| Kevin | Josh | Alexei | Jeffrey | Marshall | Greg | Steven | Willie | |
| Keepers | Garciaparra, Nomar* | Brown, Kevin | Bonds, Barry | Halladay, Roy | Hinske, Eric | Guerrero, Vladimir | Martinez, Pedro | Boone, Bret |
| Keepers | Helton, Todd | Chavez, Eric | Rodriguez, Alex | Lopez, Javy | Mussina, Mike | Jeter, Derek& | Prior, Mark | Edmonds, Jim |
| Keepers | Hudson, Tim | Gagne, Eric | Soriano, Alfonso | Lowell, Mike | Pettitte, Andy | Jones, Andruw | Pujols, Albert | Morris, Matt |
| Keepers | Mulder, Mark | Lowe, Derek | Willis, Dontrelle | Rivera, Mariano | Ramirez, Manny | Loaiza, Esteban& | Schmidt, Jason | Sheffield, Gary |
| Keepers | Smoltz, John | Pierre, Juan | Wood, Kerry | Sosa, Sammy | Vizquel, Omar | Posada, Jorge | Wells, Vernon | Zito, Barry |
| 1 | Beltran, Carlos | Renteria, Edgar | Hoffman, Trevor | Vazquez, Javier | Weeks, Rickie | Delgado, Carlos | Schilling, Curt | Beckett, Josh |
| 2 | Ordonez, Magglio | Wilson, Preston | Thome, Jim | Kent, Jeff | Young, Delmon | Wagner, Billy | Tejada, Miguel | Anderson, Garrett |
| 3 | Rolen, Scott | Ortiz, Russ | Jones, Chipper | Giambi, Jason | Ramirez, Hanley | Oswalt, Roy | Blalock, Hank | Piazza, Mike |
| 4 | Johnson, Randy* | Hernandez, Livan | Glaus, Troy | Williams, Woody | Ellis, Mark | Colon, Bartolo& | Huff, Aubrey | Foulke, Keith |
| 5 | Webb, Brandon | Varitek, Jason | Rodriguez, Ivan | Guardado, Eddie | Crosby, Bobby | Suzuki, Ichiro | Sexson, Richie | Furcal, Rafael |
| 6 | Santana, Johan* | Castillo,Luis | Lilly, Ted | Gonzalez, Luis | Kerns, Austin | Giles, Marcus | Berkman, Lance | Sweeney, Mike |
| 7 | Vidro, Jose | Bagwell, Jeff | Abreu, Bobby | Cabrera, Orlando | Maddux, Greg | Miller, Wade | Dotel, Octavio | Clemens, Roger |
| 8 | Mauer, Joe | Lee, Carlos | Moyer, Jamie | Zambrano, Carlos | Guillen, Jose | Ramirez, Aramis | Isringhausen, Jason | Cabrera, Miguel |
| 9 | Percival, Troy | Giles, Brian | Millwood, Kevin | Nomo, Hideo | Harden, Rich | Borowski, Joe | Young, Michael | Wolf, Randy |
| 10 | Williams, Jerome | Pineiro, Joel | Damon, Jonny | Matsui, Hideki | Griffey, Ken Jr. | Hunter, Torii | Contreras, Jose | Garcia, Freddy |
| 11 | Nen, Robb | Lee, Derrick | Rhodes, Arthur | Redman, Mark | Hernandez, Ramon | Sabathia, C.C. | Kendall, Jason | Matsui, Kaz |
| 12 | Walker, Larry | Hidalgo, Richard | LoDuca, Paul | Mueller, Bill | Mondesi, Raul | Padilla, Vicente | Berroa, Angel | Young, Dimitri |
| 13 | Pierzynski, A.J. | Guzman, Christian | Nevin, Phil | Podsednik, Scott | Pie, Felix | Ponson, Sidney | Peavy, Jak | Urbina, Ugueth |
| 14 | Gonzalez, Juan | Mantei, Matt | Biddle, Rocky | Meche, Gil | Vega, Miguel | Walker, Todd | Crawford, Carl | Penny, Brad |
| 15 | Palmeiro, Rafael | Relaford, Desi | Encarnacion, Juan | Ortiz, David | Eckstein, David | Julio, Jorge | Reyes, Jose | Lofton, Kenny |
| 16 | Stewart, Shannon | Batista, Tony | Wells, David | Green, Shawn | Davis, Rajai | Lieberthal, Mike | Benitez, Armando | Baldelli, Rocco |
| 17 | Clement, Matt | Hawkins, Latroy | Hasegawi, Shigetoshi | Cintron, Alex | Shealy, Ryan | Teixeira, Mark | Ensberg, Morgan | Thomas, Frank |
| 18 | Hart, Bo | LeCroy, Matthew | Escobar, Kelvim | Franklin, Ryan | Sledge, Terrmel | Jones, Jacque | Armas, Tony Jr. | Worrell, Tim |
| 19 | Hillenbrand, Shea | Wells, Kip | Alomar, Roberto | Koch, Billy | Floyd, Cliff | Koskie, Cory | Philips, Jason | Myers, Greg |
| 20 | Klesko, Ryan* | Rodriguez, Francisco | Perez, Odalis | Spivey, Junior | Battle, Tim | Kim, Byung Hyun& | Nixon, Trot | Casey, Sean |
* to Greg via trade
& to Kevin via trade