Goblin Tongues On a night when everyone will get more than their fill of sweets, these mini bagel sandwiches will add a little variety to the offerings. Mini bagels Cream cheese Bologna slices 1. For each Goblin Tongue sandwich, spread cream cheese between the top and bottom of a mini bagel. 2. Use a butter knife or kitchen shears to cut a tongue shape from a half slice of bologna. Then gently press the base of the tongue into the bagel hole. Use your imagination and you could probably make this gross.