| CAMPY | GRAZ | MUSTY | MAC | TONY C | MCKILL | NICK | JAY | LANCE | PAT | |
| Round 1 | LaDainian Tomlinson | Steven Jackson | Larry Johnson | Joseph Addai | Frank Gore | Reggie Bush | Peyton Manning | Shaun Alexander | Brian Westbrook | Rudi Johnson |
| Round 2 | Cedric Benson | Willis McGahee | Thomas Jones | Marvin Harrison | Randy Moss | Travis Henry | Steve Smith | Laurence Maroney | Willie Parker | Chad johnson |
| Round 3 | Terrell Owens | Ronnie Brown | Torry Holt | Carson Palmer | Tom Brady | Andre Johnson | Reggie Wayne | Drew Brees | Marc Bulger | Phillip Rivers |
| Round 4 | Lee Evans | Roy Williams | Antonio Gates | Maurice-Jones Drew | Duece McAllister | TJ Houshmandzadeh | Anquan Boldin | Marcus Colston | Chicago | Larry Fitzgerald |
| Round 5 | Edgirrin James | Vernon Davis | Brandon Jacobs | Marshawn Lynch | Carnell Williams | Ahman Green | Clinton Portis | Javon Walker | Plaxico Burress | New England |
| Round 6 | Jon Kitna | Adrian Peterson | Baltimore | Donald Driver | Hines Ward | Donovan McNabb | Julius Jones | Chris Cooley | Laveranues Coles | Warrick Dunn |
| Round 7 | Calvin Johnson | Braylon Edwards | Matt Leinart | Tony Gonzalez | Jeremy Shockey | Reggie Brown | Marion Barber | San Diego | Santana Moss | Wes Welker |
| Round 8 | Jason Witten | Kellen Winslow Jr. K2 | Vincent Jackson | Denver | Deion Branch | Dallas | Jerricho Cotchery | Tatum Bell | Todd Heap | Ben Watson |
| Round 9 | Philadelphia | Jay Cutler | Donte Stallworth | DeAngelo Williams | Lamont Jordan | Bo Scaife | Jamal Lewis | Adam Vinatieri | Darrell Jackson | Ladell Betts |
| Round 10 | Greg Jennings | Mark Clayton | Vince Young | Mike Furrey | Matt Hasselbeck | Tony Romo | Randy McMichael | Chris Chambers | Brandon Jackson | Terry Glenn |
| Round 11 | JP Losman | Matt Schaub | Bernard Berrian | Shayne Graham | Isaac Bruce | Joey Galloway | Miami | Jerious Norwood | Chester Taylor | Dominic Rhodes |
| Round 12 | Michael Turner | Josh Scobee | Reuben Droughns | Santonio Holmes | Jaksonville | Neil Rackers | Jake Delhomme | Anthony Gonzalez | Alex Smith | Nate Keading |
| Round 13 | Stephen Gostkowski | Ted Ginn Jr | Josh Brown | Ben Rothlisberger | John Kasay | Fred Taylor | Olindo Mare | New Orleans | Jeff Wilkens | Pittsburgh |
| Round 14 | Alge Crumpler | David Akers | Heath Miller | Eric Johnson | Daniel Graham | Owen Daniels | Dallas Clark | Greg Olsen | LJ Smith | Eli Manning |
| Round 15 | Cincinnati | Carolina | Jason Hansen | Jay Feely | Seattle | Oakland | Tampa Bay | Jason Campbell | Ryan Longwell | Jerramy Stevens |
| Round 16 | Joe Nedney | San Francisco | Kansas City | NY Jets | Matt Stover | Mike Nugent | Lawrence Tynes | Jason Elam | Green Bay | Robbir Gould |