(Source: Wikipedia)
World Video Game Hall of Fame (1st year 1-5), 2015

Computer Gaming World
1994 Game of the Year

150 Best Games of All Time, #5
15 Most Innovative Computer Games, #3

GameSpy
Top 50 Games of All Time IGN
Top 100 Games of All Time (2003) #44 Top 100 Games (2005) #39

Top 100 Shooters #2

Retro Gamer
#9, Top Retro Games

Library of Congress Game Canon

GameTrailers
#1, Top Ten Breakthrough PC Games

Game Informer
#7, Top 200 Games of All Time

TIME
All-TIME 100 Video Games

GameSpot
The Greatest Games of All Time

PC Gamer UK
#3, Top 50 Games of All Time 1994-1995 Awards (Source: The Page of Doom)

Doom, 1994
Recognized by Computer Gaming World as Best Action/Adventure Game.
Received a Golden Triad Award "In Recognition of the Products’ Superior Quality".
Computer Game of the Year for 1994 from the European Computer Trade Show.
Best Action Adventure Game from the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences in 1994.
Game of the Year from PC Gamer.
Game of the Year from Computer Gaming World.
Received the Award for Technical Excellence from PC Magazine.

DOOM II 1994-95
Best Game in PC World magazine.
Mac User Editors Choice for Best New Action Game in 1995.
Computer Games Strategy Plus magazine named DOOM II as the 1994 Action Game of the Year.
The Golden Triad Award "In Recognition of the Products’ Superior Quality"