"I'd Rather Have What We Had" by Lee Ann Womack
(written by Bobby Braddock)

It used to be red wine
There in room 3-2-9
Over the river
Where we weren't well known

Now, it's two coffees
Then off to the office
Then back in the driveway
And sittin' at home

Sneaking around with me
Or being tied down with me
Which one would you rather have
Dying to be with me
Or watching TV with me
Is this what we wanted so bad
I'd rather have what we had

We carefully planned it
What our hearts demanded
No more motel rooms
No more cheatin' lies

Now we're looking at it
A neatly wrapped package
But open it up
And there's no surprise

Sneaking around with me
Or being tied down with me
Which one would you rather have, be honest
Dying to be with me
Or watching TV with me
Is this what we wanted so bad
I'd rather have what we had
I'd rather have what we had