EXCELLENT!

5 points each

GOOD

4 points each

FAIR

3 points each

NEEDS

IMPROVEMENT

2 points each

TRY AGAIN!

0 points

Reader’s Response (Mechanics)

Use of grammar, spelling, capitalization, and/or punctuation is correct throughout the entire piece

Few (1-2) errors in grammar, spelling, capitalization, and/or punctuation after feedback and editing

Some (3-4) errors in grammar, spelling,

capitalization, and/or punctuation after feedback and editing

Many (5+) errors in grammar, spelling, capitalization, and/or punctuation after feedback and editing

Careless errors in grammar, spelling, capitalization, and/or punctuation after feedback and editing

Research

Many resources (5 or more) were used

Some resources (3 to 4) were used

A small amount of resources (2)  were used

Not enough

resources were used   (only 1)

No resources (0) were used

Group Cooperation

Prepared and well organized. The ability to cooperate with all contributing

members was

demonstrated.

Some evidence of organization with some indication of cooperation with peers

Poorly organized, with uneven distribution of workload among group members

Little or no evidence of organization or little cooperation with group members

Lacks organization and no evidence of cooperation with group members

Brochure or PowerPoint Presentation

Persuasive and informative with nice use of graphics or visuals; also includes extra information

Reasonably attractive with moderate use of visuals; includes all required information

Not very attractive, is difficult to read and understand; some required facts are missing

Shows little effort, many required facts are not included;  and not enough graphics or visuals were used

Shows no effort, too few facts were included, with no graphics or visuals used