| Batters | ||||
| Dawgs of War | 1B - Todd Helton | SS - Nomar Graciaparra | OF - Ichiro Suzuki | |
| koonzaholics | 1B - Albert Pujols | OF - Carlos Beltran | 1B - Richie Sexson | |
| Widow Maker | 1B - Jeff Bagwell | OF - Aubrey Huff | OF - Vlad Guerrero | |
| Ackworth Acks | OF - Barry Bonds | 1B - Jim Thome | 3B - Eric Chavez | |
| Sand Gnats | OF - Manny Ramirez | OF - Sammy Sosa | C - Ivan Rodriquez | |
| Oddballs | 2B - Alfonso Soriano | SS - Miguel Tejada | 1B - Raul Ibanez | |
| Tigers in the Series | SS - Derek Jeter | 3B - Scott Rolen | OF - Maggilo Ordonez | |
| San Pablo Mexicans | SS - Alex Rodriquez | |||
| Krasnei Macheena | 1B - Carlos Delgado | OF - Garrett Anderson | OF - Lance Berkman | |
| Bat Boy | OF - Juan Pierre | C - Jorge Posada | 2B - Jeff Kent | |
| DA New DetroitTigers | OF - Torri Hunter | C - Mike Piazza | ||
| Les Sexareenos | 2B - Bret Boone | SS - Edgar Renteria | OF - Preston Wilson | |
| Pitchers | ||||
| Dawgs of War | RP - Octavio Dotel | RP - Jason Isringhausen | SP - Roger Clemens | |
| koonzaholics | SP - Mike Mussina | SP - Barolo Colon | SP - Mark Mulder | |
| Widow Maker | RP - Eric Gagne | SP - Jason Schmidt | SP - Pedro Martinez | |
| Ackworth Acks | SP - Kerry Wood | RP - Keith Foulke | SP - Randy Johnson | |
| Sand Gnats | SP - Kevin Brown | RP - Troy Percival | SP - Barry Zito | |
| Oddballs | SP - Roy Halladay | RP - Jorge Julio | ||
| Tigers in the Series | SP - Curt Schilling | SP - Wade Miller | ||
| San Pablo Mexicans | SP - Tim Hudson | RP - Branden Looper | ||
| Krasnei Macheena | RP - Billy Wagner | SP - Matt Morris | ||
| Bat Boy | SP - Randy Wolf | SP - Kevin Millwood | SP - Brett Myers | |
| DA New DetroitTigers | SP - Mark Prior | SP - Javier Vasquez | ||
| Les Sexareenos | RP - Joe Borowski | SP - Russ Ortiz | SP - Woody Williams | |
| - Player is no longer on the team's roster | ||||