PARTICIPATION OF WOMEN IN THE CATHOLIC CHURCH
IN AUSTRALIA
by Dr. Marie Macdonald
Excerpts from "Participation of Women in the Catholic Church
in Australia," a speech by Dr. Marie Macdonald, Coordinator of a research
project report "Woman and Man: One in Christ Jesus." For fuller text see
website: http://www.catholic.org.au/media/99aug18mm.htm
There were those who wish to maintain the current
position of women in the Church, or even return to the position of the
pre-Vatican ll Church, and there were those who seek an expanded role for
women.
Women were seen as integral and central to
the very nature and life of the Church. Their participation was presented
as diverse and myriad; they were described as "the backbone of the local
Church." The future of the Church and the participation of women were closely
linked. In general, greater participation was sought for women in the Catholic
Church in Australia in the areas of decision-making, Church administration
and leadership.
The results of the Catholic Church Life Survey
revealed that church attenders have a considerably older profile than the
catholic population in general. Women outnumber men about three to two,
and more than half of all attenders are not involved in any regular way
in other parish activities, although women are more likely to be involved
than men. Young people and separated or divorced are under-represented.
The great majority of attenders feel that the parish adequately meets their
spiritual needs. They felt that the best ways to increase women's participation
were through prayer, increasing women's involvement in decision-making
and administration, and reforming beliefs and practices that do not promote
the equality of of men and women. Three quarters said they have never experienced
nor observed barriers to women's participation in the Church, but more
than one quarter said they did not accept the Church's teaching on the
ordination of women.
On the other hand, written submissions, public
hearings and targeted groups revealed a strong sense of pain and alienation
resulting from the Church's stance on women. A dichotomous relationship
with the Church, characterised by such feeling as love and commitment yet
anguish and alienation, was experienced by both individuals and groups.
Pain, alienation, and often anger resulted
from a strong sense of women's marginalisation, powerlessness, and a lack
of acknowledgment within the Church.The frustration yet persistence of
both women and men in trying to stay in the Church despite their dissatisfaction
with the Churcg's perceived treatment of women was evident.
The frankness and sadness of those who had
left the practice of the faith, and of those who have considered leaving
as a result of the Church's treatment of women were obvious. It was clear
that many people have hope, but in many cases it is faint.
There was a heightened sense of frustration
at the blockage of the much-needed gift of women from service to the Church.
The sense of alienation and anguish resulting from the issues concerning
women and the Church was shown by all categories of individuals and groups
such as the young and elderly, women and men, lay and religious, and was
not characteristic of any particular group.
The fundamental barrier concerned so-called
patriarchal traditions and attitudes which were seen to be inconsistent
with the person and message of Jesus Christ and especially his relationship
with women. It was felt that such attitudes had been reinforced par
by Pope John Paul ll and the Vatican bureaucracy in recent times to the
detriment of the teachings and spirit of the Second Vatican Council. The
structures of the Church were experience as male-dominated, hierarchical,
and authoritarian.
One of the greatest challenges to arise from
the research is the need to create a range of opportunities in the Church
for respectful listening and dialogue concerning the experiences, needs,
and aspirations of women.
|