The album proved tough to follow up and despite critical acclaim her sophomore album More (2001) bombed debuting way beyond the Billboard Top 100. The album included the singles The Itch (2001) and As Long As Your Loving Me (2001). Colleen took a role in Wes Craven's Dracula (2001) and Get Over It (2001) as well as a small cameo in Scary Movie 2 (2001).
Colleen also took part in Celebrity Boot Camp (2002) as Vitamin C alongside fellow pop star and 80's icon Tiffany. She was last seen in summer 2003 with a new single Last Nite (2003) a cover of The Strokes Last Nite (2002) which sampled Blondie's Heart Of Glass (1979). It slumped at number 70 in the UK, it was also her UK debut. She also contributed a new song to The Lizzie McGuire Movie (2003) soundtrack a cover of the classic 50's hit Volare.
