Lesson #11: Changing
Belief
Objective:
The previous lesson took a look at how
beliefs can be formed. This lesson looks at how those beliefs can be changed
both in advertisements and in daily life. The ideas learned in this lesson
come from the Social Psychology field. This gives students a view of how
persuasion works on them.
Preset Activity:
(In the previous lesson students
researched derived beliefs. Here students will take a look at Authority
beliefs. These are beliefs that are formed over time, and are contingent
on what others around an individual believe.)
Have students compile a list of different behaviors expected in their classes.
For example, some teachers might allow them to talk more then others. Classes
might have different seating arrangements. The students might write that
most teachers want them facing the front of the room and listen to lecture.
Then they could write that a couple of teachers allow them to sit differently,
or talk more in their class. Have the students write how they know what
the behavior norms are for each class. For example did the teacher tell
them they could chat as he taught or did it occur over time? (This gives
students a glimpse into how behaviors are developed, which is a main focal
point to this lesson.)
Lesson:
Behaviors are developed over time with
influence from outside sources (those around you). Examine how the classroom
norms were developed in each classroom. Did the teachers tell them how
to act or did they learn how to act over time? Today we will take a look
at how those around you can shape your behavior.
In advertisement it is important that
the audience gets the message right away. They are attempting to change
your attitudes, which they hope will change your behavior.
Their method can be explained as a Single-shot
Attitude change. This is a series of steps that have to be met in order
to change the audiences attitude.
1)Attention - have to have their attention
2)Comprehension - audience needs to understand.
3)Acceptance - accept what you say is
true.
4)Retention - need to remember the message.
5)Action - If all the others are met,
the audience will be persuaded into some action.
This model is one that is used by everyone
trying to change someone's attitude. Even your friends and family need
to have all five elements of the single-shot method if they hope to change
your attitude, however those around you don't need to change your mind
in one commercial or advertisement. Most of your friends don't layout an
extensive explanation in order to change your mind. Usually those around
you use subtle methods to change your attitude over time. There are a few
different models or methods that describe how people can persuade over
a period of time.
Behaviorism:
Skinner and schedules of reinforcement.
There are fixed and intermittent schedules of reinforcement. Fixed
schedules give positive feedback on a continuous bases. The schedule can
be based on either time (interval) or action (ratio). Giving dessert after
eating beans is a fixed ratio schedule of reinforcement based on eating
beans. Giving dessert every six hours is a fixed interval schedule of reinforcement.
Intermittent schedules give positive
feedback on a more limited bases. These are also based on either time (interval)
or action (ratio). Playing the lottery is an example of variable ratio.
Addictions can arise out of variable ratio. It is one of the strongest
reinforcements to ensure that a behavior continues after the reinforcement
has ceased.
Negative reinforcement - The taking
away of something for a negative stimuli after a behavior has been completed.
(The taking of Tylenol to rid a headache is an example of this.)
Learning Theory:
Bandura and role models. Social
learning theorist who says that we learn from those around us. We learn
what things are acceptable and which aren't by how others are treated according
to their actions.
Bandura describes this in a three step
model:
1) observes the behavior of a model.
2) immediately copies the response.
3) receive reinforcement.
Shaping or Successive Approximations
- This is where you get someone to do somethhing kind of the way you want
and gradually get them to do more specific things. This is how animals
are trained in obedience schools.
A Story on shaping behavior:
Students in a psychology class decided
to reinforce the professor to move to the left. The reinforcers they used
were listening attentively, nodding their heads, and taking notes. Whenever
the professor moved to the right, however, they stopped delivering the
reinforcers. They would stop taking notes, yawn, and look bored. This systematic
delivery of reinforcers for movement to the left was apparently quite successful,
for legend has it that about halfway through the lecture the professor
fell off the left of the stage.
Tension Theory:
-
We like to agree with people we like
-
We disagree with people we don't like.
-
If we don't like someone and find out that
we agree on something, we either have to change our attitude about the
thing or the person.
Cognitive dissonance:
-
Make people uneasy about something
-
Give them a way to put their minds at ease.
-
We want our beliefs to be in balance with
our actions.
-
When we are made to believe that our actions
are hindering our beliefs it cause dissonance.
-
There are some overall situations that can
cause this imbalance, these are: Loss of Group Prestige, Economic Loss,
Loss of Personal Prestige, Uncertainty of Prediction, and Sense of Guilt.
Reflective: Have groups prepare
a list explaining where they can find each method being used in their daily
lives. They should have an example for: Behaviorism, Learning Theory, Tension
Theory, and Cognitive Dissonance. Then have them prepare a skit that demonstrates
a group trying to change behavior by using one of these methods. (An
example of this would be: Shaping can be found when I hang out with my
friends. My friends like to play basketball and I grew up liking soccer,
after continuous reinforcement for basketball by my friends talking positively
about the sport and giving me the opportunity to play, I have grown to
like basketball more then soccer.)
This unit has been created by
Larry J. Colby
Eastern Michigan
University
April 26, 2003
Please feel free to visit the rest of my website.
http://www.geocities.com/joey2_73