| Super Bowl | Most | Most | Toilet Bowl | ||
| Year | Winner | Runner-Up | Wins | Points | Winner |
| 2007 | Benchwarmers | Headbutts | Ned the Dog (10-4) | Ned the Dog (555) | Hooters |
| Dave Smith | Jeff Smith | Pete Larsen | Pete Larsen | Mike Smith | |
| 2006 | Glazed Donuts | Benchwarmers | Benchwarmers (13-2) | Benchwarmers (624) | Headbutts |
| Rich Murphy | Dave Smith | Dave Smith | Dave Smith | Jeff Smith | |
| 2005 | Pachyderms | Hooters | Hooters (11-4) | Hooters (580) | Out of Africa |
| J.T. Biddison | Mike Smith | Mike Smith | Mike Smith | Blair Jenkins | |
| 2004 | All In | Dirtbags | Glazed Donuts (10-5) | Ned the Dog (555) | Geeks on Call |
| J.T. Biddison | Dave Smith | Rich Murphy | Pete Larsen | Pat Smith | |
| 2003 | Glazed Donuts | Trailer Trash | Headbutts (13-2) | Headbutts (600) | Out of Africa |
| Rich Murphy | Dave Smith | Jeff Smith | Jeff Smith | Blair Jenkins | |
| 2002 | Caterpillars | Fudgepackers | Los Bastardos (13-2) | Fudgepackers (601) | Hagan's Heroes |
| Bill Seaver | Pat Smith | Dave Smith | Pat Smith | J.T. Biddison | |
| 2001 | Los Bastardos | Fudgepackers | Los Bastardos (10-5) | Los Bastardos (580) | Ned the Dog |
| Dave Smith | Pat Smith | Dave Smith | Dave Smith | Pete Larsen | |
| 2000 | Glazed Donuts | Grey Beards | Grey Beards, Studpuppies (12-3) | Studpuppies (602) | Fudgepackers |
| Rich Murphy | Bill Seaver | Bill Seaver, Dave Smith | Dave Smith | Pat Smith | |
| 1999 | Studpuppies | Glazed Donuts | Glazed Donuts (12-3) | Hagan's Heroes (551) | Hooters |
| Dave Smith | Rich Murphy | Rich Murphy | J.T. Biddison | Mike Smith | |
| 1998 | Glazed Donuts | Gnomads | Gnomads (10-5) | Gnomads (516) | Beavis & Buttheads |
| Rich Murphy | Pete Larsen | Pete Larsen | Pete Larsen | Blair Jenkins | |
| 1997 | Headbutts | Studpuppies | Beavis & Buttheads (11-4) | Beavis & Buttheads (515) | Fudgepackers |
| Jeff Smith | Dave Smith | Blair Jenkins | Blair Jenkins | Pat Smith | |
| 1996 | Studpuppies | Beavis & Buttheads | Pierogy Boys (11-4) | Pierogy Boys (486) | Vagrants |
| Dave Smith | Blair Jenkins | Rob Mikula | Rob Mikula | Bill Seaver | |
| 1995 | Ball & Chain | Newborns | Beavis & Buttheads (14-1) | Studpuppies (660) | Kiltian Forge |
| J.T. Biddison | Bill Seaver | Blair Jenkins | Dave Smith | Pete Larsen | |
| 1994 | Studpuppies | Lench Mob | Studpuppies, Lench Mob (11-4) | Studpuppies (566) | Hooters |
| Dave Smith | Terence McCrea | Dave Smith, Terence McCrea | Dave Smith | Mike Smith | |
| 1993 | Headbutts | Boxseats | SMB10I (11-5) | SMB10I (461) | Bad Boys |
| Jeff Smith | Bill Seaver | Chris Keefe | Chris Keefe | Billy Price | |
| 1992 | Fudgepackers | Blackhawks | 3 teams (9-6) | Boinkers (521) | Messpots |
| Pat Smith | Mike Price | Dave Smith, Chris Keefe, Mike Price | Dave Smith | Mike Smith | |
| 1991 | Fudgepackers | Jousters | Fudgepackers, Jousters (10-5) | Stallions (481) | Chiggers |
| Pat Smith | Jeff Ramey | Pat Smith, Jeff Ramey | Steve Phillips | Bill Seaver | |
| 1990 | Im Huge | Headbutts | Headbutts (12-3) | BSBB (515) | BSBB |
| Mike Price | Jeff Smith | Jeff Smith | Chris Keefe | Chris Keefe | |
| Triple Crown (Super Bowl Winner, Most Wins, Most Points Scored) | |||||
| 2001 | Los Bastardos | ||||