Singles matches vs. Eachother
- MAW (1/8/00; West Allis, WI): C.M. Punk
d. Colt Cabana (the MAW debuts of both).
- IWA-MS "From Hardcore Hell And Back 2000"
(8/5/00; Charlestown, IN): C.M. Punk vs.
Colt Cabana (Punk's IWA-MS debut).
- MAW (1/13/01; West Allis, WI): C.M. Punk
d. Colt Cabana.
- MAW (6/3/01; West Allis, WI): Colt Cabana
d. C.M. Punk via the Pepsi Plunge (about
15:00).
- MAW (8/17/01; Kenosha, WI): C.M. Punk
pins Colt Cabana.
- SDW (8/18/01): C.M. Punk d. Colt
Cabana in a Best 2/3 Falls Match. Cabana wins
the first fall and Punk wins both of the next two falls.
Danny Dominion was the special guest referee.
- IWA-MS "Barbed-Wire, Bombs, & Blood"
(9/1/01; Charlestown, IN): Best 2/3 Falls Match - C.M.
Punk vs. Colt Cabana (Special
Guest Referee: Suicide Kid)
- IWA-MS "Bloodfeast 2001" (11/22/01;
Charlestown, IN): C.M. Punk vs. Colt
Cabana (30:000 Ironman Match).
- IWA-MS "Christmas Carnage" (12/8/01;
Charlestown, IN): C.M. Punk vs. Colt
Cabana vs. Chris Hero.
- MAW (12/15/01; Wind Lake, WI): In the final round of an
MAW World Heavyweight Title Tournament, C.M. Punk
d. Colt Cabana to win the vacant MAW
World Heavyweight Title. Harley Race was the special
guest referee.
- AWA Christmas Chaos (12/18/01): Colt Cabana
pins C.M. Punk in a No DQ,
Barbed-Wire-Wrapped Baseball Bat, Casket, Blindfold,
Barroom Brawl of Death. Punk broke his nose after an Asai
Moonsault, but continued the match. About ****1/4.
- MAW (1/12/02; Wind Lake, WI): C.M. Punk
and Colt Cabana wrestle to a 60:00 Time
Limit Draw.
- IWF (1/25/02): C.M. Punk and Colt
Cabana wrestle to a No Decision.
- MCW (1/26/02; Grayslake, IN): Colt Cabana
pins C.M. Punk via a Super Powerbomb
(16:58).
- IWA-MS (2/8/02; Indianaloplis, IN): C.M. Punk
d. Colt Cabana in the first round of a
Gauntlet Match, and then goes on to wrestle Ace Steel
followed by Chris Hero.
- 3PW (2/15/02): Joey Matthews, Christian York, & Ric
Blade d. Colt Cabana, C.M. Punk,
& Paul E. Normus.
- MAW (2/16/02; Wind Lake, WI): C.M. Punk,
Dave Prazak, & "The Hustler" Carmine
DeSpirito d. "Classic" Colt Cabana,
Axl Rotten, & "The Sensational One" Sherri
Martel in a Mixed Six-Person Tag Team Match.
- IWF (2/24/02): Mr. Insanity & Deranged d. Colt
Cabana & C.M. Punk.
- IWA-MS (3/8/02; Dayton, OH): C.M. Punk
d. Colt Cabana.
- IWC (3/16/02): C.M. Punk d. d. Colt
Cabana.
- IWA-MS "April Bloodshowers 2003 (4/5/02;
Indianapolis, IN): C.M. Punk d. Colt
Cabana and Mike Quackenbush in a three-way
match. Quackenbush forces Cabana to tap out and Punk then
pins Cabana.
- IWF Michigan (4/12/02): Colt Cabana d.
Ace Steel and C.M. Punk in a three-way
match.
- IWA-MS (4/19/02; Dayton, OH): Colt Cabana
d. C.M. Punk (c) and "Latino
Heat" Eddy Guerrero to win the IWA-MS World
Heavyweight Title when he pins Punk w/ a small package.
This was Eddy's last indy show appearance before
returning to (the) WWF/E around mid-200.
- MCW April Anarchy (4/20/02): Colt loses to either Ace
Steel or Punk.
- IWA-MS (5/3/02; Indianapolis, IN): Colt Cabana
(c) d. Chris Hero and C.M. Punk to
retain his IWA-MS World Heavyweight Title. Hero was
eliminated 17:13 and Punk was eliminated by Cabana at
17:27
- IWA-MS (5/4/02; Dayton, OH): Colt Cabana
(c) d. C.M. Punk in a 30:00 Ironman
Match to retain his IWA-MS World Heavyweight Title.
- Chikara Pro's debut show (5/25/02): The BTS (Black
T-Shirt Squad), (Reckless Youth, Don Montoya, & Mike
Quackenbush) d. Colt Cabana, C.M.
Punk, & Chris Hero.
- MAW (6/8/02; Chicago, IL): C.M. Punk d. Colt
Cabana.
- 3PW (9/21/02): Colt Cabana d. C.M.
Punk.
- IWF (9/26/02): Colt Cabana & C.M.
Punk d. Tommy Johnson & Ace Steel.
- IWC (9/27/02): Colt Cabana d. C.M.
Punk.
- IPW (10/26/02): C.M. Punk d. Colt
Cabana (about 11:00).
- ROH Night of [Abdullah] the Butcher (12/7/02): Colt
Cabana pins C.M. Punk.
- ROH (12/28/02):
- NWA-TNA Xplosion Tapings (pre-PPV) (1/8/03): C.M.
Punk pins Colt Cabana after an
Inverted Huracanrana. (aired on 1/11/03 on Xplosion)
- FWA (10/18/03; London, England): International Guest
Match - IPW (10/26/02): C.M. Punk pins Colt
Cabana via the Pepsi Plunge.