Johnny Oaktree's

Year End Fantasy Football Awards


Let's take a look at the best and worst of last year's
players, while examining their outlook for the coming season as well.

Each year we like to acknowledge those fantasy performers who made a difference. 
We do that by presenting 
the YEFFA®
- our virtual award given to those who have truly earned them over the course
of the most recent fantasy football season.
Congratulations to all our Winners!

 

Top Fantasy Players

 
QBs

 Carson Palmer – Cincinnati Bengals

A great season from the Bengals QB in 2005.  3,836 passing yards, 32 TDs, a 67.8 completion percentage and 101.1 QB rating.  He was the main reason why the Bengals reached the postseason last year. 

 2006 Outlook
Palmer’s postseason knee injury last year is cause for concern going into the fantasy drafts this year.  This situation needs to be watched closely during the preseason to determine where his stock lands in the drafts.  Without the injury, he probably would have been the 2nd QB taken, but now, it’s a waiting game.  With the current situation as it is, it would be highly too risky to select him early in fantasy drafts.

 

Tom Brady – New England Patriots

Brady is one of the most underrated fantasy QBs.  He has always been drafted late in fantasy drafts, and last year he shined once again.  4,110 passing yards, 26 TDs with a 63 completion percentage and 92.3 QB rating.

 2006 Outlook
Last year Brady lost WR David Patton in free agency to Washington, but still managed a great stat year for fantasy owners.  This year, so far, he lost WR David Givens in free agency as well.  Brady will still have WR Deion Branch and the Patriots signed another free agent WR in Reche Caldwell and drafted Chad Jackson.  Brady will probably still get no respect in drafts this coming year, but if you’re willing to concentrate on filling your other positions first, Brady is a good option to have in 2006 again.

 

RBs

Shaun Alexander – Seattle Seahawks

Alexander listed here should not surprise anyone.  Seattle rode Alexander on their way to the Superbowl.  1,880 rushing yards (5.1 avg), 27 rushing TDs.  He also added 78 yards receiving and another TD.

2006 Outlook
Free Agent T Steve Hutchinson left Seattle and decided to open running lanes in Minnesota.   It’s a small concern, no doubt, but Alexander should still be drafted within the top 5 (more likely the top 3) in most fantasy drafts this coming season.


Larry Johnson –
Kansas City Chiefs

This is not a shock either.  But the question is, was he drafted as “Priest Holmes insurance”, or did someone else draft him with a sense of simply taking a chance.  LJ was just amazing last season and if you owned him, you probably made the playoffs.  1,750 rushing yards (5.2 avg), 20 rushing TDs.  He added another 343 yards receiving and another TD.  He managed this feat with only starting 9 games last season.  Yes, that’s right, only NINE (but he did play in all 16).

 2006 Outlook
Johnson received the opportunity to shine because of an injury to Priest Holmes last season.  Holmes may retire, but officially he has not decided his future yet.  Regardless of what Holmes decides, Johnson should be the #1 selection overall in most fantasy drafts, or within the top 3 at minimal, because he will continue his dominance in 2006.

 

WRs

 Steve Smith – Carolina Panthers

Smith is also honored as one of the Comeback Players in 2005.  Smith broke his leg early in 2004, in which, he sat out the entire year.  And when he returned last year, he produced monster type numbers.  103 receptions for 1,563 yards (15.2 avg) and 12 TDs. 

2006 Outlook
This season, Smith will look down the line of scrimmage and see a capable WR that could steal a lot of Smith’s catches this season.  WR Keyshawn Johnson signed with Carolina as a free agent.  There is cause for concern that Smith’s numbers could dip, but Smith proved that he is one of the top WR’s in this league.  The Johnson signing should help Smith from seeing double coverage in most games.  Johnson is a big target for QB Delhomme and a good possession guy.  Smith is still the deep threat and his performance last season solidified his fantasy value where he should be drafted as one of the top 3 WRs this season.

 
Chad Johnson – Cincinnati Bengals

Johnson entertained us last season with his creative TD celebrations (9 of them).  He gelled with Palmer and quickly created a deadly fantasy QB-WR duo.  97 receptions for 1,432 yards (14.8 avg).

 2006 Outlook
No more TD celebrations for Johnson in 2006 according to the new NFL rules.  But that doesn’t mean he won’t get any more TDs, it just may take him a while.  His success will ride on the quick recovery of QB Carson Palmer.  Backup QB Jon Kitna left for the Detroit Lions and Cincinnati is now left without a valuable backup.  Johnson should be one of the top 5 WRs drafted in the coming year, but don’t be surprised if he starts a little slow in 2006.

 

TE

 Antonio Gates – San Diego Chargers

The best fantasy TE in the game today.  He was suspended for the first game of the season in 2005 and after that, well, let me just show you the numbers.  69 receptions for 1,101 yards (12.4 avg) and 10 TDs.

2006 Outlook
The other end of Gates’ receptions last season, QB Drew Brees, found a new address in 2006.  Philip Rivers will now take over at QB for the Chargers, and I am sure everyone is wondering what will happen to Gates’ value.  Gates has been drafted usually around rounds 4-5 in the past, in some instances, earlier.  With so many good TEs becoming more involved in their offenses, personally, I would wait until someone takes the chance on Gates and let that begin the TE run in the fantasy draft before selecting a TE of your own.

Biggest Surprise Players

 
QBs

 
Eli Manning –
New York Giants

Eli was drafted in many leagues in 2005 as a backup QB for their fantasy squad.  But my guess is he probably started more games than your original starting QB (unless his name was the “other” Manning).  Eli was consistently good all year long.  3,762 passing yards, 24 TDs with 52.8 completion percentage and 75.9 QB rating.

 2006 Outlook
Eli’s stock will rise in 2006 Fantasy drafts.  His INT total was still high (17 last season), but that shouldn’t matter to most owners.  Eli will still have WR Plaxico Burress, and Pro Bowlers, TE Jeremey Shockey, and RB Tiki Barber.  Eli is not quite a top 8 fantasy QB, but he certainly has the tools and the weapons to succeed, he just needs to lower that INT total.

 

Kurt Warner – Arizona Cardinals

Warner was out from weeks 4 through 8.  He returned week 9 and produced great fantasy numbers until week 15.  Most likely, Warner helped many last season through the playoffs.  Despite playing in only 10 games last year, these are the incredible numbers he was able to put together.  2,713 passing yards, 11 TDs with a 64.5 completion percentage and 85.8 QB rating.

 2006 Outlook
All Warner has to do in 2006 is stay healthy.  If he can manage that feat, he should be able to produce Pro Bowl like stats.  Warner no longer has QB Josh McCown looking over his shoulder since the youngster signed with Detroit in the offseason.  The incredible receiving tandem of Larry Fitzgerald and Anquan Boldin are still in Arizona uniforms.  They also added one of the top RB’s in the league in Edgerrin James.  If Coach Dennis Green can improve that Offensive Line, it could be a magical year for Warner.

RBs

 Lamont Jordan – Oakland Raiders

Maybe to some people, Jordan was not a big surprise.  But to me, I certainly did not expect him to put up the kind of numbers he did, hence the reason I listed him here.  Not bad for a first year starter.  1,025 rushing yards (3.8 avg), 9 rushing TDs.  He also added 563 yards receiving on 70 catches and 2 more TDs.

 2006 Outlook
One of the qualities that make Jordon so valuable is his receiving yards and if your league awards points for receptions, than Jordan will easily be a top RB in 2006 again.  However, Jordon will not be catching passes from Kerry Collins in 2006.  Aaron Brooks will take the helm of the Oakland offense.  Brooks, practically thrown out of New Orleans, hopes to revitalize his career with the Raiders.  This QB move should not affect Jordon much in fantasy drafts.  Jordon should be a second round or even a late first round pick come draft day.

 

Samkon Gado – Green Bay Packers

The Nigerian Nightmare, part II.  Another team’s trash, becomes another team’s gold.  Kansas City releasing Gado prior to the start of the season and Green Bay, needing a RB, snatched him up.  With injuries to Ahman Green and Najeh Davenpart, Gado got his chance to strut his stuff.  And those owners, who added him to their rosters late in the season, got nice production and a playoff boost.  From weeks 9-14 Gado’s stats were as follows; 582 rushing yards (4.1 avg), 6 rushing TDs.  He added another 77 yards receiving and another TD. 

 2006 Outlook
At the end of last season, Gado was certain to be listed as a sleeper candidate for 2006.  But since than, that has all changed and not in Gado’s favor.  Ahman Green and Najeh Davenport were both resigned by Green Bay in the offseason.  Unless another injury occurs or if Green or Davenpart get traded, Gado has little value this coming year.  For the 2006 draft, Gado should only be drafted as Ahman Green insurance until further notice.

 
WRs

 Chris Chambers  Miami Dolphins

Chambers, with an average at best QB in Fiedler, produced terrific numbers in 2005.  A late draft pick in most leagues, owners soon inserted Chambers into their weekly lineups.  82 receptions for 1,118 yards (13.6 avg) and 11 TDs. 

 2006 Outlook
One could easily say if Chambers can muster 1,118 with Fiedler, imagine what he should do with Daunte Culpepper now throwing passes his way.  Well, for me, the jury is still out on Culpepper.  Before he was injured, his passes resembled ducks in the wind.  Culpepper still needs to be 100% back from injury before I rant and rave about Chambers.  Although, Chambers should provide fantasy owners a solid #2 WR in 2006.

 
Joey Galloway – Tampa Bay Bucs

Galloway could easily been also nominated for the comeback award last season.  In 2004, an injury shortened season, he managed 416 yards.  In 2005 he had 83 receptions for 1,287 yards (15.5 avg) and 10 TDs.  Galloway was either a very late round draft pick last season, or a free agent pick up by the week 2.

 2006 Outlook
Not many significant changes to the Tampa Bay offense so far this offseason.  In other words, what you saw in 2005, you can expect pretty much the same for 2006.  One significant side note, Galloway will be 35 years of age in November.  At his age, the question asks if he can duplicate and continue his success without another injury.  Galloway is a solid #3 WR in 2006, drafting as a #2 is risky, but manageable.

TE

 Chris Cooley – Washington Redskins

A sleeper candidate in virtually every magazine I read prior to the 2005 season.  Cooley can now be considered a legitimate TE fantasy threat after his 2005 performance.  71 receptions for 774 yards (10.9 avg) and 7 TDs.

 2006 Outlook
My biggest concern with Cooley in 2006 is how many catches will he lose to his new WR teammates?  Washington signed WR Antwaan Randle-El and traded for WR Brandon Lloyd in the offseason.  And let’s not forget that Santana Moss still wears a Redskins uniform.  A lot of options for QB Mark Brunell in 2006, but will Cooley still play a big part?  With so many TE’s playing bigger parts in NFL’s offenses these days, you should be able to find one on draft day where a more prominent role is played.  Cooley is a solid #2 TE, but if you make him your #1, just make sure, you have solid pieces in all your other positions.

 

Most Disappointing Players

 
QBs

 Brett Favre – Green Bay Packers

Favre fell anywhere from #6 to #8 on most QB draft boards last year.  Many people will strictly look at Favre’s 2005 yardage total and keep him ranked fairly high again in 2006.  No doubt, his passing numbers were good, despite not having WR Javon Walker all season.  But, if you look at a game by game analysis on Favre in 2005, you will find from weeks 8 to16, Favre only had 2 weeks of solid fantasy performances.  And from week 12 on, his fantasy production was terrible. That being said, he probably sealed many fantasy owners’ fate on not reaching the playoffs.  His 2005 total stats are 3,881 passing yards, 20 TDs, 29 INTs with 61.3 completion percentage and 70.9 QB rating.

 2006 Outlook
It took a while but, Favre finally decided to return to the NFL next season.  However, despite this announcement, Favre should be dropped down on your 2006 QB draft boards.  The main pieces of this offense always appear to be injured (WRs Driver and Ferguson, RBs Green and Davenport) and this will take a toll on the QB.  He should be drafted as a quality backup QB and not more than that for this coming season.  I also predict that QB Aaron Rogers will see a lot of playing time this season.

 

Aaron Brooks – Oakland Raiders (New Orleans in 2005)

New Orleans’ problems in 2005 could be related to Hurricane Katrina, but the blame went to Aaron Brooks, as he was benched late in the 2005 season.  Hurricane Katrina destroyed the Superdome and the Saints were forced to play 8 home games, away from home.  The hurricane affected the morale and the psyche of many of the New Orleans players, Brooks included.  Maybe this is why his numbers were less than great.  2,882 passing yards, 13 TDs, 17 INTs with a 55.7 completion percentage and 70 QB rating.

2006 Outlook
From hurricanes to earthquakes.  But this is not the only thing Brooks will swap this coming season.  It’s a fresh new start and Brooks has a lot of talent around him to succeed.  He will have better WRs here in Oakland (R. Moss & Porter) than he did in New Orleans (Horn & Stallworth).  Also, the defenses in the AFC West can not even be compared to those tough D’s in the NFC South.  Brooks is a solid sleeper candidate in 2006, he is not the long term answer at QB, but surprisingly the Raiders did not select a QB in the draft.

 

RBs

 Jamal Lewis – Baltimore Ravens

In most 2005 fantasy drafts, Lewis was selected in the first round, or at the very least, the second round.  His final 2005 numbers were terrible, and I have to wonder if that jail time he served, affected him.  Lewis may have even been found on the waiver wire late in the 2005 season because too many owners were just disgusted.  906 rushing yards (3.4 avg), 3 rushing TDs.  He also added 191 yards receiving on 32 catches and 1 more TD.

 
2006 Outlook
Surprisingly, Lewis re-signs in Baltimore and RB Chester Taylor lands in Minnesota.  And I thought the Baltimore management would have done the opposite by keeping Taylor and letting Lewis walk.  But anyway, this doesn’t change my outlook on Lewis.  The Ravens replaced Taylor with RB Mike Anderson in the offseason, and with these 2 big backs possibly splitting carries, Lewis is no more than a 3rd RB or even a 2nd RB at best, but that would be pushing it. 

 
J. J. Arrington – Arizona Cardinals

In 2004, Arrington was the talk of the college nation were he was the leading rusher and amassed over 2,000 yards. Fast forward to 2005, and being drafted by the Cardinals, who desperately needed a RB, many thought Arrington would be a great sleeper candidate.  Well, Arrington could hardly amass over 500 total yards in his first pro season.  370 rushing yards (3.3 avg.), 2 rushing TDs.  He also added 139 receiving yards.

 
2006 Outlook
The only way Arrington will see another start as an Arizona Cardinal, is if an injury occurs to the new starting RB, Edgerrin James.  And even then, it will probably be more of the same as last season.  Don’t bother drafting him, unless you want your Edge insurance.

 
WRs

 
Randy Moss –
Oakland Raiders

One of the top 3 WRs going into the 2005 season and was drafted accordingly.  But Moss killed too many fantasy teams late in the year last season.  Where teams are trying to make a playoff push and counting on their top guys, Moss was a flop.  After week 11, Moss did not have a double digit performance until week 17 (where most fantasy seasons were already finished). 60 receptions for 1,005 yards (16.8 avg) and 8 TDs. 

 2006 Outlook
Moss’ stock will drop in the draft this year, especially with Brooks at QB.  He is no longer a viable first round selection, and I may not even consider him a top 5 WR in 2006. (Owens, Smith, Johnson, Holt, Fitzgerald, are all higher ranked in my estimation).  Sure he has all the talent in the world to succeed, but do you really want to risk your whole draft on this guy?  Moss can be a solid #1, and will still be drafted as such, but I am thinking more on the lines as a late second round pick this season, nothing more

 
Michael Clayton – Tampa Bay Bucs

Can someone say “sophomore jinx”?  In 2004, Clayton managed 1,193 yards.  Now I realize that Galloway was injured in 2004, but those are still impressive numbers from a rookie WR.  Galloway returns strong in 2005, and mix that in with Clayton’s nagging shoulder injury all year, and it’s a recipe for a disastrous fantasy year.  In 2005 he had 32 receptions for 372 yards (11.6 avg) and 0 TDs. 

 2006 Outlook
According to so many fantasy experts, even though there may be a “sophomore jinx”, there is a notion that third year WRs break out and produce great numbers for those who draft them.  Clayton could be a solid sleeper in 2006.  Galloway will be 35 in November, and may struggle to stay healthy on a weekly basis.  Keep Clayton on your radar for late in the draft.  Many people will forget about him, mostly because last season’s stats were completely terrible, but he could be a nice addition to your team, coming off the bench and filling in when you need him.

 
TE

 Dallas Clark – Indianapolis Colts

Another sleeper candidate in virtually every magazine I read prior to the 2005 season. Mostly because Marcus Pollard left for Detroit and Indy has an incredible pass oriented, defense torching offense.  But that wasn’t the case.  As a matter of fact, Clark didn’t have significant production until week 7 (where he was probably already a fantasy free agent at that point).  37 receptions for 488 yards (13.2 avg) and 4 TDs.

 2006 Outlook
Despite Clark’s lack of production last season, I will go out on a limb and say that he again will be a solid sleeper candidate for 2006.  With RB Edgerrin James removed from this offense, the passing game may come much more into play then in the past (Is that possible?)  The Colts selected RB Joseph Addai in the NFL Draft, but you can’t put that kind of pressure on a rookie.  I personally feel Dominic Rhoads will be the starting RB this season.  But to keep the pressure off Rhoads, QB Manning will look to all his receivers to step up next season, Clark included.


Comeback Players of the Year

 
QBs

Drew Bledsoe – Dallas Cowboys

Bledsoe had a surprisingly good year in 2005.  In 2004, his numbers were subpar, 2,932 passing yards, 20 TDs, 16 INTs with a 56.9 completion percentage and a 76.6 QB rating.  In 2005 Bledsoe was most likely drafted as a backup and was a spot starter in some weeks where the matchup was favorable.  Bledsoe threw for 3,639 yards, 23 TDs, 17INTs with a 60.1 completion percentage and 83.7 QB rating.

 2006 Outlook
Bledsoe has a new target in 2006, Terrell Owens.  T.O. brings attitude, a desire for winning, and complete stupidity to a Dallas offense.  But as for Bledsoe’s outlook for 2006, it really couldn’t be brighter.  Bledsoe’s numbers should see an increase this year, that is, as long as T.O. doesn’t start with his antics like he did in Philly last season.  Bledsoe should still be drafted as a backup, but he will be a solid one.

 

Mark Brunell – Washington Redskins

In 2004, Brunell and the Redskins struggled.  He only started 9 games in 2004 and produced these numbers.  1,194 passing yards, 7 TDs and 6 INTs with a 49.8 completion percentage and a 63.9 QB rating.  In 2005, the Skins bounced back and reached the post season, with the main reason pointing directly to Brunell.  His numbers in 2005 were very good: 3,050 passing yards, 23 TDs and 10 INTs with a 57.7 completion percentage and 85.9 QB rating.

 2006 Outlook
At 35 this season, it will be difficult to select him as an every week starter.  But that being said, with the Skins loading up talent at the WR position (Randle-El and Lloyd) in the offseason, how can anyone not take a chance at this potential potent offense.  He will be a good #2 QB in fantasy leagues

 

RBs

 Mike Anderson – Baltimore Ravens (Denver in 2005)

Mike Anderson had no stats in 2004 because of an injury.  In 2005 he regained the starting role in Denver’s carousel of RB’s and produced good numbers in 15 starts.  1,014 rushing, 212 receiving yards and 13 total TDs.

 2006 Outlook
Anderson will be in a Baltimore uniform this season.  The big question is who will be the lead RB since Jamal Lewis is still in town.  My best guess is, Anderson has better hands to catch the ball out of the backfield so expect to see him on passing downs.  And if Lewis continues to struggle, like he did in 2005, that will be good news for Anderson owners this season.  Anderson is nothing more than a 3rd or 4th RB on anyone’s fantasy team.

 
Ricky Williams – Miami Dolphins

In 2004, Ricky Williams decided to retire/quit, whatever you wanted to call that fiasco, just to avoid a drug suspension.  When he finally had his head examined and rejoin the NFL in 2005, he was never the feature back in Miami, but he still produced good numbers.  In 12 games (first 4 he was suspended), and 3 games he started, he rushed for 743 yards (4.4 avg.) and scored 6 TDs.

 2006 Outlook
Please do NOT draft Ricky Williams this season.  I do hope everyone knows that he is currently playing in the Canadian Football League and will not play in the NFL this season.  So unless you are in a keeper league, there is no point to draft him in 2006.

 

WRs

 Steve Smith – Carolina Panthers

(PLEASE READ THE “TOP PLAYERS” SECTION, STEVE SMITH IS LISTED THERE)

 2006 Outlook
(PLEASE READ THE “TOP PLAYERS” SECTION, SMITH’S OUTLOOK IS LISTED THERE)

 

Santana Moss – Washington Redskins

Much like I said in the Brunell piece above, the Skins struggled in 2004, and every offensive player suffered.  Moss started in 14 games (played in 15) had 838 receiving yards on 45 receptions (18.6 avg.) and 5 TDs.  In 2005, the Skins improved their offensive production which helped them reach the playoffs.  Moss started all 16 games and produced 1,483 receiving yards on 84 receptions (17.7 avg.) and 9 TDs.

 2006 Outlook
Santana Moss will have some competition grabbing attention this season on the offensive side of the ball.  I still expect the Skins to run the ball with Portis often, but they also upgraded their WR corps in the offseason with Randle-El and Lloyd.  Moss is still the #1 on this team with one of the best yards per catch in the NFL.  I don’t expect that to change much in 2006.

 

TE

 
Todd Heap –
Baltimore Ravens

In 2004, Heap suffered a nagging injury that resulted in him starting only 5 games.  He produced 303 yards on 27 receptions (11.2 avg.) and 3 TDs.  In 2005, despite the inept passing offense guided by QB Kyle Boller, Heap returned to top tier TE status with 855 receiving yards on 75 receptions (11.4 avg.) and 7 TDs.

 2006 Outlook
In 2006, QB Boller moves to the bench as Steve McNair comes to town.  If McNair can remain healthy, the passing offense will be vastly improved.  The Ravens have pieces in place to challenge for a playoff spot this season.  Heap should benefit greatly to the addition at QB and should be selected within the top 4 of TE’s this season.




Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1