Phil Kretschman: o12 FISH +57
Paul 199
Phil 228 ALP
...and Phil leaps back ahead with a nearly bingo-sized intermediate play, not to mention retaining an L. I also know quite a few 8 and 9 letter -FISH words, one of which is SPADEFISH (don't ask how I know this but not QUANTICS), and I'm keeping two of the key letters.
As an aside, AFHILPS is a tricky little unistem.