Chapter 16
Spencer Residence
“Knock, knock!” Bobbie called out as she tentatively entered her brother's home, with Lucas guiding the way. She was carrying a large glass casserole dish and was glad to find the lights on, the tree lit, Lulu still in her pajamas looking up at them from the floor, surrounded by a pile of torn wrapping paper, a smile on her face.
Lucas immediately joined his cousin, handing over the gift bag with the stuffed animal poking its head out from within. He then sat down to inspect her loot of Christmas toys and to show off the handheld digital planner he'd received that morning.
“Bobbie!” Laura called out, rushing from the kitchen to relieve the dish from her hands. She took a quick pleasing whiff and smiled. “You shouldn't have,” she said, though she really was grateful.
Laura was having a hard time trying to put her constant worries on hold long enough to focus on the holiday meal. Her reserves of good cheer had been depleted earlier as she, Luke and Lulu exchanged gifts. Laura's gaze trailed to the packages still left unopened under the tree.
Bobbie reached into her jacket pocket, pulling out a small wrapped box and placing it with the others, attempting a bolstering smile, which seemed too melancholy to encourage real hope. Still, company might help distract them from the somber mood of the day.
“Well, I figured since you guys weren't going to be at the brownstone this year, we'd all come here.”
“All who?” Luke grumbled, coming down the stairs just as the front door opened again. He could do without a pity parade. He didn't need moral support, what he needed was a lead on Lucky. He needed to find his son and bring him home.
Carly bustled in, guiding Michael in front of her. The little boy was desperately trying to push his scarf down so he could see where he was going, but the mittens hindered his efforts.
For a moment Luke recalled Lucky at that age, already too wise for his years. His son had to grow up faster than most, thanks to the choices Luke had made. He hoped to god his boy wasn't still paying for his mistakes.
Michael lurched forward and Luke caught the kid before he tripped into the staircase. “Whoa! Who do we have here?” he teased, lifting Michael up off the ground like a sack of potatoes. “Can't quite tell under all the winter weather gear. Who's in there?”
“Geez, Luke, you're going to drop him!” Carly huffed, shedding her coat and tossing it over the banister, clearly not in the most playful mood.
“It's ME!” Michael squealed, though his voice was muffled by the woolen knit.
“Ah, okay,” Luke set him down and patted the boy's hooded head before Carly swooped in to unwrap her son.
Laura smiled at Luke's interaction, although it all still felt surreal to her. They were putting on a good performance. But underneath it all was still the uncertainty and dread - the unanswered questions to their son's latest disappearance.
Bobbie took off her winter coat and grabbed the dish from Laura, heading into the kitchen to lend a hand. Carly managed to free Michael from his cocoon, chasing after him to retrieve his wet shoes as he joined Lucas and Lulu by the tree. Luke turned to get the door, and found Jason standing there, fists shoved into the pockets of his leather jacket, looking uncertain, like he was about to turn around and head back to the car.
Luke gave him a nod and a smile, then held out his hand in greeting. “Jason, get in here,” he warmly insisted, holding the door open with his foot.
This was the absolute last place Jason wanted to be, but just when he and Carly finally showed up at the brownstone, Bobbie insisted on moving the Christmas festivities here.
Right now he wished he had stayed upstate with Lucky. As hard as it was to face what he walked in on that morning, it was a hundred times worse shaking the hand of the man whose son he'd been defiling, dominating, and fucking for months.
Jason's grip was cold and brief. Luke assumed it meant there was no new word on Lucky. Jason was obviously beating himself up for not finding him yet. “We'll talk later,” Luke determined, trying to put him at ease. “I appreciate everything you've done,” he added, giving Jason a light slap on the back as they stepped into the living room.
“Yeah,” Jason stammered, choking on the knowledge of what Luke would do if he really knew “everything” Jason had done to Lucky. He couldn't give Luke the reassurance he was looking for, the news that Lucky had been found and was safe and okay - as okay as he could be, considering. He couldn't give them any reassurance, until Lucky was ready to return on his own. He hung back, relieved when Luke joined Laura and Carly with the kids.
His attention was diverted from the cozy scene when the kitchen door swung open and someone else entered the room.
“Laura, Bobbie wants to know if you want the yams in now or if we should wait until the stuffing is out.”
Elizabeth Webber.
Jason wondered if there was still time to change his mind about being here.
Elizabeth glanced around the room, as if Lucky might be in attendance and no one had bothered to tell her yet. Jason avoided her gaze, catching the disappointment on her face before she disappeared into the kitchen again. He tried not to think about Lucky's feelings for her, what she meant to him. They never really talked about Elizabeth, just like they usually avoided talking about Carly. Some subjects were best left out of their conversations.
Actually, when they were together, talking wasn't a priority.
It was all about need, urgency, heat, lust, strength and control. His. Lucky's. A combination and culmination of their intense connection and mutual desire.
His thoughts suddenly flashed back to the beginning of their relationship - when things were uncertain and uncharted. Lucky's body was still new territory that Jason yearned to explore and conquer…
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
“So, what is this place?”
Lucky took in his surroundings while Jason remained by the door, pulling it shut.
There wasn't much to inspect. The secluded building was small, intimate. The inside was as nondescript as the outside, yet the room had an almost familiar feel to it.
It was perfect.
“Used to be a safe house,” Jason explained. “But it hasn't been used in years. It's a place where I can just...”
“Do whatever you want?” Lucky slowly turned to face Jason, his lips curling slyly. “Because you can, you know – whatever you want.”
Jason wasn't sure what the hell he wanted anymore, or what he intended to do, bringing Lucky up here. Actually, that wasn't really true. Jason knew. He just couldn't bring himself to admit it.
His eyes drifted around the place, avoiding Lucky's unrelenting gaze. “I come here sometimes, when I need to get away,” he confessed.
Lucky nodded, his eyes trailing to the bed. “You get away a lot?”
“Not lately,” Jason muttered, now lost in Lucky's determined, desirous eyes.
“Well, I have a feeling you'll be coming here - often.”
Jason would come to recognize that tone - classic, seductive Lucky. Confident, cocky, in control. Jason felt himself twitch in response to the flirtatious words and alluring half-smile.
Since that first encounter on the docks, they'd only had a few fast, furious fucks. But Lucky recognized the signs of Jason's arousal immediately - the darkening eyes, the hitch in his breathing, the slight flush to his cheeks, the growing bulge in his black jeans.
As thrilling as it had been to feel Jason take him quickly and feverishly, this was what Lucky had been waiting for. A place and time when they could take their time, where Lucky could show Jason exactly how much he could take. How long, how far, how deep, how often.
He let out his own involuntary growl, imagining the elaborate tortures this simple room would witness. He knew they had to start out slowly. Lucky couldn't push things. Jason was still testing himself. But he was confident he wouldn't have to wait long. Jason was a quick study.
He remembered their second time. Sonny and Jason had come to Luke's club on business. Lucky was there - having another blowout with his father. He stormed out, past Sonny, past Jason. The next thing he knew, he felt Jason's hand over his mouth, his hard-on against his back.
Jason had told Luke he'd try to find Lucky, calm him down. And maybe Jason had even been concerned about him. But as soon as he saw Lucky, other things became more important. More pressing. He'd proceeded to drag Lucky to the limo and fucked him senseless.
Oh, yeah, Jason knew how to exploit an opportunity. And Lucky knew how to exploit him.
Just as he'd predicted.
Perfect.
“So…” Jason awkwardly tried to establish some sort of command over the situation.
“Where do you want me?” Lucky cut in.
Everywhere, Jason sighed. But he couldn't seem to articulate anything as he felt Lucky approach.
“On the bed, the floor, the chair?” Lucky prompted.
Jason finally pushed Lucky down to his knees, rasping out more of a plea than a command. “On my cock.”
The floor it is, Lucky smiled to himself as he assumed the familiar position. He jerked Jason's zipper down roughly, reaching in and grabbing Jason's throbbing dick. He took it in his mouth, swirling his tongue around the head, lapping at the tiny beads of pre-cum, teasing and tonguing the tip as he lightly stroked Jason's length with his hand. After just a few frustrating moments, Jason grabbed Lucky's head and forced it down.
“Suck it, now! All of it!” he demanded, pushing himself further into Lucky's throat.
Lucky felt his own hard-on burn as Jason took exactly what he wanted. He sucked and licked Jason's long, thick shaft, meeting each thrust, matching every moan.
There was no need to worry about interruption or discovery, and Jason reveled in the opportunity to cry out in desire, shout out his needs.
“Fuck, yeah, don't stop, keep going, Lucky. Harder, faster, come on!” Jason ordered. He wanted his cock as far down Lucky's throat as he could take it. He was consumed by the desire to mark every inch of Lucky, inside and out. To claim him. To possess him.
Lucky struggled for air as Jason fucked his mouth completely, mercilessly. Not knowing how long Jason could maintain this pace and needing to breathe, Lucky surprised Jason, running his finger from Jason's heavy balls to his ass, pressing into that sweet spot.
Jason gasped and exploded immediately, flooding Lucky's mouth with hot spurts of cum. He struggled to remain standing as his orgasm subsided. Lucky drank it all in, swallowing Jason's full load.
As Jason withdrew his dick, Lucky started to clean him off, lapping at the sticky fluid on Jason's thighs. But Jason pushed his head away and roughly pulled Lucky to his feet.
“Why did you do that?”
“What?”
“You fucking know what. Did I tell you to make me come?”
“I thought that was the whole point,” Lucky drawled.
Jason seemed to have lost his sense of humor, but not his erection, Lucky noted. He was pleased that Jason had been annoyed by the power play, and he was even more turned-on as Jason finally took command, throwing him down on the bed.
“Take off your pants,” Jason ordered. He tried to suppress his sigh of desire as Lucky shed his jeans, revealing the perfect ass and enticing cock that Jason spent most of his nights, and days, fantasizing about.
But Jason couldn't hide it. He wanted Lucky. And Lucky knew it. He didn't know why or how, but in the space of a few weeks, this game, this dance, this body, had become Jason's obsession. He had to have it. To have him. He wanted it. He needed it. And he would take it.
He just had to prove it - to Lucky and to himself.
With one long, powerful thrust into Lucky's tight hole, Jason began to do just that, drilling him.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
“Deep?”
Raising his gaze, Jason met Luke's curious expression. Visions of the past quickly dissolved as he stared up at Lucky's father. “What?”
“Your thoughts.”
“Oh…yeah…right,” Jason muttered as Luke sank into the chair beside him, setting his glass of whiskey on the table. Jason had half an urge to grab the drink and down it himself.
The kids were playing in the middle of the floor, and Michael had a green bow stuck to his bottom. Carly had her digital camera out of her purse, snapping picture after picture to capture the moment for future embarrassment.
Jason was trying to keep his eyes off the time. Laura poked her head out of the kitchen, flooding the living room with mouthwatering aromas. “Dinner's almost…”
Her eyes went wide and her hand flew up to cover her mouth. Luke turned to follow her gaze, as did everyone else in the room.
There'd been no knock, nothing alerting them of his presence. He just stood there patiently observing, waiting for them to welcome him home.
“Lucky!” Laura finally cried out, overcoming her shock before anyone else had a chance. In an instant she had her son in her arms, holding him as tight as she could.
Even under the padding of his heavy winter coat, the strong embrace reminded Lucky that his body still hadn't completely healed. He squirmed slightly and his mother withdrew to get a better look at him, her eyes spilling over with tears, thankful laughter escaping her smile as she touched his face.
Lucky felt his own eyes cloud, and a pang of guilt clutched at his throat. He should have called and ended her worries days ago. His mother hugged him again, her grip gentler this time, and then his father was there, drawing them both to him.
From across the room, Jason watched as Lucky abruptly pulled away from the embrace. He caught the troubled look on Luke's face as Lucky turned his attention to his sister, who raced over to greet him.
Lulu’s excited squeal drew laughter and tears from Laura as she watched them hug. Lucky released a laughing groan, feigning injury as Lulu squeezed him, but Jason could tell by the purse of his lips that he wasn't entirely faking the pain.
Carly was still snapping pictures of the homecoming as Jason moved closer to the crowd. Bobbie replaced Lulu, welcoming her nephew with a light hug and rubbing his back as she whispered something scolding in his ear, to which he nodded and chuckled softly.
Once his aunt stepped aside, Lucky's lips curled into a shy smile. Jason recalled some of the smiles Lucky had dazzled him with in the past. Playful smirks. Seductive, come-hither grins. Breathless, fucked-sore, gloating, toothy flashes. And dreamy, sated, orgasmic beams. But this was one he hadn't seen before. This was something special.
Something only Elizabeth could kindle.
She seemed to bask in the moment before relief and joy, laughter and tears broke through all at once. “God, Lucky, I was…we were all so worried,” she breathed, wrapping her arms around him.
Lucky closed his eyes for a moment as she hugged him. Jason wanted to close his as well, but before he had the chance, Lucky's blue gaze found him, from over Elizabeth's shoulder. It was just a brief glimpse, and it was gone before Jason could read it, but it left him feeling calmer than he had a second ago.
Lucky was reassuring everyone with his mere presence. The tension was seeping out of the room. He was smiling and greeting everyone, as if he'd just returned from a long vacation. He appeared relaxed and at ease. Jason was stunned at how well Lucky could hold it all in and cover up the pain.
He was an amazing liar.
Lucky turned toward the flash of a camera, finding his cousin standing there with a chagrined look on her face. “Carly,” he smiled warmly as his mouth went dry and Jason squirmed in the background. Lucky hadn't expected to run into her - them - Jason's family. He wasn't sure what he had hoped to find coming here. “So, are you the family paparazzo now?”
Carly held up the digital and smiled. “Jason gave it to me, for Christmas.”
“Nice,” Lucky nodded, trying to sound sincere while his brain swallowed the disparity. A camera. Jason gave his wife a digital camera and built him an entire fucking house? How was he not supposed to feel indebted after that? Owned? There was no way he was accepting it. He had told Jason that, and he meant it. And yet he let his hand brush over the outline of the gold key in his pants pocket. He should never have taken it with him. He’d give it back to Jason as soon as he had the chance.
“Lucky, where were you?”
It was Lulu who finally voiced the question on everyone's mind.
Jason tensed, watching Lucky pause, all eyes on him. Despite the pain of Lucky's indiscretion and their heated exchange that morning, Jason wished he could spare Lucky from this.
Then suddenly that charming smile returned to Lucky's face. He focused on his little sister's curious gaze. She was still worth shielding. For all the reasons he had to hate Nikolas, at least his love for their sister had saved her from Helena's grasp. Lucky would see she stayed that way, untainted by their war.
“I was out trying to track down the perfect Christmas present,” he bluffed. “I wanted to get a real gift – not some boring item from the mall. This had to be special. So I traveled all over. It took a while, but I finally found something that no one else would think to get you.”
Lulu looked skeptical, but there was a flicker of excitement in her eyes, sparked by Lucky's own enthusiastic telling of his tale. “What?”
“You know, it's the darnedest thing,” he sighed. “The airline, they lost my luggage. I had this huge…” he spread his arms wide, “huge suitcase. And it had all these stickers all over it, so they'd be extra careful with your perfect present. Bet you're wondering what I had in there for you, huh?”
By this time everyone in the room seemed entranced. Jason envied them. Instead his mind flashed to Lucky being hauled out of a garbage can, unconscious, broken, bleeding.
“Well, I can tell you this,” Lucky glanced around secretively, then leaned in closer to Lulu. “I think it got away on its own. And after all the trouble I went to. But somewhere out there is a kangaroo hopping around wearing a nice high-quality suitcase marked 'fragile - this end up.'“
Lulu stared at him for a moment, then rolled her eyes and let out a heavy groan. “You don't expect me to believe that, do you?” Lucky smirked at her exasperated expression then winced at her follow-up. “You know, Lucky, I'm not a baby anymore.”
Lucky swallowed hard, caught between sorrow and resentment at having missed out on all those years with his not-a-baby-anymore sister. But he had to admire her tenacious claim of maturity. He'd always hated it when people treated him like a kid.
Lulu caught the lost look on her brother's face and felt bad for saying that, for reminding him that she grew up while he was away. Unconsciously, her fingers rose to her neck to play with the gold locket that she had received that morning.
“Sorry, kiddo. I forget sometimes. Just keep reminding me - I'll get it right.” Lucky reached out to admire the necklace. “Guess I should have gone with something like this instead, huh?”
“It opens,” Lulu beamed, showing him her treasure.
Inside was a picture of Nikolas looking back at him, as smug as ever. Lucky clicked the locket shut with a pained, apologetic smile. “I didn't have time to get you anything,” he finally admitted. “But I'll make it up to you, I promise.”
“You don't have to get me anything, Lucky,” she said sincerely, innocently. “Having you come back was the only thing I asked Santa for.” Lulu smiled and hugged him again, and Lucky swallowed back the lump in his throat. The entire room seemed to be holding its collective breath as Lucky returned the hug.
“So you're not too old to write to Santa, I guess?” Lucky teased, drawing another exasperated sigh from his baby sister, then a wide grin and another hug.
A hand settled on Lucky's shoulder, giving a gentle squeeze as Lulu pulled away.
Luke cleared his throat, and nodded to his daughter. “Why don't you take Lucas and Michael upstairs to play until dinner's ready,” he suggested, though his tone was insistent. He turned to Carly before she could object. “You just stay where you are. They'll be fine,” he declared. “We've got fire extinguishers up there, what could be safer?”
Lulu sighed and collected her cousins, leading the way up the stairs. Lucky could hear Michael asking if they were going to see the kangaroo. He made a move toward the staircase, but his father's grip tightened, turning him back toward the living room.
Lucky shook him off, his expression quickly changing from relaxed to riled, anticipating a confrontation. “Oh, you want me to stay, with the grown-ups? I figured you were sending all the kids out of the room.”
“When have I ever treated you like a kid?” Luke demanded, frustrated and saddened, and alarmed, by Lucky's defensive attitude.
“I could use some help in the kitchen…” Bobbie interrupted, trying to diffuse the situation. But no one took her up on the ploy, so she remained as well.
“We need some answers, Lucky. Are you okay?”
“I’m fine,” Lucky answered Luke’s dubious stare.
“Then where have you really been?” Luke's tone was serious and filled with concern. “And don't give me that bull about Australia. No way you spent the last month trekking across the outback, and if you did, why didn’t you call? Hell, even the aborigines have cell phones these days.”
“Maybe I'm just inconsiderate and thoughtless. You know, like you. How many times have you left without telling anyone where you were going, when – or if – you’d be back?” he glared accusingly. Luke stepped back, as if slapped. “Don’t like it?” Lucky pressed. “Where do you think I learned it?”
“If you have something to say, Lucky, I wish you’d just say it. You need to get this out, so we can get past this, move on.”
“Just like that? It’s always so easy for you, isn’t it, Dad?” Lucky spat.
Luke noted the bitterness in Lucky's tone, the angry glint in his eyes. "None of this is easy, Cowboy."
"Yeah, I know. And that's why I went away. So you wouldn’t have to deal with it."
Luke didn't buy that for a second. “Funny how you and Helena decided to disappear around the same time."
“Lots of people like to get away for the holidays, escape the family melodramas for a while,” Lucky intoned.
“Lucky,” Laura interrupted, hoping to ease the tension. “We're just worried about you. It's not like you to just vanish without a word.”
“Oh come on, Mom. It’s what I do best.”
“That's Helena's bag of tricks, boy, certainly not yours,” Luke seethed.
“You'd be surprised how much a guy can pick up in three or four years,” Lucky shot back.
“Why the hell are you doing this?” Luke began to lose his patience. “Just tell me - what did she do this time?”
Lucky's jaw clenched, accentuating his furious expression. He spun around, facing Luke head on. His anger finally boiled over, and he erupted. “What's with the sudden interest, Dad? You never asked for the details the last time. What do you care? As long as she keeps returning me alive and in one piece, your conscience is clear, right?”
Luke looked shaken by the outburst and the confirmation it contained. He took another step back and Lucky flew past him, storming out of the house.
Jason instinctively moved to follow, but caught himself. He wanted more than anything to go after Lucky, comfort and calm him. Get him the fuck out of here. After everything he'd been through, the last thing Lucky needed to come home to was an interrogation.
But all Jason could do was sit there. Powerless. Frustrated. Angry. Carly plopped down next to him, and he recoiled. “Man, what is with you, today?” she whined. “You'd think you were the one abducted by aliens.”
“Helena Cassadine, Carly. Not aliens.”
“Whatever,” she retorted weakly. “I knew we shouldn't have come here.”
Jason looked at her incredulously. Carly was the one who had insisted they go to Bobbie’s. He’d wanted to stay home, lock out the world, forget this whole day had even happened. But Carly forced him to go to Bobbie's, and then Bobbie had forced them to come here. “I thought you wanted to be with your family.”
“I did,” she conceded. “I just forgot that they’re all insane.”
“Carly, we need your help in the kitchen,” Bobbie called, as if on cue.
Carly sighed and rolled her eyes as she got up, though Jason didn't seem to notice. His attention was focused on the porch, on her volatile cousin. She should have been relieved not to be the center of the family drama for once, but Carly had an uneasy feeling as she headed off to the kitchen. She whispered to Jason not to worry about Lucky, but she wasn't sure he heard.
Front Porch
Lucky paced back and forth, oblivious to the cold blasts of air swirling around him. Anger and resentment and frustration mounted. He had to get out of here. If he stayed one minute longer, he was going to do something crazy. Scream or break something. Or better yet, go back in there and grab Jason by the collar, kiss him breathlessly then fuck his brains out on the living room floor. Right under the tree.
He chuckled, imagining the looks on their faces, watching him grope and grapple with his cousin-in-law. Boy, would that shut Luke up. Show him that Lucky didn't need his protection or his love or his concern. He had Jason now.
Except you don't have him, Lucky reminded himself. You lost him this morning. Threw him away for a quick fuck with the security guard, remember?
Okay, so Jason wasn’t his best option right now. Maybe he could find Zander - finish what they had started last night.
But that wasn't what Lucky wanted, either. He needed something rougher, something sharp and stinging. He wanted to be chained down, spread wide, tortured and toyed with, and then fucked until his emotional pain became overpowering physical agony. The only Christmas present he truly deserved.
He was halfway down the stairs when he heard the quiet plea.
“Lucky, don't go.”
He couldn't turn around, couldn't face her. But he didn’t leave.
“I know that was awful for you, and you probably want to get out of here, but it’s just…I never thought I'd celebrate another Christmas with you, Lucky, and I need…I mean, we all need…” she sighed, struggling to find the right thing to say. “I know it's selfish, Lucky, but can you please stay?”
“Elizabeth,” he whispered, finally turning to her.
He was chastened by the pain and confusion in her eyes. After all this time, he still couldn't seem to stop hurting her. “I'm sorry,” he breathed, returning to the porch. He saw her shiver in the cold, trying to regain her composure. “Here. Put this on,” he insisted, removing his jacket. “You're going to freeze out here.”
“And you're not?”
“Don't argue with me.”
“How about a compromise?” she relented, threading her arm through one sleeve in the jacket, holding the other one out for Lucky.
“We're sharing?” he asked dubiously. Elizabeth's emphatic nod convinced him, and he slipped one arm around Elizabeth and the other in the jacket.
“Big enough for two,” she declared. The coat actually was, in fact, too big for Lucky. “I guess you didn’t get to pick it out,” she gathered. She was surprised Helena didn’t know his jacket size by now.
Lucky looked out at the driveway again and tried to pull away, but Elizabeth held onto him.
“Don't, Lucky, please. I'm sorry - I won't ask any questions. You don't have to tell me anything you don't want to. I just…”
“What?”
“I'm happy you're home, that's all.”
He looked down at her open, honest gaze, and smiled that same smile Jason had noted earlier. It sent a shiver through Elizabeth, and Lucky drew her closer.
“It's too cold - you should go inside.”
“It's gone again,” she noted wistfully.
“What?”
“That look.”
“What look?”
“Whenever you look at me, for a brief second, you get this expression on your face. I don't know how to describe it. It's almost like…”
“Like what?”
“Forget it. It's silly.”
“No, tell me, please. I want to know.”
Elizabeth blushed a little. “I don’t mean to sound vain, but sometimes when you look at me, your eyes light up, and for a moment, it's almost like the way we were, you know, before...”
“Before the fire?”
“Yeah,” she said softly, regretting it immediately when she saw Lucky's eyes turn cloudy. “Lucky, I'm sorry. I didn’t mean to bring up the past. I know things aren’t the same with us. I'm not trying to make you remember. I guess I was just surprised to see that look again.”
“You don't have to do anything to make me remember, Elizabeth,” he corrected her. “I haven’t forgotten. For so long, I thought I'd never see you again. All I could do was imagine what it would be like. I lived inside those memories for as long as I could. But life went on – things changed. I have new memories now, and as hard as I try, I can’t forget those either. Or maybe I just don’t want to.”
“I shouldn't have said anything.”
“Don't,” Lucky shook his head, dismissing her guilt. “I want to explain. I don't want you to think I'm trying to hurt you, playing some sort of mind game.”
“I would never think that, Lucky.”
“When I see you…” he paused, trying for the right words to explain this, even though he wasn't sure he fully understood it himself. He started again. “Your face, the memory of you, the hope that I'd see you again - for so long, that was the only thing that kept me going. So sometimes when I look up and you’re actually here with me, I don't think my brain can quite believe it. No matter how many times I see you, Elizabeth, it's always going to be like a miracle to me.”
Elizabeth's eyes filled with tears as she listened to Lucky's declaration. He hardly ever talked about his time in captivity. It moved her to hear his memories, the hopes he once had. The love that once saw him through.
“Seeing you is my proof that I survived.”
“But…” she prompted knowingly.
“But it’s also a reminder that I’m not who I was before the fire. I’m not even the same guy who dreamt of you night after night. I couldn’t bring him back with me. He didn’t survive.”
Elizabeth winced at the blunt declaration. But she knew Lucky was right. Those fleeting moments between them were just lingering memories and unfulfilled hopes. For whatever reason, he had stopped wishing for a future with her. Watching him over the past year, and just now with Luke, she wondered if Lucky could envision a future with anyone.
She wondered if one day he’d just give up on any kind of future at all. Maybe that was Helena’s ultimate revenge: not to take Lucky away from Luke, but to drive him so close to the edge that Lucky would jump on his own, and no one would be able to pull him back.
That thought made her even sadder and she couldn’t hold back the tears that spilled down her cheeks.
“I’m so sorry, Elizabeth. I never wanted to hurt you,” Lucky repeated. He pulled his arm out of the jacket, away from Elizabeth’s grasp and walked to the railing, leaning over the porch. “I should never have come here today. Hell, I should never have come back at all.”
“Lucky, don’t say that!”
“Why not, Elizabeth? It’s the truth. I don’t belong here anymore. All I do is make people tense or unhappy.” He ran his hand over his side. “Unsafe.”
“Lucky, none of this is your fault.”
Lucky released a bitter laugh, continuing to stare out into the distance.
“It’s true, Lucky. I know you feel responsible, but you aren’t. This war began before you were even born.”
“And continued even after I died,” he noted sarcastically. He felt another pang of guilt when he heard Elizabeth sigh.
“I’m sorry…” he began to apologize again, turning around. But Elizabeth silenced him, placing a finger to his lips.
“You don’t have to keep apologizing, Lucky. You don’t owe me anything…”
“That’s not true,” he objected. “I promised you everything, and I’ve given you nothing. Not even a fucking Christmas present.”
“God, Lucky, you gave me everything. You gave up your life for me, to keep me safe. And then, when you came back, even though I know you didn’t want to, you tried to make it work with us.”
Lucky groaned and turned away again, remembering those first few months after his return. How eager Elizabeth, and everyone else, was for things to go back to the way they were. How hard it was to play the happy resurrected hero in public. It was impossible in private.
Elizabeth had tried everything she could – patience, seduction, guilt, anger, jealousy. But nothing worked. She couldn’t get Lucky to open up to her, to confide in her. To even touch her.
She shivered at the same rush of memories. Sometimes, if she cried hard enough or if Lucky was completely exhausted, she’d been able to persuade Lucky to sleep with her. Not to make love. He refused that, always.
But he couldn’t deny her any contact, any comfort. And he needed it, too. Even if he started out every night on the other side of the bed, by morning, he was in her arms. Sometimes he would even kiss her, and she got to feel the thrill and the joy of his lips on hers. She treasured those moments, and tried to prolong them. She’d wake up at dawn and watch him, thankful for whatever respite sleep afforded him. She knew it wasn’t much – he tossed and turned and trembled more often than he was at rest. And as soon as he awoke, he’d pull away, scanning his surroundings to ensure himself that he was safe. That he was home.
Except that he never really seemed to believe that. And she could never convince him.
As the months went by, Lucky stopped coming to her bed at night. Eventually, he stopped coming home at all. Elizabeth had some inkling of the traumas Lucky had suffered. And she had some idea of where he went at night to exorcise his demons. Or to embrace them. But she had never figured out how to talk to him about it.
“Lucky, look at me.” He shook his head. “Please.”
Slowly, he turned around again.
“I know you want me to, but I don’t blame you for what happened. I know you wanted to love me, that you tried. That a part of you still does, even if you can’t admit it. That you are struggling to figure out who you are, what you want.”
Lucky looked up at her in amazement that she could still read him so well, that she could still care, after the way he’d treated her.
“I know you want to come to terms with the past, and I hope you can find some comfort, some peace.” Elizabeth’s tone was urgent and sincere, and Lucky felt himself surrender to it. She smiled, and moved closer to him, opening the jacket and pulling him closer, trying to warm his body and ease his mind.
“One of the things you are going to have to accept, Lucky, is that I loved you once, and you loved me. We are a part of each other. It didn’t end up the way either one of us wanted it to, but that doesn’t diminish what it was,” she said softly but firmly. “Do you hear me?” Lucky nodded. “Do you believe me?”
“Yes,” he whispered.
“Good! Then don’t say that you shouldn’t have come back. I never want to hear you say that again. Your coming back was a miracle, Lucky. For me, for your parents, your family, your friends. Let it be one for you, too. Let us help you. Please.”
Lucky allowed Elizabeth’s soothing words and gentle touch wash over him. He closed his eyes and leaned into her, kissing her forehead, drinking in the feel of her. He knew it was wrong, but he couldn’t deny himself this small comfort. So he accepted it, and lingered there.
Maybe the day could be salvaged after all.
Inside
The children were upstairs, again, eager to get back to the day’s real goodies. The adults were finishing up with coffee and dessert. Dinner had proceeded uneventfully, if a bit awkwardly. It wasn’t the usual raucous Spencer celebration. The joy of the day, especially of Lucky’s homecoming, was tempered by the palpable tension between father and son.
Squeezed between Carly and Michael, and across the table from the watchful gaze of his mother-in-law, Jason had only caught Lucky’s eye a few times during the meal. His expression was almost completely unreadable. Jason couldn’t tell if Lucky was still angry and hurt from their morning encounter, or if he even cared at all anymore.
Jason barely touched his own plate. He was too busy wondering if anyone else noticed the way Lucky could be so sexy simply eating a mouthful of stuffing or a slice of pie. Did the others notice the way his tongue darted out, catching the small drop of vanilla ice cream then swirling it in his mouth. Was this a show just for him, or was Jason just so hard for Lucky now that any motion or movement he made reminded Jason of something else – Lucky on his knees, Lucky on his back, Lucky spread wide, taking him, licking, sucking, slurping, swallowing…
Carly’s sudden sharp gasp snapped Jason out of his reverie. “What are you doing?” she whined, wiping at the whipped cream he had spooned all over her skirt, and not his plate. “What the hell is wrong with you today?”
Hoping no one else noticed Lucky’s sly, tantalizing lick of his lips, Jason tried to help a muttering Carly clean off the offending white stain.
“Hey, Caroline, it’s Christmas. Watch the goddamned swearing,” Luke smirked.
Carly just rolled her eyes. She wanted to get up, go home and get out of this outfit, out of this “celebration.” But Michael, god bless him, was having an obliviously merry time, and she didn’t have the heart to spoil it for him.
“Luke,” Laura eyed him warningly.
“All right, darlin’. I’ll be good.”
“Right,” Carly and Lucky simultaneously sneered. Jason cringed at the conspiratorial smile Carly flashed. Lucky tried his best to ignore it. Just a little while longer, and he could get out of here, and then it would be to all a good night.
“Lucky, honey, we have a surprise for you,” Laura beamed as she served him another huge slice of pie.
Lucky was completely full, and his stomach lurched at Laura’s unexpected words. He didn’t want any more pie, or surprise gifts. Not today. Not ever.
“Come on, aren’t you curious?” Luke pressed.
Jason shook his head. For people who claimed to know Lucky so well, Luke and Laura didn’t seem to have a clue. It was obvious that Lucky didn’t need this now. ‘Right – you’re the only one who really knows him.’ If that were true, he would have expected the surprise he walked in on that morning. Jason let out an unmistakable sigh, drawing stares from the table, and an outright glare from Carly, who couldn’t figure out what was wrong with her usually stoic husband.
“Okay, fine,” Lucky relented. Might as well get this over with. And give Jason a few minutes to get his act together. Lucky was trying not to think about what it meant that Jason seemed to be having so much trouble tolerating even the simplest family interaction today. “What’s the big surprise?”
Laura was disheartened by Lucky’s complete lack of enthusiasm, but she didn’t let it show. She wanted this to work out. “Your father and I, and Lulu, want you to move back in here…”
“No way,” Lucky immediately cut in.
“Wait, Lucky, let me finish,” Laura insisted. She knew it would be a hard sell, but she also believed it was the best thing, for all of them. “We fixed up your old room – new paint, new furniture, new everything.”
“No kidding? Kind of had to do that, though, since Dad threw all my old stuff away.”
“Lucky, don’t be spiteful,” Bobbie chastised.
Lucky shook his head. “Jumping in to censure the truth. Some things never change,” he muttered.
“She does that to you, too?” Carly sympathized. “I’m so glad it’s not just me.”
“You’re not helping, Carly,” Bobbie reproved.
“You think you are?” Carly snapped back. “It’s obvious Lucky needs some space. Why don’t you all just back off?”
“Since when do you know anything about what my son needs?” Luke blasted. “Why don’t you stay out of this. It doesn’t concern you.”
“Then maybe you shouldn’t bring it up at the dinner table,” Jason jumped to Carly’s defense. Luke was right – Carly had no idea what Lucky needed. But Jason just wanted them to stop talking about it. Actually, he wouldn't have minded if everyone just shut up completely.
“Suddenly I’m getting etiquette lessons from the mobster and his moll,” Luke drawled.
So much for that hope, Jason mused.
“Luke, please,” Laura implored. “Let’s get back to the matter at hand.”
“As enjoyable as this little family squabble has been, there’s nothing to get back to,” Lucky declared. This visit had been a complete disaster. It was time to end it, before he did something irrevocable. Elizabeth tried to squeeze his hand for moral support, but he shook her off and stood up. “It’s been almost five years since I lived here. I’m certainly not coming back now.”
“Yes, it has been almost five years,” Luke agreed, standing up and confronting Lucky head-on, finally. He hated resorting to these tactics, but he had nothing left to lose. He had to make Lucky see reason. “It’s also been five years since you were safe.”
Lucky swallowed hard. Direct hit. But Luke had no idea who he was playing with anymore.
“I haven’t been safe a single day in my entire life. Canadian diner, Port Charles living room, Greek island prison cell. It’s all the same, Dad. My life for your sins. And there might not be anything I can do to stop it. But I sure as hell don’t have to live under your roof and wait for it.”
Luke’s eyes darkened, and he clenched his fists to keep from just grabbing Lucky and shaking some sense into him. The entire room was silent as Lucky watched the full range of emotions flash in his father’s eyes – anger, confusion, sadness, guilt. He refused to let Luke see the same feelings in his eyes, which blazed only with fury.
“Lucky, please,” Laura tried again. Lucky hated making his mother cry, but her tears no longer moved him the way they once did.
“I’m sorry, Mom. I know you think I can move back here and everything will go back to the way it used to be, but that’s just never going to happen. The sooner you accept it, the better off we’ll all be.”
“But what will you do? Where will you go?”
“Back to my place.”
“It’s not safe there, honey.”
“It’s not safe anywhere,” Lucky stated plainly. His resigned tone frightened Laura.
“But Lucky, Helena didn’t have any trouble taking you from there…”
“I wasn’t at home when she kidnapped me.”
“Well, where the hell were you?” Luke snapped. Jason cringed, wondering if Lucky would be so angry, he’d actually answer that question. But Luke’s next blast overshadowed the first question. “And why weren’t you more careful?”
“Luke!”
“It’s okay, Mom. I know Dad blames me for this. After all, he taught me everything he knew, and still, I’ve been kidnapped not once, but twice. How could I be so stupid, so careless? That’s what you really think, isn’t it, Dad? You can admit it. I know it’s true.”
“Don’t put words into my mouth, Lucky.”
“Why not? It’s the only way to get them there. I know it eats at you. Am I really the son you raised? Falling victim to Helena one more time. Maybe once you could excuse. I was young, just a kid. But then I stayed all those years; I never got away. And then she nabs me again after I’ve been back less than a year? Didn’t I learn anything from you?”
Luke couldn’t even look at Lucky as he continued the withering assault.
“Or maybe there’s something else going on. Maybe I actually wanted to be there. Isn’t that what keeps you up at night, Dad? Just like with Mom. You say you blame yourself, but the truth is – you blame us. You blamed Mom all those years ago. And you blame me now.”
“Lucky, stop that!” Laura demanded, her tears flowing freely. Luke fumed silently, at a loss as to where Lucky’s venom was coming from.
“Why? It’s the truth, Mom. You know it, even if you’ve never been able to say it out loud.”
“Lucky, please,” Elizabeth went to him. “Let’s just go. Let me take you home.”
“No, no, no,” Laura insisted. She refused to let Lucky go off unprotected. Even if he hated it, at least here, they could keep him safe. Or at least she could reassure herself with his presence. “I want you to stay here. This is your home. You can hate us, Lucky, but we are still your family. We want what’s best for you.”
“And what about Lulu?”
“What about her?”
“You really think this is what’s best for her? Living with this tension, not to mention the constant threat of Helena just waiting to take me one more time.”
“I can take care of my children,” Luke blustered. It sounded pathetic, even to him.
“Take care of Lulu, Dad. She needs you. I don’t. I don’t need any of this.”
Lucky remained defiant. Luke and Laura looked utterly defeated. Elizabeth sank down in her seat, feeling empty and sad. Jason quietly seethed, frustrated by his utter lack of control over this situation. On the second floor, Lucas, Lulu and Michael crouched at the top of the stairs, curious and concerned by all the raised voices.
"If you want him safe and protected, I know just the right place," Carly casually announced, breaking the unbearable silence. Everyone turned to her with dubious expressions. "Jason's still leasing the penthouse next door. It's completely empty. Lucky can move in across the hall from us."
Lucky stared at his cousin like she was insane. But she wasn't insane, just clueless. There was no way Jason would allow this. Even if they could get past the morning fallout, he knew Jason needed that separation between their relationship and his family. "I don't think so…”
"Now hold on a minute, Lucky," Luke mulled it over. "Maybe sweet Caroline's right, for a change. A place like that would be more of a challenge for Helena. And a hell of a lot safer for you with Jason there to watch your ass..."
Jason clanged his coffee cup against the pie plate as he picked it up and took a sip, trying to camouflage his discomfort.
“What if I don’t want him watching my ass?” Lucky challenged.
Jason couldn’t tell if Lucky was serious or smirking. He met Lucky’s blue gaze, recognizing the desire and the defensiveness raging there. It was a combination he could never resist.
“Too bad,” Jason announced authoritatively. “I think it’s perfect.”