Scary Faced Pizzas Items you will need: 1/2 English Muffin 1 Tablespoon pizza sauce 1 Tablespoon mozzarella cheese 1 olive 1 pepperoni 1 mushroom 1 tomato 1 pepper 1 onion Spilt the muffin in half. Cover half with pizza sauce and cheese. Decorate with tomato, onion, olive, pepperoni, mushroom and pepper. Bake in oven for 5 minutes or until cheese is melted.