march | april
2001
F E
A T U R E D article
Mosaic Records
WHEN I checked out the web-site for Ken Burns’s documentary on jazz (http://www.pbs.org/jazz), I was surprised to find that not a single record company is listed among the sponsors. Since jazz accounts for a mere three percent of record sales, I assume that record labels must be hoping the series generates as much interest for their back catalog as Burns’s previous documentaries did for Civil War history and baseball. At least two record labels, Verve and Sony Legacy, do have tie-ins with the show, compilation discs of many of the artists whose work is examined there.
Cuscuna and Lourie met in 1975,
when Lourie, then the marketing director for Blue Note, hired Cuscuna to
do research in the Blue Note recording vaults. Like many executives and record
producers who preceded them in jazz, such as John Hammond and Orin
Keepnews, Cuscuna and Lourie loved the music and brought a fanatic’s zeal
to their mission. With Cuscuna as producer, Blue Note began reissuing
recordings that had long been out of print. Cuscuna also discovered a
large number of sessions that Blue Note never got around to releasing and
began making some of them available to listeners. Mosaic was born when
Capital Records, which owns Blue Note, took a pass on a suggestion from
Cuscuna and Lourie that Blue Note should release boxed sets of work by its
artists. When Mosaic began, boxed sets
were a rarity. CDs were just beginning to be widely distributed and
Mosaic’s first sets were pressed on vinyl. The last ten years have seen a
glut of boxed sets, some of great value (The Complete Stax/Volt Singles),
others of little or questionable value (take your pick). Mosaic may have anticipated the
trend but it never compromised its quality or its vision of how the music
should be presented. Mosaic produces limited edition
boxed sets that are available only through them by mail order. The company’s attention to detail
reflects the seriousness with which it regards jazz and jazz scholarship.
It presents jazz from nearly all periods of its history and because it
doesn’t limit the subjects of its sets to household names, it often
reclaims the work of some great musicians whom time has unfairly
forgotten. Mosaic’s sets are limited to
runs of 5000 to 7500 copies on disc and LP1 (a Charlie Parker set, The Complete Dean Benedetti Recordings of Charlie
Parker, is not a limited-edition). The sets are housed in an
elegant 12” X 12” box with a laminated cover that features a black and
white photograph from one of the recording sessions. Enclosed with the music is a full
sized booklet that contains a biography of the featured musician, as well
as a critical evaluation of the sessions contained in the set, which are
carefully documented. The booklet also contains quite a few black and
white photographs from the original sessions, all beautifully
reproduced. Anyone who
remembers carefully reading a record cover while listening to music can
appreciate what a pleasure it is to hold and read an LP cover sized book
with easily readable print and great photos.
A small list of currently
available Mosaic sets demonstrates the uniqueness of their approach: The Complete Blue Note Hank Mobley
Fifties Sessions; The Atlantic New Orleans Jazz Sessions; The Complete Kid
Ory Verve Sessions; The Complete Pacific Jazz Recordings of the Chico
Hamilton Quintet; The Complete Illinois Jacquet Sessions 1945-50. Nine discs comprise Anita
O’Day’s sessions for Verve/Clef. A four-disc set brings together all of
Donald Byrd’s Blue Note studio recordings with Pepper Adams. Cuscuna’s archival skills have
been put to good use by a number of labels. His name appears on reissued
discs on Impulse, Sony Legacy (he was executive producer of the vastly
improved Kind of Blue), and Capital
Records, whose vast jazz catalog includes recordings they obtained from
United Artists, Pacific Jazz, Roulette, and Blue Note. When Mosaic began,
it was unusual for a record label to go back to the original session tapes
in an effort to restore a take that was edited for an LP release. 2 Once Mosaic established this
practice, which Cuscuna and Lourie extended to their reissues of
individual sessions on Blue Note, the rest of the industry began to follow
suit. While it is certainly the case
that the increased capacity of CDs has enabled record companies to offer
complete, unedited, historically accurate performances on disc, it was not
a practice they submitted to voluntarily. Consider the first CD reissue of
Miles Ahead by Miles Davis and
Gil Evans. Columbia Records hired Teo Macero to help with the digital
remastering of Davis’s Columbia Records catalog. Macero was the producer
for many of Davis’s records for the label, although he didn’t produce Miles Ahead. The final release used many
alternate takes rather than the originals (for reasons that aren't
entirely clear--the alternate takes may have been chosen because they were
in stereo, but the final product was pseudo stereo anyway). Most critics felt the alternate
takes were inferior to the originals. A few years later, Columbia
released a second Miles Ahead CD, with the
original producer, George Avakian, overseeing the remastering. He used the
original takes. Columbia may have felt pressured into doing the remaster
because of complaints from critics and jazz fans about the quality of the
first disc. I believe a more important factor was that Cuscuna and Lourie,
through Mosaic and Blue Note, had set a precedent of presenting music
accurately and had created a jazz marketplace where an inferior Miles Ahead just wouldn’t do.
3 A listing of Mosaic’s releases
through the years would include some big names, such as Count Basie, Duke
Ellington, and Art Blakey.
Yet their most important contribution may be that they make
available the work of musicians who seem to have fallen through the
cracks. They put together two Ike Quebec sets, a complete set of Serge
Chaloff sessions (a vital link to players like Gerry Mulligan and Pepper
Adams), and a collection of Blue Note sessions by Tina Brooks. Those sets are out of print, but
available sets by Arthur Hill, Woody Shaw, and a Thad Jones small group
collection serve a similar purpose: To make available once again the
important contributions of musicians whose work shouldn’t be lost.
The Complete Blue Note Horace Parlan
Sessions, a recent Mosaic release, highlights the accomplishments
of a pianist who is best known for his work on an essential jazz album,
Charles Mingus’s Mingus Ah Um. Some of Parlan’s Blue Note
recordings as a leader are available as expensive Japanese imports and
Classic Records produced a limited edition pressing of one of the sessions
included on the Mosaic set, On the Spur of the Moment.
Otherwise, his work is only
available here in the US on Steeplechase, a UK label, and those recordings
were all done long after his Blue Note work. Parlan was stricken with polio
at age 5, and as a result lost use of the fourth and fifth fingers on his
right hand. His style is
heavily rhythmic and shot through with blues and gospel (his father was a
minister). Discs one and two of the five disc set include three trio
sessions from 1961 (conga player Ray Barretto joins the third session on a
few tracks) and those recordings give us an opportunity to hear Parlan’s
approach more closely. He
doesn’t play long, expansive melodies. He develops his solos by combining
short melody runs with interval and chordal examinations of the harmonic
possibilities of the song.
Tension grows out of the rhythm attack of his right hand as he
skirts over notes, hits a hard chord or repeats a phrase from different
rhythmic angles, and then drops to a softer advance while his left hand
solidly holds down the structure of the song. As strongly blues based as his
playing is, he doesn’t coast on familiar riffs. The next two sessions, one from
July 1960 and one from March 1961, are quintet recordings featuring Parlan
with Stanley and Tommy Turrentine.
Tommy’s slightly raspy trumpet tone blends well with his brother’s
tenor sax. Once again, the songs are very blues influenced, a musical
platform that always brought out Stanley Turrentine’s best. Parlan’s
support for both horn players contains some unexpected chord changes that
anticipate and underline each soloist’s lines. Parlan’s own no-nonsense
approach to solos is matched by Tommy Turrentine’s economical
playing. The two remaining sessions are a quintet recording from 1961 with Booker Ervin and Grant Green and a sextet with Ervin, Green, and Johnny Coles from 1963. Ervin's tone is more open and his approach more urgent than Stanley Turrentine's and the overall feel of the session where he is the only horn is more spare, since Grant Green is taking what would usually be the second horn position. Parlan's comping on this session and the session with Coles feels darker, the chords at times more dissonant than in the other sessions in the set. It's Ervin's unique voice that causes the shift. Even a track like "A Tune for Richard," which sounds like a standard Blue Note hard bop composition, moves into an entirely different direction during Ervin's solo (the tune is his). Johnny Coles's work makes you realize how underrecorded he was and makes you wonder why. Grant Green is, as always, endlessly inventive, his tone instantly recognizable but his melodies always unique.
Horace Parlan's unique approach is featured
on great recordings by Lou Donaldson (Sunny Side Up), Dexter Gordon
(Doin' Alright), and Booker
Ervin (Exultation!). He played on the 1961 sessions of
the great British tenor player, Tubby Hayes. He moved to Denmark in 1972 and
has done a lot of recording with other expatriate jazz musicians, such as
Archie Shepp. After listening to and absorbing the Mosaic set, I pulled
other recordings on which he played and found that I was consistently
impressed with the impact he had on the tone of the sessions. His amazing
chordal shifts provide tremendous support and possibilities for
improvisers and when he enters for his own solos the energy level rises a
notch. Soon after I began writing
this piece, I was saddened to read that Charlie Lourie died at age 60
after a long illness. I wish he'd had more time. Lourie left behind so
many great sets, so many tributes to the vitality of jazz. The message
that he and Mosaic delivered again and again, and will surely continue to
deliver in his absence, is that attention must be paid to these musicians,
to the forgotten as much as to the well known.
W.H. Auden once observed of
literature, "Some books are undeservedly forgotten; none are undeservedly
remembered." He was
describing a phenomenon that occurs in all the arts. In recorded music,
greatness can be rediscovered when records are returned to print. Scholars can place someone like
Horace Parlan in the right context and those of us who are collectors can
search through our libraries to find him and learn where he helped jazz
achieve its greatness. Charlie Lourie left a legacy of beautifully presented, perfectly
restored sets of recordings by musicians whose contribution to jazz is
incalculable. One of his favorites was Tina Brooks, who was the leader of
a mere four sessions. Mosaic gathered those sessions together so we could
be reminded that Tina Brooks mattered. Four great sessions is more than
most of us will do. You can request a catalog from Mosaic at http://www.mosaicrecords.com/ or call them at 203-327-7111.
1 These numbers
represent a combined total for both formats. In 1998, Mosaic began phasing
out LP versions of its releases. It will continue to release some titles
on vinyl and CD, as it did the recent Complete Blue Note Horace Parlan
Sessions. All of its Miles Davis/Columbia Records releases will be
on vinyl only, simultaneous with the CD release by Columbia. Several factors probably
contributed to Mosaic’s decision to reduce its LP releases. First,
slackening demand. Even LP loyalists find that the volume of music
contained in a Mosaic set is easier to handle and listen to on disc. The 5
CD Parlan set, for instance,
takes up 8 LPs. Second, LP sets are more expensive. Mosaic LPs are
pressed on 180 gram vinyl at $18.00 each. The CD version of the Parlan set
is $80.00, the LP version is $144.00. Third, production costs. Mosaic uses
separate analogue masters for its LPs, rather than the digital master. The
additional cost of mastering is probably not offset by the number of LP
sets sold. 2 It was not unusual for record producers to edit a performance in order to keep the length of an LP side under 20 minutes. When an LP side exceeds 20 minutes, the grooves begin to narrow, resulting in lower volume and less detail. The loss in detail was especially apparent with older styli, which were not as slim as today’s and, therefore, couldn’t make close contact with narrow record grooves. 3 The story doesn’t
end there. Columbia brought Cuscuna in to be executive producer of Miles Davis and Gil Evans: The
Complete Columbia Studio Recordings (Mosaic offers a
limited-edition version on 180-gram vinyl). Jazz historian and producer Phil
Schaap (those terms only begin to describe his contributions to jazz)
searched Columbia’s archives and found that there were, in fact, stereo
versions of the takes used on the original Miles Ahead. The version of Miles Ahead that is currently
available is in true stereo and has smoother editing than the original,
which had some rather abrupt tape splices. Avakian’s CD version also had
shifts from mono to stereo that were jarring, especially through
headphones (they were also never really explained). While Schapp’s version
may not be, strictly speaking, historically accurate, it sounds better.
Ideally, you should buy the current version on CD and find a mono pressing
of the original LP. |
Copyright © 1997 - 2001 Planet HiFi, Inc. All rights reserved.