� THE COMMISH: GIVING IT THE OLD COLLEGE TRY

I've always kind of wondered which of the "big six" conferences would field the most complete starting lineup of fantasy studs, but it took a rainy, cold week in April for me to actually do the research. The results range from downright scary to seriously pitiful. The ACC checks in at a solid third. Without further ado ...


SEC
Pos. Player College Team NFL Team
QB Peyton Manning Tennessee Indianapolis Colts
RB Shaun Alexander Alabama Seattle Seahawks
RB Travis Henry Tennessee Buffalo Bills
RB Deuce McAllister Ole Miss New Orleans Saints
WR Eric Moulds Mississippi State Buffalo Bills
WR Hines Ward Georgia Pittsburgh Steelers
TE Randy McMichael Georgia Miami Dolphins
K John Kasay Georgia Carolina Panthers

You can make a case for Manning as the best fantasy quarterback option. But the real prize here are the running backs. Just look at some of the guys left off the squad: Auburn's Stephen Davis (Carolina), Florida's Fred Taylor (Jacksonville), Tennessee's Jamal Lewis (Baltimore), Tennessee's Charlie Garner (Oakland). And there's more where that came from. The Volunteers also have a couple of nice receivers that didn't make the cut: Peerless Price (Atlanta) and Donte' Stallworth (New Orleans). What? No Florida receivers? More on that later ...


Big East
Pos. Player College Team NFL Team
QB Michael Vick Virginia Tech Atlanta Falcons
RB Edgerrin James Miami Indianapolis Colts
RB Curtis Martin Pitt New York Jets
RB Clinton Portis Miami Denver Broncos
WR Marvin Harrison Syracuse Indianapolis Colts
WR Jerry Porter West Virginia Oakland Raiders
TE Jeremy Shockey Miami New York Giants
K Mike Vanderjagt West Virginia Indianapolis Colts

Tough choices on the board here, but I went with potential over past performance, for the most part. Vick over Syracuse's Donovan McNabb (Philadelphia) is splitting hairs. And if you think Martin's better days are behind him, take Boston College's William Green (Cleveland) instead. There's not much depth at receiver, but we're looking for the best starting lineup. There's even a nice second option at tight end: Miami's Bubba Franks (Green Bay).


ACC
Pos. Player College Team NFL Team
QB Aaron Brooks Virginia New Orleans Saints
RB Tiki Barber Virginia New York Giants
RB Warrick Dunn Florida State Atlanta Falcons
WR Laveranues Coles Florida State Washington Redskins
WR Torry Holt N.C. State St. Louis Rams
WR Koren Robinson N.C. State Seattle Seahawks
TE Alge Crumpler North Carolina Atlanta Falcons
K Sebastian Janikowski Florida State Oakland Raiders

The obvious downfall to this team is its running backs, which only beat out the Pac-10 for quality (it's a wide margin, though!). That receiving corps is arguably the best here, and you can sub Clemson's Rod Gardner (Washington) in for one of those three if you want.


Big Ten (11)
Pos. Player College Team NFL Team
QB Tom Brady Michigan New England Patriots
RB Michael Bennett Wisconsin Minnesota Vikings
RB Eddie George Ohio State Tennessee Titans
WR David Boston Ohio State San Diego Chargers
WR Plaxico Burress Michigan State Pittsburgh Steelers
WR Amani Toomer Michigan New York Giants
TE Rickey Dudley Ohio State Cleveland Browns
K Jay Feely Michigan Atlanta Falcons

Take Indiana's Trent Green (Kansas City) at quarterback if you want. The running backs aren't as strong as you might think, with George on his last legs and touchdown vultures Daunte Culpepper and Moe Williams stealing all of Bennett's goal line work in Minnesota. Nice receivers left on the bench: Michigan State's Derrick Mason (Tennessee) and Charles Rogers (Detroit), Wisconsin's Chris Chambers (Miami) and Ohio State's Joey Galloway (Dallas). Sorry Terry Glenn (Ohio State and Dallas), but no props for you.


Big 12
Pos. Player College Team NFL Team
QB Kordell Stewart Colorado Chicago Bears
RB Ahman Green Nebraska Green Bay Packers
RB Priest Holmes Texas Kansas City Chiefs
RB Ricky Williams Texas Miami Dolphins
WR Robert Ferguson Texas A&M Green Bay Packers
WR Quincy Morgan Kansas State Cleveland Browns
TE Stephen Alexander Oklahoma San Diego Chargers
K Martin Gramatica Kansas State Tampa Bay Buccaneers

The quarterback and receivers are downright laughable. But that, my friends, is one hell of a corps of running backs, probably the best of the bunch. It is the Big 12's saving grace and the only reason they aren't in last place. Interestingly enough, Holmes was Williams' backup at Texas, which raises the question: What's the best collegiate running back tandem of all-time? Without research, Oklahoma State teammates Barry Sanders and Thurman Thomas, and Notre Dame's pair of Jerome Bettis and Rickey Watters come to mind. Virginia Tech "untouchables" Lee Suggs and Kevin Jones recently parted ways. And I'm sure when it's all said and done, N.C. State's soon-to-be remarkable one-two punch of T.A. McClendon and Darrell Blackman (whenever he actually qualifies) will go down as one of the greats!


Pac-10
Pos. Player College Team NFL Team
QB Drew Bledsoe Washington State Buffalo Bills
RB Trung Canidate Arizona Washington Redskins
RB Corey Dillon Washington Cincinnati Bengals
WR Curtis Conway Southern Cal New York Jets
WR Chad Johnson Oregon State Cincinnati Bengals
TE Tony Gonzalez California Kansas City Chiefs
TE Todd Heap Arizona State Baltimore Ravens
K Ryan Longwell California Green Bay Packers

You're not going far if those are your starting running backs (yes, Canidate was the second-best guy I could find). You've got to love the options at tight end, where Gonzalez and Heap allow you to keep the overrated Keyshawn Johnson (Southern Cal, Tampa Bay Buccaneers) on the bench (thank God for the flex position!). Too bad Washington State's Jason "Mmm-Bop" Hanson (Detroit) got beat out at kicker. ... When you've got two Bungles in your lineup, you know you're in trouble.


Gator-rific!
Well, I promised, now I must deliver ... If this outstanding group doesn't render the old Baysden adage "Thou shall not draft a Florida receiver" obsolete, we don't know what will. Not a bad apple in the group, I say! Draft early and often!

THE BEST FLORIDA HAS TO OFFER
Player NFL Team Comment
Reche Caldwell Chargers Rookie season a disappointment -- big shock
Chris Doering Steelers Even Spurrier kicked him to curb
Jabar Gaffney Texans Can't beat out Corey Bradford for starting gig
Jacquez Green Buccaneers Couldn't cut it in Detroit! Days are numbered
Ike Hilliard Giants Perennial whiner and usually injured
Darrell Jackson Seahawks Just there to take a DB off K-Rob
Willie Jackson Free Agent Not even his momma loves him
Taylor Jacobs Redskins The next great Gator hope
Travis Taylor Ravens Baltimore has WRs? Why?

Archives main page
Columns archives
Main page

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1