This week, I was privileged to attend the Asian Pacific American
Film Festival occurring in APA310. Although all of the films were
excellent, and all raised interesting issues about the roles of the APA
person in today’s society, I selected two on which I wish to focus:
Debra Gee’s Slaying the Dragon and Jennifer Phang’s Love, Ltd.
Both of these strongly explore the role of the Asian American women, in
very different ways.
Slaying the Dragon was created in 1987, and in many ways, it
shows it. It is a documentary which aims to chronicle the role of
Asian women in American filmmaking, but it feels like a timeline cut short.
Still, it does a good job of detailing the evolution of the Asian female
in film. One of the interesting facts I discovered in the course
of watching Slaying the Dragon was that frequently, white actresses played
Asian women because of anti-miscegenation laws that were in place at the
time. I had always assumed that the reason for this was simply that
the white actresses were better known.
The documentary does a good job of detailing the influences of several
major films such as The World of Susie Wong, a 1960 film starring Nancy
Kwan and William Holden, which inflamed the stereotypes of Asian women
as prostitutes. Slaying the Dragon also discusses the importance
of Flower Drum Song, an all Asian-American musical, which though it provided
some variety of roles for the women, tended to pigeonhole them into certain
stereotypes. It even points out the strong impact Connie Chung had
on the role of women in the media, adding one more stereotype to fit the
women into.
While Slaying the Dragon does a fine job of detailing this history
of Hollywood pigeonholing Asian women into various stereotypes, it might
be helpful for them to point out that women in general in Hollywood have
been placed in the virgin/whore paradigm for many years. It would
be interesting to see how much this documentary would be changed if it
were created today, and whether a different conclusion would be drawn.
Love, Ltd. Is a much more recent production (1999) and so has
a more au courant feel to it. It is the story of a young Asian American
woman attempting to break the news that she is a lesbian, and involved
in a committed relationship with a woman, to her family. She is thwarted
along the way by her younger brother, who confesses himself to be gay,
and her mother’s homophobic reaction. In the end, the whole damned
family (except for the mother and possibly the youngest child) turns out
to be gay, in a comedic twist.
The film is oddly constructed, interspersed with a number of
shots that are not explained until later in the film. The cinematography
seems to embrace sensuality, and worship the human body. We are treated
to lovingly detailed shots of a woman combing her hair and embracing her
sleeping lover. The film lingers over the body of a young man playing
basketball, forcing the moment into slow motion, as if to appreciate his
youthful beauty more fully. There are ceiling shots of a karate class,
embracing the vigor of the martial arts. I cannot quite decide, however,
if the lyricism of the film is helped or harmed by the final sequence of
the two female lovers arguing, which is shown with no sound. At the
time it seemed strange and off-putting, but upon later reflection, it seemed
more in harmony with the rest of the film.
There are a number of uniquely Asian American issues in this
film, as well as a lot of universal ones (after all, isn’t it a little
strange that the whole family except the mother is gay, and they’re the
ones who feel isolated?). The stereotype of the overbearing Asian
mother is dusted off and examined, revealing a wealth of complexity in
this woman, who in trying to keep her family whole and healthy is driving
them further apart. The idea of an Asian American woman’s sexuality
is dissected, though to tell the truth, the two actresses portraying lesbians
were so lovingly natural together, it was impossible to be shocked or unsettled
by them. Another theme presented in this movie is the Asian American
family; this theme is explored by presenting a charming suburban family,
who just happen to be mostly gay. This is a time-honored tactic –
if you want to get people to look at something in a new way, show them
people who are different from us, but turn out to be just like us or people
who are just like us, but turn out to be fundamentally different.
All in all, this is an excellent film festival, highly challenging
and provocative. I highly recommend it to anyone who would like to
cut Hollywood’s dull fare with something a little sharper.