| Team | New York Muggers | Louisiana Fighting Lampreys | Bethel "Tushie" Bears | Monroe Money | Chicken Dicks | Brevard County Pirates |
| QB 1 | Carson Palmer - CIN | Jay Cutler - DEN | Peyton Manning - IND | Derek Anderson - CLE | Drew Brees - NO | Brett Favre – NYJ |
| QB 2 | Ben Roethlisberger – PIT | Chad Pennington – MIA | Jason Campbell - WAS | Kurt Warner - ARI | Jake Delhomme – CAR | Philip Rivers - SD |
| QB 3 | Gus Frerotte – MIN | Matt Ryan – ATL | Kyle Orton – CHI | Shaun Hill – SF | J.P. Losman – BUF | Jeff Garcia - TB |
| RB 1 | Steven Jackson - STL | Clinton Portis - WAS | Larry Johnson - KC | Matt Forte – CHI | Fred Taylor - JAX | Thomas Jones - NYJ |
| RB 2 | Willie Parker - PIT | Jerious Norwood - ATL | Julius Jones – SEA | Maurice Morris – SEA | Joseph Addai - IND | Maurice Jones-Drew - JAX |
| RB 3 | Mewelde Moore – PIT | Kevin Smith – DET | Darren McFadden – OAK | Peyton Hillis – DEN | Marion Barber III - DAL | Marshawn Lynch – BUF |
| RB 4 | Antonio Pittman – STL | Justin Fargas - OAK | Derrick Ward – NYG | Warrick Dunn – TB | Steve Slaton – HOU | Edgerrin James – ARI |
| WR 1 | Hines Ward - PIT | Andre Johnson - HOU | Laveranues Coles - NYJ | Santana Moss - WAS | Reggie Williams - JAC | Antonio Bryant – TB |
| WR 2 | Chad Johnson - CIN | Larry Fitzgerald - ARI | Chris Chambers - SD | Anquan Boldin - ARI | Reggie Brown - PHI | Vincent Jackson – SD |
| WR 3 | Lee Evans - BUF | Wes Welker - NE | T.J. Houshmandzadeh - CIN | Roddy White - ATL | Bobby Engram - SEA | Greg Camarillo – MIA |
| WR 4 | Donnie Avery – STL | Calvin Johnson - DET | Musin Muhammad – CAR | Josh Morgan – SF | Devin Thomas – WAS | Mark Bradley – KC |
| TE 1 | Jeremy Shockey – NO | John Carlson – SEA | Dallas Clark - IND | Chris Cooley - WAS | Bo Scaife - TEN | Alex Smith - TB |
| TE 2 | Tony Scheffler - DEN | Kevin Boss – NYG | Jason Witten - DAL | Robert Royal - BUF | Marcedes Lewis - JAX | Dante Rosario – CAR |
| TE 3 | Matt Spaeth – PIT | Visanthe Shiancoe – MIN | Martellus Bennett – DAL | Desmond Clark - CHI | Reggie Kelly - CIN | Billy Miller – NO |
| K 1 | Matt Prater – DEN | Shayne Graham - CIN | Neil Rackers – ARI | Jeff Reed - PIT | Phil Dawson - CLE | Rian Lindell – BUF |
| K 2 | Jay Feely – NYJ | Rob Bironas - TEN | John Carney – NYJ | Shaun Suisham – WAS | John Kasay – CAR | Joe Nedney – SF |
| DEF 1 | Chicago Bears | Carolina Panthers | Philadelphia Eagles | Minnesota Vikings | Cincinnati Bengals | San Diego Chargers |
| DEF 2 | Miami Dolphins | Pittsburgh Steelers | Washington Redskins | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | Cleveland Browns | Jacksonville Jaguars |
| CO 1 | Tom Coughlin - NYG | Brad Childress - MIN | Jeff Fisher - TEN | Jack del Rio - JAX | Andy Reid - PHI | Mike Shanahan - DEN |
| CO 2 | John Fox - CAR | John Harbaugh – BAL | Tony Sparano – MIA | Mike McCarthy - GB | Eric Mangini - NYJ | Dick Jauron - BUF |
| Team | Cajun Cannons | Carolina Camels | Psyracuse Psychos | Tusken Raiders | Baltimore Breeze | So Cal Earthquakes |
| QB 1 | Eli Manning - NYG | Matt Leinart - ARI | Donovan McNabb - PHI | Marc Bulger - STL | Tom Brady - NE | Tony Romo - DAL |
| QB 2 | Tyler Thigpen – KC | Aaron Rodgers – GB | Matt Hasslebeck - SEA | Trent Edwards – BUF | David Garrard – JAX | Matt Schaub - HOU |
| QB 3 | Chad Henne – MIA | Matt Cassel – NE | JaMarcus Russell - OAK | Joe Flacco – BAL | Brady Quinn - CLE | Sage Rosenfels – HOU |
| RB 1 | Jamal Lewis - CLE | Brian Westbrook - PHI | Ronnie Brown - MIA | Willis McGahee - BAL | Frank Gore - SF | Reggie Bush - NO |
| RB 2 | Michael Turner – ATL | LaDainian Tomlinson - SD | Jonathan Stewart – CAR | Adrian Peterson - MIN | Chris Johnson – TEN | Ryan Grant - GB |
| RB 3 | Felix Jones – DAL | Earnest Graham - TB | Cedric Benson – CIN | Rashard Mendenhall – PIT | Ryan Torain – DEN | Brandon Jacobs - NYG |
| RB 4 | LenDale White – TEN | Tim Hightower – ARI | BenJarvus Green-Ellis – NE | Ray Rice – BAL | Selvin Young – DEN | DeAngelo Williams – CAR |
| WR 1 | Terrell Owens - DAL | Torry Holt - STL | Marvin Harrison - IND | Roy Williams - DET | Steve Smith - CAR | Donald Driver - GB |
| WR 2 | Reggie Wayne - IND | Joey Galloway - TB | Plaxico Burress - NYG | Jerricho Cotchery – NYJ | Braylon Edwards - CLE | Marques Colston - NO |
| WR 3 | Dwayne Bowe - KC | Randy Moss - NE | Santonio Holmes - PIT | Steve Breaston – ARI | DeSean Jackson – PHI | Anthony Gonzalez - IND |
| WR 4 | Ted Ginn Jr. - MIA | Eddie Royal – DEN | Greg Jennings - GB | James Hardy – BUF | Bernard Berrian – MIN | Brandon Marshall - DEN |
| TE 1 | Tony Gonzalez - KC | Vernon Davis - SF | Heath Miller - PIT | Kellen Winslow Jr. - CLE | Greg Olsen - CHI | Owen Daniels - HOU |
| TE 2 | L.J. Smith - PHI | Anthony Fasano – MIA | Benjamin Watson - NE | Antonio Gates - SD | Todd Heap – BAL | Zach Miller - OAK |
| TE 3 | Dustin Keller – NYJ | Alge Crumpler – TEN | Daniel Graham – DEN | Fred Davis – WAS | Leonard Pope - ARI | Jacob Tamme – IND |
| K 1 | Jason Elam – ATL | Adam Vinatieri - IND | Nate Kaeding - SD | Stephen Gostkowski - NE | Robbie Gould - CHI | Mason Crosby - GB |
| K 2 | Ryan Longwell – MIN | Josh Scobee – JAX | Kris Brown - HOU | Nick Folk - DAL | Jason Hanson – DET | David Akers - PHI |
| DEF 1 | Dallas Cowboys | Baltimore Ravens | Green Bay Packers | Tennessee Titans | Indianapolis Colts | Seattle Seahawks |
| DEF 2 | New York Giants | New England Patriots | Oakland Raiders | San Francisco 49ers | New York Jets | Buffalo Bills |
| CO 1 | Sean Payton - NO | Tony Dungy - IND | Bill Belichick - NE | Jon Gruden - TB | Norv Turner - SD | Lovie Smith – CHI |
| CO 2 | Mike Tomlin - PIT | Wade Phillips - DAL | Romeo Crennel - CLE | Jim Zorn – WAS | Ken Whisenhunt – ARI | Mike Smith – ATL |