Author’s Name:                                               

 

Peer Editor’s Name:                                               

 

 

Peer Editing Guide

 

Organization:

1. Does the essay have a clear introduction, body, and conclusion?

 

 

2. What is the main thesis of this paper?

 

 

3. What are the main points that support the thesis? Are they easily identified? Are they effectively sequenced?

 

 

 

4. Do the arguments coherently lead to the conclusion?

 

 

5. What transitional devices are used? Does the paper read smoothly or does it need more effective transitions?

 

 

 

Content:

1. Are the main points and arguments supported with sufficient evidence?

 

2. Are "key" terms and ideas clearly defined or explained?

 

3. Do any sections of the paper leave you feeling confused? If so, explain.

 

 

 

Usage:

1. Are there any problems with word choice, vocabulary, and style? If so, identify.

 

 

2. Are there any consistent errors in grammar, especially ones that obscure meaning? If so, identify.