| Team | Cather | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | OF | OF | OF | DH | Owner | |
| 9 Finds | Oliva | Teixeira | Johnson | Arod | Jeter | Cabrerra | Matsui | Ordonez | M Young | Lisa Lvingston | |
| Aidan's Chi-Cubs | Soto | Thome | Iguchi | Arod | Jeter | Upton | Berkman | Burrell | D Lee | Andy Wagner | |
| Aliksmikalowski | Pierzynski | D Lee | Johnson | Arod | Tejada | M Ramirez | Cabrera | Sizemore | Swisher | Al Michalowski | |
| B&B bombers | Veritek | Dunn | Phillips | Arod | Uribe | Berkman | Hart | Willingham | Thomas | Paul Mandeville | |
| Badger | Pierzynski | Morneau | Uggla | Beltre | Ramirez | Fancoeur | Hawpe | Hart | Fielder | Thomas Kranz | |
| Ball Game | Martin | D Lee | Uggla | Arod | Ramirez | Duncan | Cust | Burrell | Nardy | Corine Swegler | |
| Beachnut | Hernadez | Dunn | Weeks | Arod | Jeter | Jenkins | M Ramirez | Upton | Braun | Chuck Bacon | |
| Bella I | I Rodriguez | Gonzalez | Wigginton | Arod | Rollins | Berkman | Hawpe | C Young | Pena | Joe Piacentino | |
| Bella II | I Rodriguez | Pena | Wigginton | Beltre | Rollins | Berkman | Hawpe | C Young | Fielder | Joe Piacentino | |
| Berno | Johjima | Pena | Uggla | Arod | Ramirez | Rios | Burrell | Markakis | Swisher | Bernie Segatto | |
| BF Boomsticks | McCann | Howard | Utley | Zimmerman | Reyes | Holliday | Willingham | Hart | Braun | Joe | |
| Big Bats | I Rodriguez | Howard | Phillips | Wright | Jeter | Soriano | Hunter | Pence | Helton | Jack Ridgway | |
| Bonica | McCann | Dunn | Phillips | Arod | Ramirez | C Young | Hawpe | Hart | Crust | Ryan Kranz | |
| Brody's Bombers | Posada | Pujols | Johnson | Atkins | Rollins | Drew | Guerrero | Dye | Rios | Clif White | |
| Bubba Army FTE | Pierzynski | Teixeira | Phillips | Arod | Reyes | Holliday | Burrell | C Young | Markakis | Carlos Coniglio | |
| Buster | Soto | Ortiz | Johnson | Braun | Ramirez | Holliday | Burrell | Rios | Young | Dave Sr | |
| CB's BJ | Hernadez | Ortiz | Weeks | Zimmerman | Jeter | Jenkins | M Ramirez | Sheffield | Dunn | Gail Beach | |
| Chubbs | Hernadez | Thome | Wigginton | Arod | Tejada | Beltran | Rios | C Young | Braun | Lou Cetina | x |
| Corked Bats | Martin | Dunn | Utley | Arod | Peralta | Duncan | Cust | Markakis | D Lee | Corine Swegler | |
| Cubs | V Martinez | Helton | Uggla | Arod | Tejada | Upton | Guerrero | Crawford | Glaus | Dustin Davis | |
| DC Sluggers | McCann | Fielder | Kent | Wright | Cabrera | Holliday | Upton | Ibanez | Morneau | Danny Collins | |
| Dem Bums | Posada | Delgado | Kent | Arod | Renteria | Soriano | Matsui | Duncan | Fields | Mathew Kranz | |
| Deviates | Molina | Morneau | Uggla | Arod | Ramirez | C Young | Hunter | Cust | Reynolds | Paul Mandeville | |
| Dodgerblue | Martin | Howard | Roberts | Braun | Renteria | Soriano | M Ramirez | Ordonez | Crawford | Michael Austin | |
| DodgerBoy | Martin | Pena | Uggla | Arod | Ramirez | Burrell | Young | Pence | Byrnes | Fred Kranz Sr | |
| DooDooBip | Veritek | D Lee | Wigginton | Arod | Jeter | M Ramirez | Abrue | Holliday | Inge | Dawn Medeiros | |
| Ducks on the Pond | Johjima | Howard | K Johnson | Zimmerman | Tejada | Soriano | Berkman | Sizemore | Konerko | Carlos Coniglio | |
| GJZ1 | Synder | Thome | Belliard | Arod | Cabrera | M Ramirez | Dye | Ordonez | F Thomas | Jerry Zeitner | |
| GJZ2 | Veritek | Fielder | Hill | Glaus | Renteria | Soriano | Guerrero | Wells | Konerko | Jerry Zeitner | |
| GJZ3 | Martinez | Swisher | Utley | Cabrera | Peralta | Ibanez | Rios | Hart | Arod | Jerry Zeitner | |
| Global warming | McCann | Pena | Utley | Arod | Rollins | Hawpe | C Young | Pence | Willingham | Donna Medeiros | |
| Got Game | Buch | Fielder | Wigginton | Fields | Uribe | Holliday | Burrell | C Lee | Teixeira | Kinsley Medeiros | |
| Hanks's Stars | Soto | Teixeira | Canu | Arod | Jeter | Griffey | Cabrera | Cameron | Youkillis | Thad Henry | |
| Hit Men | Johjima | Jacobs | Canu | Arod | Tejada | Soriano | Guerrero | Rios | Upton | Scott Callari | |
| JC Jammers | Pierzynski | Morneau | Kent | Arod | Ramirez | Soriano | Ordonez | Hart | Atkins | Jim Collins | |
| JC Slammers | Ross | Howard | Wigginton | Braun | Tejada | Berkman | Sizemore | Pence | Dunn | Jimmy Caron | x |
| JC24 / LC31 | Martin | Ortiz | Johnson | Wright | Tulowitzki | Holliday | Ordonez | Cust | Swisher | Jimmy Caron | x |
| Joltin Joe D's | Veritek | Pujols | Canu | Lowell | Jeter | Crawford | Guerrero | Cabrara | Renteria | Carl Pitruzzello | |
| KC Girl Power | Pierzynski | Konerko | Roberts | Arod | Peralta | Soriano | Guerrero | Rios | Wigginton | Katie Collins | |
| KRP in Port Richey | Molina | Fielder | Phillips | Lowell | Rollins | M Ramirez | Ordonez | Markakis | Granderson | Keith Pratt | |
| Liam's Cubs | V Martinez | Dunn | Wigginton | Glaus | Ramirez | Upton | Ordonez | Kearns | Arod | Andy Wagner | |
| Louie the Lizard | Johjima | Howard | Uggla | Braun | Peralta | M Ramirez | Sizemore | Nardy | Swisher | Ted Oconnell | |
| Lunatic fringe | McCann | Fielder | Phillips | Atkins | Young | Holliday | Berkman | Sizemore | Markakis | Dan Ridgway | |
| Lynn Otto l | Posada | Pena | Uggla | Arod | Ramirez | Rowand | Upton | Willingham | Wigginton | Lynn Otto | |
| Lynn Otto ll | I Rodriguez | Fielder | Wigginton | Braun | Tejada | Holliday | Beltran | Hawpe | Nardy | Lynn Otto | |
| Milo's Bombers | McCann | Thome | Wigginton | Braun | Ramirez | C Young | Hawpe | hart | Ortiz | Miles Anderson | x |
| MRay | Johjima | Fielder | Utley | Rolen | Cabrera | A Jones | Burrell | Abreu | Soriano | Micheal Ray | |
| No Legs I | Buck | Swisher | Wigginton | Braun | Ramirez | Holliday | Burrell | Hart | Howard | Ken Legno | |
| No Legs II | Soto | Fielder | Utley | Zimmerman | Rollins | A Jones | Hunter | Hawpe | Nardy | Ken Legno | |
| No Legs III | Soto | Pena | Hill | Arod | Uribe | Soriano | Berkman | Sizemore | A Gonzalez | Ken Legno | |
| Oil Companies Suck | Martin | Howard | Weeks | Zimmerman | Tulowitzki | Soriano | Berkman | Ibanez | Youkillis | Donna Medeiros | |
| Otto l | Buck | Howard | Wigginton | Braun | Ramirez | Soriano | Burrell | C Young | Nardy | Mike Otto | |
| Otto ll | Soto | Fielder | Uggla | Atkins | Peralta | Berkman | C Lee | Sizemore | Wigginton | Mike Otto | |
| Otto lll | Soto | Pena | Utley | Arod | Rollins | Hart | Hunter | Hawpe | C Young | Mike Otto | |
| ProStocks | Pierzynski | Sexson | Belliard | Arod | Guillen | Holliday | Crawford | Sizemore | Wright | Dave Rathkamp | |
| Raggedy Ann | Pierzynski | Konerko | Uggla | Arod | Reyes | Beltran | Burrell | Upton | Hill | Nora Kranz | |
| Ram-Rod | Posada | Pena | Roberts | Arod | Young | Soriano | M Ramirez | Rios | Pence | Bob Austin | |
| Rays & Mets on the Rise | Pierzynski | Dunn | Hill | Arod | Uribe | Beltran | Ordonez | Hampe | Pena | Bill Buchalski | |
| Scrubs | Soto | Pena | Uggla | Arod | Ramirez | Upton | Ordonez | Rios | Castro | Tom Delello Jr | |
| Smitty's | Ross | Youkillis | Uggla | Arod | Ramirez | C Lee | Ordonez | Hawpe | Byrnes | Andy Tinsley | x |
| Spam Yankees | Posada | Pena | Uggla | Arod | Jeter | M Ramirez | Byrnes | Hart | Upton | Dana Boivin | |
| Sultans Of Slipknot | McCann | Dunn | Utley | Arod | Young | C Lee | Hawpe | C Young | Markakis | Carlos Coniglio | |
| Team G | Pierzynski | Thome | Utley | Arod | Tulowitzki | Burrell | Rowand | Francoeur | Nardy | Greg Zeitner | |
| Team Jake | Posada | Fielder | Wigginton | Braun | Rollins | C Young | Hawpe | Markakis | Teixeira | Greg Zeitner | |
| Team Z | Martin | Dunn | Phillips | Arod | Ramirez | Hart | Willingham | Hunter | Swisher | Greg Zeitner | |
| TerriorTerror | V Martinez | Youkillis | Weeks | Arod | Ramirez | Wells | Holliday | Willingham | Bay | Amy Zuzevich | |
| The Powerfuls | Soto | Pena | Kent | Arod | Uribe | Soriano | Beltran | Hunter | Hart | Dominic Dilello | |
| Think Blue | Soto | Howard | Kinsler | Braun | Ramirez | Holliday | Upton | Sizemore | Hart | Dfed Kranz Jr | |
| Tiger Hunter | Molina | Fielder | Canu | Wright | Uribe | Holliday | Burrell | Cust | Kearns | Robert Keeder | |
| TMcGee | Martin | Howard | Wigginton | Zimmerman | Ramirez | Soriano | Dye | Ordonez | Jacobs | Greg Zeitner | |
| TVM | Veritek | Garko | Hill | Arod | Jeter | M Ramirez | Cabrera | A Jones | Atkins | Teppee | |
| Tom Sr | Soto | Pena | Kent | Arod | Ramirez | Cabrerra | Young | Hart | A Gonzalez | Tom Delello Sr | |
| Ubobs' Slobs | Martinez | Howard | Pedroia | Inge | Ramirez | Holliday | Hunter | Rios | Francoeur | Bobby Pratt | |
| Wades Whalers | McCann | Thome | Utley | Arod | Tulowitzki | Wells | Sizemore | Granderson | Nardy | Wade Hergenrother | |
| Waechter's Warriors | I Rodriguez | Thome | Wigginton | Reynolds | Guillen | Rios | Guerrero | Ordonez | Arod | Nanct Waechter | |
| Wagner I | Johjima | Dunn | Ellis | Arod | Young | Berkman | C Lee | Burrell | Kearns | Andy Wagner | |
| Wagner II | Veritek | Fielder | Hill | Wright | Renteria | C Lee | Hawpe | C Young | Thome | Andy Wagner | |
| Wagner III | V Martinez | Teixeira | Wigginton | Arod | Peralta | Cameron | Rowand | Hart | Thome | Andy Wagner | |
| Walmart | Martin | Teixeira | Uggla | Arod | Tejada | Cust | Upton | Markakis | Pena | Joe | |
| WaybackWayback | McCann | Howard | Utley | Zimmerman | Rollins | Cust | Sizemore | Nardy | Pena | Rich Zuzevich | |
| Xouts | Martin | D Lee | Uggla | Arod | Ramirez | Duncan | Cust | Burrell | Nardy | Brain Richards |