| Name | Year | O/A | Notes | |
| Angel | 5 | A | ||
| Apple Delight Family | 7 | O | All three of them with factory curls… really pretty! | |
| Applejack | 2 | A | She's missing her tail… | |
| Baby Blue Ribbon | SO | O | Still have the game board - I'M ALWAYS LOOKING FOR THE CARDS! | |
| Baby Bouncy | 5 | O | ||
| Baby Cotton Candy | 3 | A | Had one when I was little… but this isn't the same one. | |
| Baby Cuddles (Drink 'n Wet) | 8 | O | ||
| Baby Cuddles (Regular Eye) | 3 | A | Complete with her buggy! | |
| Baby Fifi | 5 | A | ||
| Baby Fleecy | 7 | O | ||
| Baby Glory | 3 | A | I think I had her when I was little… but there's no record of it. | |
| Baby Gusty | 4 | O | ||
| Baby Half Note (BBE) | 4 | O | Just her, her tutu and leg warmers - I have some of the animals too. | |
| Baby Lickety-Split (First Tooth) | 5 | A | ||
| Baby Lofty | 4 | A | ||
| Baby Moondancer | 3 | A | Had this one when I was little too… | |
| Baby Nectar | 7 | O | ||
| Baby North Star | 5 | A | ||
| Baby Quackers | 5 | A | ||
| Baby Rainribbon | ? | A | Can't remember the year on this one… | |
| Baby Ribbon | 4 | A | ||
| Baby Shady | 4 | A | My one and only garage sale success - $.50! | |
| Baby Starbow | ? | A | Can't remember the year on this one… | |
| Baby Stripes | 7 | O | ||
| Baby Sundance (BBE) | 3 | O | ||
| Baby Tic-Tac-Toe | 5 | O | ||
| Baby Tiddly Winks (BBE) | 4 | A | ||
| Baby Tippytoes | 9 | O | ||
| Baby Wolly | 7 | O | ||
| Bangles | 5 | A | ||
| Beach Ball | 7 | A | Her hair still changes color! | |
| Blue Belle | SO | A | CF My brother had one when we were little… but not now. | |
| Bouquet | 6 | A | A gift from my friend, Kris! | |
| Bowtie | 2 | A | I had one when I was little, but this ain't her. | |
| Brilliant Bloom | 7 | O | Brush 'n Grow feature still works! | |
| Bubbles | 3 | A | She's in bad shape… I'd like to replace her. | |
| Buttons | 4 | A | ||
| Cherries Jubilee | 3 | A | ||
| Cherry Treats | 6 | O | Still smells a little like cherries still… | |
| Christmas Baby Pony | SO | A | ||
| Cosmos (October) | SO | A | Not for sale, so stop asking! :-) | |
| Cotton Candy | 1 | A | FF She's a lighter version than some of the other ones… | |
| Cotton Candy | 2 | O | CF She's a darker version! | |
| Cranberry Muffins | 6 | A | Leaving the herd soon as a trade! | |
| Creamsicle the Giraffe | 5 | O | I have a great picture of me posing with her and Peppermint Crunch! | |
| Dancing Butterflies | 5 | A | ||
| Ember (pink w/ purple hair) | SO | O | ||
| Fancy Flower | 7 | O | ||
| Firefly | 2 | A | ||
| Fizzy | 4 | A | ||
| Flower Bouquet | 7 | O | ||
| Foamy | 6 | O | Have her float too! | |
| Galaxy | 4 | A | ||
| Gardenglow | 9 | A | From what I've heard she didn't have an earring, but mine has a hole for one… | |
| Glory | 2 | O | My first pony! Hardly any symbol left and her tail's missing. | |
| Gusty | 3 | A | ||
| Gusty (SS) | 4 | O | ||
| Half Note | 9 | A | Have her MOC - what started the pony obsession again… | |
| Heart Throb | 3 | A | ||
| Heart Throb (SS) | 4 | A | Her flocking is really great still. | |
| High Flyer | ? | A | I can't remember what year this Summer Wing is, but I'll find it soon. | |
| Hula Hula | 8 | A | ||
| Lemon Drop | ? | A | Got her with a Show Stable, but I'm not sure about the year. | |
| Lickety-Split | 3 | A | ||
| Locket | 5 | O | ||
| Lofty | 4 | A | ||
| Love Melody | 5 | A | Her hair's still barely pink. | |
| Lucky, the Stallion | SO | O | Still wondering how he could be a baby AND a stallion… | |
| Majesty | SO | A | ||
| Masquerade | 4 | A | Apparently had her when I was little, but not this one. | |
| Medley | 2 | A | First adopted Pony! | |
| Megan | 3 | A | Very complete… | |
| Megan (SS) | SO | A | Not the right shoes, but has everything else! | |
| Megan (TAF) | 7 | O | Never took Megan's hair out of its pony-tail! Her hair still changes color too! | |
| Merry Treat | 8 | O | Have her comb. | |
| Milky Way | 5 | O | ||
| Minty (FF) | 1 | A | ||
| Molly | 4 | A | ||
| Moondancer | 2 | A | Mint, save the red streak on her side… so she models Pony Wear! | |
| Moonstone | 2 | A | ||
| Morning Glory | 4 | A | No wings, but her hair's just great. | |
| North Star | 4 | O | I had two of these… | |
| Paradise | 4 | A | ||
| Parasol | 2 | O | ||
| Peppermint Crunch | 6 | O | Still smells good! I've got a picture of me posing with her and Creamsicle! | |
| Pony Bride (Dum Dum de Dum) | 8 | O | Still have her cake. | |
| Pretty Beat | 9 | A | Have her guitar brush. | |
| Princess Serena | 5 | O | Have another blue Bushwooly that came with her… | |
| Princess Sparkle | 5 | O | Have Hugster Bushwooly. | |
| Princess Tiffany | 5 | O | Have her blue Bushwooly - Friendly | |
| Quackers | 5 | A | ||
| Quarterback | 5 | O | Have his scarf. | |
| Rattles (New Born Twin) | 5 | O | ||
| Ringlets | 6 | O | ||
| Rosedust | 4 | O | No wings now… but I remember when… | |
| Salty | 5 | O | Have his scarf. | |
| Satin 'n Lace | SO | O | Dark magenta version. | |
| Scoops | 5 | O | She's got her hat and apron, but I can't find her Sweet Shop at all! | |
| Sea Breeze | 8 | A | ||
| Seawinkle | 2 | A | I have her blue clam shell too. | |
| Sealight | 6 | O | Still have her float. | |
| Shady | 4 | A | ||
| Shoreline | 7 | O | Hair still changes color. | |
| Sky Rocket (Sparkle) | 7 | O | ||
| Sky Rocket (TE) | 4 | A | ||
| Skydancer | 2 | A | ||
| Sprinkles | ? | A | I got her with the Waterfall, yet she's the lavender version - so who knows! | |
| Spunky the Camel | 5 | O | ||
| Starflash | 8 | O | ||
| Starshine | 2 | A | I'd love to replace this one… her symbol is bad. | |
| Sugar Apple | 7 | O | Beautiful hair and still smells great! | |
| Sugarberry | 5 | A | Her hair's silky, but has cuts in it. | |
| Sunbeam | 2 | O | ||
| Sundance | 3 | A | ||
| Sundance (SS) | SO | A | Yellowing, but that's okay. | |
| Sundance (TAF) | 7 | O | Her hair still changes color! | |
| Sunlight | 2 | A | ||
| Sun Spot | 7 | A | ||
| Sweet Notes | 9 | O | Have my original guitar brush too. Her hair's still beautifully crimped! | |
| Sweet Sundrop | 8 | O | ||
| Swinger | 7 | O | ||
| Taffy | 5 | O | ||
| Tall Tails | 6 | O | ||
| Tattles (New Born Twin) | 5 | O | ||
| Tootie Tails | 8 | O | ||
| Tuneful | 9 | A | Have her guitar brush. | |
| Twilight (SS) | 5 | A | ||
| Twinkler | 7 | A | ||
| Twirler | 7 | O/A | I have my original and I also have one MIB! | |
| Twisty Tail | 6 | O | ||
| Up, Up and Away | 5 | O | ||
| Wavedancer | 2 | O | Shell and everything! | |
| Whizzer | 4 | A | ||
| Wind Whistler (UK Version) | ? | A | Her hair still has the slightest hint of pink! | |
| Windy | 2 | O | ||
| Windy (Magic Message) | 6 | O | She doesn't change anymore. | |