Excerpt from http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/harvest/viewpoints/risks.html
|
Critics of
biotechnology say nature is incredibly complex and that GM technology is
introducing a new genre of environmental and health questions. They argue
that introducing foreign genes from distant species (e.g., a gene from a fish
into a strawberry) increases the risk of allergenicity. Also, the risk of new
toxins must be considered. And they point to lab research which has revealed
possible unintended consequences of GMOs. Jeremy Rifkin
Third, they can mutate. Fourth, they can
migrate and proliferate over wide regions. And fifth, you cannot easily
recall them to the laboratory or clean them up. So when we're dealing with
genetically modified organisms, we're dealing with a whole new genre of environmental
and health questions, totally different than when we introduce chemical or
even nuclear products into the environment. ... Those very small bits [of DNA inserted into
genetically modified organisms] can change in qualitative ways that GMO when
it's introduced. Let's say you take a human growth hormone gene and place it
into a salmon. That's just one gene. But if the salmon gets out into the
marine ecosystem and it's growing twice as fast and twice as big, it can
destabilize millions of years of relationships in the oceans. So one gene can
be very, very powerful. ... There's a second generation of genetically
modified organisms being readied in R&D. These organisms are plants that
act as chemical factories to produce genes that code for proteins to produce
vaccines and chemicals and drugs and vitamins. ... This all sounds very
good--except no one has stopped for even a moment and paused and asked this
question: When we seed millions of acres of land with these plants, what
happens to foraging birds, to insects, to microbes, to the other animals,
when they come in contact and digest plants that are producing materials
ranging from plastics to vaccines to pharmaceutical products? There hasn't
been as much as a single congressional hearing, and as far as I know, there
hasn't been a single parliamentary debate anywhere in the world, on
introducing this second generation of pharmaceutical and chemical-producing
plants. |
||||||||||||||||||||||