A puzzle made of pieces you can't find
And for me you never really had the time
I was blind, No...
Chris: And everything that you meant to me
Is written in the pages of my history
But it's over now as far as I can see
Suddenly
Ben: Things are so different, now you're gone
I thought it'd be easy, I was wrong
(And now I'm caught) And now
Caught in the middle
Ben: Even though I'm with someone new
All I can think about is you
(And now I'm caught) And now
I'm caught in the middle
Mark: Moving on she brings me brighter days
Thoughts of you are in my mind always
Like a memory that I can't erase
It's here to stay, Wo...
Ben: Things are so different, now you're gone
I thought it'd be easy, I was wrong
(And now I'm caught) And now
Caught in the middle
Ben: Even though I'm with someone new
All I can think about is you
(And now I'm caught) And now
I'm caught in the middle
(So different) Chris: It's so different
(So easy) Paul: Oh, so easy
(But I can't get over you) Ben: And I can't get over you
(So different) Paul: It's so different
(So easy) Chris: So easy
(But I can't get over you) Ben: And I can't get over you, No babe
Ben: Things are so different, now you're gone
I thought it'd be easy, I was wrong
(And now I'm caught) And now
Caught in the middle
Ben: Even though I'm with someone new
All I can think about is you
(And now I'm caught) And now
I'm caught in the middle
Ben: Things are so different, now you're gone
I thought it'd be easy, I was wrong
(And now I'm caught) And now
Caught in the middle
Ben: Even though I'm with someone new
All I can think about is you
(And now I'm caught) And now
I'm caught in the middle
Ben: Things are so different, now you're gone
I thought it'd be easy, I was wrong
And now
Caught in the middle
Ben: Even though I'm with someone new
All I can think about is you
And now
I'm caught in the middle