Taking into account all of our "Iraq
War/morality/volunteer-military" discussion of the past two days; the
NY Times article on the table on Friday (copied below); the 2% v 40% reality*
of American personal connection to the Iraq War; the duration of the Iraq War
(soon to be heading into its 5th year); and the accelerated rotations of
various national guard units (transcript from class linked) . . .
please construct a 1,000 word minimum essay (to be submitted
via email only no later than 11:59:59 PM on
Friday, March 2, 2007) that addresses the following question:
Should the
-------I expect your answer to involve careful discussion of
all items listed above (the NY Times article, the 2% v 40% reality, the
duration of the Iraq War, and the accelerated rotations of various national
guard units. The essay should involve the use of smooth transitions along
with proper grammar and sentence structure. ALL plagiarism rules are in
effect {which is always the case, for the record}).
It will be worth 100 points.
Again, I wish to stress that this exercise is not about
whether or not the
Please know that your essay may be subjected to peer editing
and/or a full reading by all American Government students.
Also, this is an exploratory essay. You may write
according to how you really feel/what you really believe----or you may take a
stance that does not represent your true feelings/beliefs. I don't need
to be told what you're doing. To be honest, I'd rather not be told what
you're doing. The purpose is to explore a line of reasoning regarding all
of the above.
* While most of you were fine in class today, I was
particularly concerned with the lack of engagement demonstrated by a small few;
therefore, I am not responding to emails seeking clarification on the 2% v 40%
reality. If you don't know what it is, you must seek clarification from
classmates. If you were gone from class, I'm asking you to do the
same.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
February
23, 2007
In the nearly two
years Cpl. John Callahan of the Army was away from home, his wife, he said, had
two extramarital affairs. She failed to pay his credit card bills. And their
two children were sent to live with her parents as their home life
deteriorated.
Then, in November,
his machine gun malfunctioned during a firefight, wounding him in the groin and
ravaging his left leg. When his wife reached him by phone after an operation in
“Haven’t you told
him it’s over?” Corporal Callahan, 42, recalled the man saying. “That you
aren’t wearing his wedding ring anymore?”
For Corporal
Callahan, who is recuperating at Walter Reed Army Medical Center, and so many
other soldiers and family members, the repercussions, chaos and loneliness of
wartime deployments are one of the toughest, least discussed byproducts of the
conflicts in Iraq
and Afghanistan.
Hundreds of thousands of soldiers and loved ones have endured long, sometimes
repeated separations that test the fragility of their relationships in
unforeseen ways.
The situation is
likely to grow worse as the military increases the number of troops in
Most families and
soldiers cope, sometimes heroically. But these separations have also left a
trail of badly strained or broken unions, many severed by adultery or sexual
addictions; burdened spouses, some of whom are reaching for antidepressants;
financial turmoil brought on by rising debts, lost wages and overspending;
emotionally bruised children whose grades sometimes plummet; and anxious
parents who at times turn on each other.
Hardest hit are the
reservists and their families, who never bargained on long absences, sometimes
as long as 18 months, and who lack the support network of full-fledged members
of the military.
“Since my husband
has been gone, I have potty-trained two kids, my oldest started preschool, a
kid learned to walk and talk, plus the baby is not sleeping that well,” said
Lori Jorgenson, 30, whose husband, a captain in the Minnesota National Guard,
has been deployed since November 2005 and recently had his tour extended
another four months. “I am very burnt out.”
In the next couple
of months, Ms. Jorgenson, who has three young children, has to get a loan, buy
a house and move out of their apartment.
Even many
active-duty military families, used to the difficulties of deployments, are
reeling as soldiers are being sent again and again to war zones, with only the
smallest pause in between. The unrelenting fear of death or injury, mental
health problems, the lack of recuperative downtime between deployments and the
changes that await when a soldier comes home hover over every household.
And unlike the
“Prior to 9/11, the
deployments were not wartime related,” said Kristin Henderson, a military
spouse whose husband served as a Navy chaplain in
It is common for
spouses to wind up on antidepressants, Ms. Henderson said, a situation made
worse by the repeat deployments. The more deployments, the less time that
families have to mend before the stress sets in again, she added.
Ms. Henderson
recalled having a panic attack in church while her husband was away and crying
in the shower most mornings so no one would see her. “The common
misconception,” she said, “is that the more you do this, the better you get.
That is not true.”
Some relationships
grow stronger as distance and sacrifice help bring into sharp focus what is
important. Before Robert Johnson’s deployments to
But Ms. Johnson,
41, who works full time at a pharmacy, said she felt there had been an upside
to the ordeal. “Now I know,” she said, “that I can pretty much survive
anything.”
Other marriages,
especially young marriages rushed by deployment, may have been destined to fail
from the start.
Seeking
Help
As the war
stretches into its fourth year, more troops and their families are reaching out
for help, turning to family therapists and counselors. The Army and the
Marines, partly in response to a jump in the number of divorces and a rise in
domestic violence reports, have created programs to help couples cope,
including seminars and family weekend retreats. The Army has also improved the
family readiness groups that often serve as a lifeline for spouses.
Divorces, which had
hovered in the 2 percent to 3 percent range for the Army since 2000, spiked in
2004 to 6 percent among officers and 3.6 percent among enlisted personnel. The
rate for officers dropped to 2.1 percent in 2006, but the rate for enlisted
personnel has stayed level, at 3.6 percent.
Married women are
having the hardest time. The divorce rate for women in the Army in 2006 was 7.9
percent, the highest since 2000, compared with 2.6 percent for men.
Demand for
counseling has grown so quickly among military families and returning soldiers
that the military has begun contracting out more services to private
therapists. Reservists must rely largely on networks of volunteers.
“For a while a lot
of soldiers coming back were not being seen because there was such an overload
of patients and so few mental health providers on base,” said Carl Settles, a
psychologist and retired Army colonel who runs a practice near Fort Hood, Tex.
The military
recently called him to ask how many of several hundred patients he could take
on, Dr. Settles said.
Corporal Callahan,
who is on the brink of divorce, said his marriage, his second, had been
troubled before his deployment but became unsalvageable once he shipped out.
His deployment also forced him to transfer guardianship of his children
temporarily to their grandparents because of problems at home, he said.
His injury, which
has left him unable to walk, has now complicated his chances of remaining in
the Army. “I felt like I had hit bottom,” he said. “I had so much bitterness in
me. I have been so angry. So many nights I have cried and tried to figure out
what I can do and what I can’t do.”
Capt. Lance Oliver,
Corporal Callahan’s commander in
“I can’t think of
one that is more heartwrenching,” he said.
Spouses’
Secrets
Extramarital
affairs, hardly rare in other wars, are also a fixture now.
David Hernandez,
who is in the Army and is based in
“It was very
stressful for her doing everything and worrying about me,” he said, adding, “I
spent so much time away; it drove us apart to seek other relationships.”
“Now I’m back out
here,” he said. “I feel helpless. What can I do? It makes it a little easier
being with someone out here. Temptation was the hardest, and I gave in.”
Dr. Settles sees
about 40 soldiers a week in private practice and says a majority of soldiers
cope well. But those with problems feel them deeply.
“Infidelity and
financial issues are major issues,” Dr. Settles said, adding that there are
abundant cases of wives who clear out their husband’s bank accounts or soldiers
who come home and go binge shopping. “Even a good mule needs a few oats once in
a while,” he said. “ Some of these guys, they are kind
of at their limit.”
Some therapists say
they are bracing for this year’s divorces. Mary Coe, a marriage and family
therapist working near
Lei Steivers, whose husband is a senior noncommissioned officer
at
Many spouses, she
said, blame the presence of women alongside combat units. The blame may be
misplaced, but the anxiety is not.
“They are side-by-side
fixing an engine, the girls live upstairs, the guys live downstairs,” Ms. Steivers said. “We are just more and more in awe, saying, What is going on?”
Some wives have
uncovered their husband’s pornographic pictures on Web sites like MySpace, she said, adding, “I’ve seen them because the
wives show them to me.”
Dr. Coe said she
had been surprised by the number of soldiers who had come home and sought
counseling for sexual addictions fueled by DVD’s and Internet pornography.
While pornography
is blocked by the
At the same time,
spouses back home sometimes hook up with men on the Internet. When the relationship
surfaces, it sometimes leads to violence, said Robert Weiss, who co-wrote
“Untangling the Web,” a book about Internet pornography, and who has been hired
as a consultant by military family groups looking for guidance.
Family
Trumps All Else
For some spouses,
concerns about infidelity take a back seat to the demands of a household.
Lillian Connolly’s husband of 21 years, a staff sergeant in the Army Reserve in
“He really worried
about his dad every day,” Ms. Connolly said of her son. “They couldn’t
understand he had an anger problem because his dad was gone.
“That was more
stressful and harder to deal with than my husband being gone.”
Mary Keller, the
executive director of the Military Child Education Coalition, a private
nonprofit group that helps children and schools cope, said two million children
had experienced deployments. Worst hit are those in schools that are isolated
from military culture.
“It is highly
likely that the teacher doesn’t have a personal experience with the military,”
Dr. Keller said.
At home, spouses
say, they try to keep their young children connected to their deployed parents.
Ms. Jorgenson lets her three children pull Skittles out of a bowl to mark the
passage of time. She buys them surprise gifts from their father, like boxes of
Fruity Pebbles or camouflage sheets. Meanwhile, she thinks, “Will I ever get
through bath time and get them to bed without screaming and losing my
patience?”
Parents of young
soldiers often appear the most tormented, counselors say, especially if opposed
to the enlistment. There are also few resources for them.
“Mothers are in
worse shape than wives,” said Jaine Darwin, a
psychoanalyst and co-director of Strategic Outreach to Families of All Reservists,
a volunteer group that offers counseling to military families in many states.
“Mom is not allowed to cry. And that is certainly a problem.”
Esther Gallagher,
50, who works in a counseling office at a high school in
When Sergeant
Gallagher came home for two weeks last year, he walked out of the room any time
anyone talked about
“Every day, they
are in harm’s way,” Ms. Gallagher said, her voice quavering. “I mean, that’s
your baby — to have him out there in harm’s way, and not knowing. Your life has
been to protect these kids.”
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx