ETHICS HOME PAGE                             SLC HOME                                     HELP

        
Private health gets push by Harris
But services must be available for all, Premier says
Theresa Boyle
QUEEN'S PARK BUREAU
 
TONY CLEMENT: Studied private sector in England.
Premier Mike Harris says he welcomes increased privatization of health care, as long as services are equally available to all Ontarians.

 

``We've (been) encouraging the private sector to be active in the delivery of health care,'' Harris said yesterday, adding that private-sector involvement depended on its ability to do things more efficiently and provide better service for less money.

 

``But it's within the context of one-tier (medicare), under the Canada Health Act, universally available to all our citizens.''

 

Harris' comments are important because they are the furthest the Premier has gone in opening the door to increased privatization of Ontario's health-care system.

 

In the past, Harris has said he has no plans to privatize health care.

 

Harris, speaking after the first meeting of his new cabinet, said new Health Minister Tony Clement recently visited England to investigate the private sector's role in providing health care.

 


`We've (been) encouraging the private sector to be active in the delivery of health care. But it's within the context of one-tier (medicare), under the Canada Health Act, universally available to all our citizens.'
- Mike Harris

 

``You can't go around with your head in the sand and look at health care and the growing advances and new technologies and the escalation in costs and not be looking at other jurisdictions, including Britain,'' Harris told reporters.

 

``We are looking at what roles the private sector can play, (whether) they can do things more efficiently, more effectively, better service, better price,'' he said.

 

Harris said he's committed to one-tier medicare and has no plans to create a two-tier system that would allow people to pay to jump the queue for faster and better service.

 

He said he's committed to the principles of the Canada Health Act, which ensures comprehensive, universal, portable, accessible health care for all Canadians.

 

``We're after a one-tier system, but we do encourage our ministers to look anywhere around the world for how health care is delivered, to take a look at pluses and minuses, making sure that we see if there are advantages in other systems, (and) can we apply them here?'' he said.

 

Greater private sector involvement doesn't mean the province is moving to a two-tier system, Harris argued, adding that the private sector has long been involved in the delivery of health care.

 

``This has been the practice of the Ontario government for quite some time, including (under) the Liberals and the NDP,'' he said, noting those governments privatized hospital food services and laboratory services.

 

Clement, who recently took over the helm of the $21-billion health ministry, did little to dispel the impression he's an advocate of two-tier medicine.

 

``We've always had situations where we've had both publicly funded and privately funded, and publicly delivered and privately delivered facets of health care,'' said Clement. ``That's been the history in Ontario.''

 

Meantime, Harris said he would welcome a value-for-money audit of the decision by Cancer Care Ontario to pay a private company to run an after-hours radiation clinic at Toronto-Sunnybrook Regional Cancer Centre.

 

``We have no objection. In fact we like full audits of everything that we're doing . . . and we consider the auditor an ally,'' he said.

 

But earlier in the day, the Conservative government used its majority on the public accounts committee to quash a proposal for Provincial Auditor Erik Peters to conduct such a probe. The proposal was put forth by Liberal MPP Lyn McLeod (Thunder Bay-Atikokan) who questioned why Cancer Care Ontario, a government agency, couldn't run an after-hours clinic.

 

``I am surprised that the government members wouldn't have been interested in having the auditor do a value-for-money examination of the decision to run the after-hours program in a private clinic,'' she said.

 

McLeod, the Liberal health critic, said she wondered how the private clinic would be staffed given that a shortage of radiation therapists is the reason the province has used to send patients to the United States for treatment for almost two years.

 

``If the solution is there now it should have been there months ago,'' McLeod said.

 

The public accounts committee also debated a proposal to privatize critical care air ambulance services, a move NDP MPP Shelley Martel (Nickel Belt) said would ``compromise'' health care.

 

A request for proposals for private operators interested in bidding to run the service states they would face financial penalties if air ambulances were sent on calls without critical care paramedics aboard.

 

``You're compromising patient care'' by allowing for the possibility of an air ambulance to carry a critically ill patient without a critical care paramedic aboard, Martel charged.

 

Health ministry spokesperson Fred Rusk said the clause is intended only to address situations where paramedics are absent from work.

 

He said there's no point in the government paying for a paramedic service if it's not going to get it. He insisted patient care would not be jeopardized.
 
        

                                                  ETHICS HOME PAGE                                 SLC HOME                                      HELP

 

PLEASE NOTE: These pages are always going to be under review and revision. They have been assembled for the use of students in Gen024, Medical Ethics.  The course is offered at St. Lawrence College, Kingston, Canada.  For further information on this course or to report problems with this page, please contact [email protected]

                                                                                       

 

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1