"
 
| 7-1-1895
| George W. Benton
| 7-15-1900
| "
Kelloggsville
| Monroe
|  
| 6-25-1824
| Amos Kellogg
| 3-5-1851
| Became Monroe Centre
|
Kelloggsville
| "
West Kelloggsville
| 3-6-1851
| Lemuel Moffitt
| 9-30-1903
| Mail to Conneaut
|
Kingsville
| Kingsville
|  
| 10-10-1820
| Zachary Olmstead
|  
|  
|
Monroe Center
| Monroe
| Monroe Centre
| 7-26-1892
| Lucius G. Fitch
| 10-14-1905
| Mail to Conneaut
|
Monroe Centre
| "
Kelloggsville
| 3-6-1851
| Ezekial W. Huntley
| 7-25-1892
| Became Monroe Center
|
North Kingsville
| Kingsville
|  
| 5-16-1866
| Elijah A. Butler
|  
|  
|
North Sheffield
| Sheffield
|  
| 4-7-1846
| David Y. Richmond
| 8-31-1903
| Mail to Kingsville
|
Phoenix
| Pierpont
|  
| 10-28-1862
| Alfred Hollister
| 8-31-1903
| To Kingsville
|
Riggs
| Monroe
|  
| 5-28-1888
| Joseph C. Hammond
| 2-28-1903
| Mail to Conneaut
|
Ship
| Pierpont
|  
| 4-5-1880
| Riley Franklin
| 5-22-1890
| Mail to Riggs
|
Ship
| "
 
| 6-13-1890
| Alfred Russel
| 8-31-1895
| Mail to Conneaut
|
South Ridge
| Conneaut
|  
| 7-11-1844
| John W. Haskell
| 11-12-1856
|  
|
South Ridge
| "
 
| 1-26-1857
| Andrew J. Cheney
| 8-23-1895
| Mail to Clark Corners
|
West Kelloggsville
| Monroe
|  
| 2-19-1851
| Lemuel Moffitt
| 3-5-1851
| Became Kelloggsville
| | | | | | |