September 1996 (ranks pre-Marvel)

Rank  Title                               Sales   % Change
4     Final Night #1                      90,800
5     Final Night #2                      84,100    -7.4
6     Final Night #3                      82,500    -1.9
7     Final Night #4                      81,800    -0.8
9     Batman #536                         73,200
13    Detective Comics #703               68,500
23    Robin #35                           54,700
24    Nightwing #2                        54,500
25    Shadow Of The Bat #56               53,600
27    JL: A Midsummer's Nightmare #3      52,900
29    Legends Of The Dark Knight #88      51,800
31    Catwoman #39                        48,300
40    Shadow Of The Bat Annual #4         44,100
42    Azrael #23                          41,100
47    Total Justice #1                    38,800
54    Total Justice #2                    35,000    -9.8
56    Total Justice #3                    34,200    -2.3
64    Birds Of Prey: Manhunt #3           32,400
66    Batman: GCPD #4                     31,400
87    Batman & Robin Adventures #12       26,700
88    Batman & Robin Adventures Annual #1 26,700