of
cucumber - very creative and labor intensive.� This hot spot, however, is
not the place to go for serious sushi.� Neil had the special of the day -
striped bass in a tamarind sauce.� Despite his suspicions of the place, one
bite and he was a happy camper.� The sauce was packed with flavor and quite
unusual.� Anne had never tasted anything quite like it, except in a small
Indonesian town at a road side shack that created some stomach issues for
her.� The bass came with a heaping mound of flavored, aromatic white and
brown rices, which were presented on a raised serving platter.� It's nice to
go to a place where even the rice got the royal treatment.� Neil also
ordered a side of spicy tofu, which could have come
from any good Chinese restaurant in the city.�
And for the piece de resistance (spelling?) - the sushi bento box
dessert!!!� Even though Anne cannot spell, she also cannot rave enough
about this dessert.� She's been talking about it ever since she first had
it at the Times Square Foo's months ago.� Imagine a Japanese bento box with
several compartments, filled with various kinds of sushi - cucumber rolls, tuna
rolls, shrimp nigiri.� Now imagine that each piece of sushi is made from
something sweet, instead of savory.� The tuna roll is actually a
macaroon-like roll of coconut with a piece of mango at its center, the mound of
pale green wasabi is made from marzipan and a realistic looking piece of shrimp
is made from a white-chocolate crunch.� OK - so the obligatory chocolate
cake with the gooey filling inside did not look like sushi and neither did the
vanilla ice cream, but overall, the presentation was quite fanciful - this one's
also very labor intensive - and for only about $8!� Neil's favorites
included the assorted coconut "sushi," and Anne's favorites included
the banana wrapped in a sweetened, doughy "seaweed," which Anne dipped
thoroughly in the rich chocolate fudge provided in the center of the bento box.
Overall:� Neil says, "Recommended as an upscale type of
thing.� Good before a movie.� Sony Lincoln Center is
nearby."� Anne says, "Go for your birthday and bring the
gang.� You'll have a great time!"
|
|