| ATHLETE | TIME | YEAR | GRADE | |
| 1. Josh Fisher | 16:23.7 | 1995 | Sr. | |
| 2. Andy Rickert | 16:43 | 1996 | Sr. | |
| 3. Jeff Brooks | 16:49.4 | 1995 | Sr. | |
| 4. Matt Denyse | 16:59.4 | 1995 | So. | |
| 5. Mike Poole | 17:32.2 | 1995 | Jr. | |
| 6. Devon Hinds | 17:51.2 | 1995 | Jr. | |
| 7. Bob Nuttall | 18:24 | 1996 | So. | |
| 8. Jay Gessler | 18:35 | 1995 | So. | |
| 9. Bill Bennett | 18:36 | 1996 | Sr. | |
| 10. Ryan Tastor | 18:40 | 1995 | Jr. | |
| 11. Isaac Nelson | 18:47 | 1995 | Jr. | |
| 12. Chris Gerard | 18:53.1 | 1995 | Jr. | |
| 13. Bobby Engels | 19:04 | 1996 | So. | |
| 14. Jon Nieman | 19:25 | 1995 | Jr. | |
| 15. Matt Bruce | 19:27 | 1996 | So. | |
| 16. Tyler Allen | 19:38.5 | 1996 | Sr. | |
| 17. Jim Harrington | 18:49.4 | 1995 | So. | |
| 18. Nick Viscio | 19:57 | 1996 | Jr. | |
| 19. Matt Ptak | 20:01 | 1996 | Sr. | |
| 20. Mike Hughes | 20:14.2 | 1995 | So. | |
| 21. Greg Basalla | 20:19.4 | 1995 | Fr. | |
| 22. Ali Khanshab | 20:32 | 1995 | Fr. | |
| 23. Chris Walsh | 20:43 | 1995 | Fr. | |
| 24. Matt Adiletta | 20:49 | 1996 | So. |
Note: Only 24 runners listed in 1996 booklet