English 1C argument paper 1 OUTLINE

ARGUMENT Involuntary mental health treatment is costly and infringes on civil rights of a select group of people.

I There's always politics and/or money involved.

A Ideologies aside, bring it down to what's personal.

II Supporters make money. They steal public money and clients' assets. They'll steal your socks without taking your shoes off.

A EXAMPLES include Shirley Allen of Roby, Illinois.

III Involuntary detention and treatment isn't new.

IV Constitutional issue of violations of Habeas Corpus; federal mandate by executive order.

A Do we really have the right to refuse treatment?

B Lawyers go home at the end of the day but still face steadily increasing lack of empowerment to successfully defend clients.

V DO IT TO THEM INSTEAD - Issue: Clients face loss of freedom, return to lifelong warehousing at anyone's judgement.

VI How to stay ahead in this never-ending battle.

VII Light still shines in some counties.


* = strongest arguments

* 1 political / financial reasons

* 2 supporters stand to make money

3 do it to them instead

4 burdens taxpayers; theft of clients' assets

* 5 violates right of habeus corpus

RESEARCH right to refuse treatment

Examples: Shirley Allen of Illinois

ISSUE - loss of freedom, return to lifelong warehousing



1

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws