The Presidents Trophy was presented by the Fantasy Hockey League in 1993 and resides in the Fantasy Hockey Hall of Fame. The original Presidents Trophy is a figment and is represented by a 5 inch plastic trophy given to each winner each year. A new trophy is presented to the Owner/General Manager of the winning team each season.
- Lost only 3 out of 26 games.
- Has won the Presidents 3 out of the last 4 years, and becomes the 3rd team to win 3 Presidents.
2002 Halloweentown Nightmares
2001 Stalingrad Stormbringers
2000 Stalingrad Stormbringers
1999 Dan's Team T.L.
1998 Halifax Hellraisers
1997 Dan's Team T.L.
1996 Beverly Hills Beast
1995 Halifax Hellraisers
1994 Dan's Team T.L.
1993 Liverpool Limies
