Eyes of War is the story of Mat Trakall and Princess Janevra. No, it�s a story about much more than that. So much, maybe it�s too much. It�s also about the six phoenixes, Raxsen the Dark Lord, and many others. This fantasy/romance is the story of the events that took place at the beginning of The Seventh Age, the Age of the Second Dragons. The book had the potential to be full of thought provoking writing with complicated storylines and complex characters. Unfortunately, I couldn�t see past the bad writing.
The errors began within the first few chapters as Mat Trakall traveled to Caendor. I�ll admit, traveling is exhausting but not to the point where Mat has to sleep it off for twenty hours that day and the day after. I don�t think I could pull that off. I�d be nice� but no. Janevra got the same problem at one point as well. I almost laughed when Mat suggested that she�d feel better after she slept. Then, it stopped being funny when she slept for seven hours after waking up less than two hours before. Sleeping is a bad time passer.
Giving humans superhuman stamina is just as bad. During the rise of Raxsen, he captured many villages. One village would run to the next village. That village would be destroyed or they would be too late. The first village would rescue the survivors, and they all would continue on to another village. This went on for days and weeks at a time with no mention of exhaustion. All that sleeping in the first few chapters could have been used around here.
There were many contradictions in the character of Janevra. In the first few pages she stated that she wanted a normal life but wanted something exciting to happen. Later, she said she liked being a princess and wanted to become queen. Soon after she left the castle for good. That is only a few examples of the contradictions in her character. By the end of the book, I still wasn�t sure what her goal was. Other characters had similar problems at points but none to this extent.
Problems were also in the storyline. One example of this was Mat�s parents as well as Janevra�s parents said they didn�t want the two to get tested to see if they were shoi�s, magic users, or not. The parents were sure that Mat and Janevra would be taken away. However, when Mat and Janevra snuck out of the castle to the Tower of Light to get tested� nothing happened. It was very anti-climatic.
The process of sneaking in and out of the castle is even sketchy. Janevra wasn�t allowed out of the castle, and that�s why Mat and she couldn�t just leave. The first time they snuck out, the guards just let them out because they were nice. It turned out it wasn�t even required that the two sneak out. Janevra would be allowed out of the castle anytime after she went to a festive event that happened a day later. They could have just left if they had waited a day or two. The second time, there was a guard who didn�t even recognize the princess. Something�s just not right about that.
All these errors seem to suggest that the book wasn�t well planned. Constant time passers and super human stamina suggest the writer had nothing to write about at the time. Spreading out the dialog, stories, and prophecies could have helped cover this up. The contradictions in character are easily seen as bad character design. Constantly changing how an event takes place, even if it was intended, also gives the impression of bad planning.
I could give many other examples of where the storyline was weak, but I�ll focus on the main flaw in the storyline instead. The main flaw is the prophecy. Sure, many fantasy novels like this have a prophecy of some sort, but a prophecy shouldn�t be the reason behind the characters� every action.
An example is when the six phoenixes were traveling to Raxsen, Janevra, and Mat as it was written in the prophecy. The only reason they traveled to these people was because they felt they were being called. I would have liked to see a more creative way of getting the characters from point A to point B. Getting all the characters together in some quirky way is more interesting than having them �feel� their way.
The ending, though there were some nice fight scenes, was rather disappointing. Again, I blame this on the prophecy driven plot. As Raxsen was preparing to kill Mat and Janevra, Tghil and Kard, the Good and Evil Gods, came and stopped the action. Raxsen demanded to know why they stopped the fight as Kard had said that he wanted Raxsen to kill the two. Tghil and Kard replied that the battle between Good and Evil had to be a greater struggle than one battle to see which was worthy of a prize yet to be mentioned in the second book.
There were also the normal typos that every book these days will have a couple of. This book had an unusually large amount, however. One just shouldn�t see two typos on a single page. Another sign of bad editing is the constant repeats of the same lines. The most repeated line was probably �butt the shape of a saddle.� There were also many lengthy descriptions of battle that all sounded about the same.
Perhaps some of these �mistakes� were intended. For instance, the lengthy description of battle could be illustrating the horrors of war these days. All these mistakes could be minor too. I might have just started judging this book heavily due to the large amount of sleeping in the first few chapters, making a bad impression on me.
The way that I see this book now though, I could only recommend it to other writers. It�s a good example of what not to do. The book is also kind of addicting for some reason. I spent an entire weekend reading this book instead of Jonathan Strange and Mr Norell after all.