Why the Daisaku Sect Was Expelled From Nichiren Shoshu, Part 3

The First Guidance Meeting for the Regional Representatives and Vice-Representatives of Hokkeko

By Rev. Nichijun Fujimoto, General Administrator of Nichiren Shoshu

Daibyakuho, 9/1/94

Three Part Series on the History Leading to the Split between the SGI and Nichiren Shoshu.

Part Three

The Denunciation of the High Priest and the Priesthood by the Soka Gakkai

It was in the summer of 1990, the year of the 700th anniversary of the establishment of the Head Temple, that the Soka Gakkai launched its attack on the priesthood. At a communication conference between the priesthood and Gakkai, held in July of 1990, the High Priest asked Ikeda about the attendance at the Ushitora Gongyo (ceremony of believers who were at the Head Temple on pilgrimages.) He also inquired about the delay in the construction of the Tachikawa Temple. The High Priest was curtly told, "Those are not the sort of topics you should bring up with Sensei when he is so tired from his recent travel abroad." (Summarized) The Gakkai personnel outrageously prevented him from speaking further and unilaterally began their condemnation and slander of the Nichiren Shoshu priests. They exhibited the most flagrantly rude behavior when they paid absolutely no attention to what the priests had to say and simply left their seats.

It was around this time that we received information from various sources that Ikeda was slandering the High Priest and denouncing the priesthood. These were just rumors, however, and there was no proof of his wrongdoing. Thus, the decision was made to wait to see how things would proceed. In October of that year, the great ceremony celebrating the 700th anniversary of the establishment of the Head Temple took place without incident.

The "Letter of Inquiry" and the Measures Taken by the Priesthood In December, however, an audio tape was sent from a certain district to the Head Temple with the claim that there were some terrible remarks made by Ikeda at the Soka Gakkai headquarters leaders' meeting held on November 16. In his speech, Ikeda made numerous comments such as the following, which denigrated, scorned and criticized the High Priest:

"Someone who's a High Priest ought to think of the happiness of the believers . . . and not about power.

In addition, there were many statements that were disdainful and critical of Nichiren Shoshu and the priests. The priesthood sent a "Letter of Inquiry" to the Soka Gakkai in December of the same year to ask Ikeda to explain his true motive in making such comments. Rather than respond to this letter, the Soka Gakkai immediately sent a "Letter of Appeal" in which it outlined nine points, all unfounded lies, criticizing the High Priest and the priesthood.

Given this conduct, the priesthood concluded that a sincere exchange based on faith could no longer be expected of the Ikeda Soka Gakkai. On December 27, the priesthood held a special meeting to partially revise the rules and regulations of Nichiren Shoshu, the result of which was the forfeiture of the positions of the chief and senior lay representatives (sokoto and daikoto) by those who currently held them.

The Soka Gakkai immediately responded by inciting the members of its organization to make harassing and threatening phone calls to the Head Temple and the district temples nationwide. In the new year, it commenced its campaign of harassment and interference on an organizational level, such as obstructing the New Year Gongyo Ceremony at the district temples.

Thereafter, on January 4, amidst the continued exchange of documents concerning the inquiries and the forfeiture of the positions of the chief and senior lay representatives by those who presently held them, the Soka Gakkai launched an extensive campaign to criticize the priesthood through the Seikyo Shimbun and Soka Shinpo newspapers. Moreover, at its community centers, it independently performed ceremonies, such as the Urabon and Higan-e, without priests. The Gakkai proceeded to further alienate its members from the temples and priests through such conduct as holding funeral services without priests.

Advice for Dissolution - Excommunication and Expulsion of Ikeda

Given these circumstances, the priesthood determined that the Soka Gakkai had violated the three conditions that it pledged to uphold at the time of its establishment as a religious corporation:

  1. The registration at the local temple of each person who converts to Nichiren Shoshu Buddhism.
  2. The strict observation of the doctrines of our denomination.
  3. The protection of the three treasures.

The priesthood could not help but conclude that the Soka Gakkai had forfeited its standing as a lay believers' organization of Nichiren Shoshu and that it had degenerated into a slanderous group bent on destroying the three treasures. On November 7, 1991, the priesthood sent the Soka Gakkai a document, "Advice for Dissolution."

The Soka Gakkai grew even more offensive than before and intensified its hateful and slanderous activities against the High Priest and the priesthood. It was impossible for the priesthood to ignore such blatant conduct, and inevitably on November 28, it sent the Soka Gakkai a "Notification of Excommunication." When the Gakkai received this notification, it apparently feigned a strong front and declared its "sense of fresh relief at being disconnected with the bothersome priesthood and finding its independence."

If this were true, then it seems strange that the Soka Gakkai has persistently intensified its slander and denunciation of the High Priest and priesthood to an all time high and has started a signature campaign demanding the resignation of the High Priest.

By excommunicating the Soka Gakkai, the priesthood eternally banished the extremely slanderous organization from Nichiren Shoshu. Thus, it is absolutely impossible that the priesthood and the Soka Gakkai will once again engage in discussion or arrive at some reconciliation.

The individual members of the organization, however, originally embraced the precept of the Law (received Gojukai) and accepted the Gohonzon as Nichiren Shoshu believers. Therefore, all members, other than those who are recipients of the recently issued counterfeit Gohonzon, are recognized as Nichiren Shoshu believers and are permitted to go on pilgrimages (tozan) by obtaining a letter of reference from their local temples.

Ikeda has been tirelessly maintaining his repetitious slander and bad-mouthing targeted at the High Priest by calling him such names as the "diabolical High Priest," the "founder of the Nikken sect who exploits the Daishonin" and the "incarnation of Devadatta."

He has also gone to extremes to slander Nichiren Shoshu by labeling it the "Nikken sect" and the "Devadatta sect." On August 11, 1992, after completing the requisite procedures, Nichiren Shoshu enacted the disciplinary measure of expelling Ikeda as a believer of our denomination.

The Secession of the Gakkai Priests from Nichiren Shoshu

Meanwhile, within the priesthood, seven priests - including Gen-ei Kudo of Choei-ji Temple in Tachikawa and Shojun Ohashi of Daisho-ji Temple in Wakayama - submitted an outrageous document titled "The Remonstration" to the High Priest in February of 1992 and left Nichiren Shoshu.

Thereafter, until March of last year, a total of 43 priests from 27 temples have taken their leave. These priests, in their declarations expressing the reason for their departure, make mention of plausible and seemingly sensible topics such as reforming the priesthood. In reality, however, they are men who have completely lost their faith in Nichiren Shoshu and are a total disgrace to all priests.

The truth is, when the Gakkai fell into its present predicament, these priests did not know what to do with themselves and desperately had to leave. The priesthood is quite pleased that the priests left voluntarily, since it has been spared the trouble of having to remove them. Rather than leave independently, however, these priests have entangled their temples and have caused a great deal of distress to the believers who are affiliated with them. The priesthood was extremely disturbed by this and put forth its utmost effort into recovering what can be recovered through legal means.

The Falsification of Photographs and Harassing Lawsuits

Another event involves the falsification of photographs. Again, the Soka Gakkai schemed to falsely entrap the High Priest by going so far as to tamper with photographs so that the believers would turn against him. It is an unforgivable occurrence, indeed, and the priesthood is pursuing legal action against Ikeda and the Soka Gakkai on this matter.

Furthermore, there have been legal actions filed against 70 temples, based on the claim of the unlicensed operation of cemeteries and ossuaries. Again, the true intent of these lawsuits is harassment. The police are well aware of the circumstances, and so far, all the cases, except for a few cases that are still pending judgment, have been dismissed. In addition, there have been incidents concerning the handling of cremated ashes and burials, which are all still continuing as legal actions in the courts. In all cases, the priesthood is earnestly seeking prompt resolution.

The Soka Gakkai as a Political & Social Problem

Let us now turn our attention to the political situation. This year, Prime Minister Hosokawa resigned and Prime Minister Hata's term ended in dissolution. As a result, it is generally considered that the Soka Gakkai and Komeito party have finally begun to wane in power. In addition, a recently formed group called the "April Association (Shigatsu-kai)" has been avidly exposing the social improprieties of the Soka Gakkai and questioning its qualifications as a religious corporation. It is, indeed, a matter of course that circumstances have come about so that a disquieting concern is raised about the very existence of the Soka Gakkai and Komeito party.

No matter what the political and social state of affairs and activities may be, the priesthood is convinced that the act of propagating and re-propagating the correct principles of True Buddhism is, indeed, the rightful course to pursue.

The Great General Meeting of the 60,000 Bodhisattvas of the Earth and Our New Objective

On July 24 of this year, the great pilgrimage of 60,000 Bodhisattvas of the Earth was a tremendous success. It marked the commencement of our struggle towards a new harmonious unity between priesthood and laity and Kosen-rufu. The High Priest mandated a new goal: a pilgrimage of 300,000 Hokkeko followers in the year 2002, the 750th anniversary of the establishment of our denomination. United as priesthood and laity, let us hasten forth with great joy and resolution towards our new objective! The High Priest will present his profound directions to us today. I ask each and every one of you to etch his guidance deep in your hearts. I will conclude my speech by asking you to unite in spirit with the senior teacher priest of your chapter and to advance forth resolutely towards making great improvements in your chapter and accomplishing Kosen-rufu in your area.

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>


ACTIVITES OF THE SOKA GAKKAI
THE BASICS OF BUDDHIST STUDY
Soka Gakkai Seikyo Times
August, 1979 No. 218
Pages 16-17

         The Lay Organization of Nichiren Shoshu
         
           The entirety of Nichiren Daishonin's Buddhism
         was correctly inherited solely by Nikko Shonin.
         Since then up until the present day, for seven
         centuries, the pure lineage of true Buddhism has
         been maintained through the successive high
         priests of the Nichiren Shoshu Head Temple,
         Taiseki-ji, just as water from one glass is trans-
         ferred in its entirety into another.  The Soka
         Gakkai, which is the lay organization of Nichiren
         Shoshu, has promoted the movement for kosen-rufu
         which Nichiren Daishonin willed that his followers
         attain.

           I have repeatedly emphasized the importance of
           harmony between the clergy and the laity. It
           is my firm belief that we can never achieve
           k6sen-rufi~ without it. Therefore, let us confirm
           that the Soka Gakkai's eternal guiding principle
           is to protect, support and advance hand in hand
           with the Nichiren Shoshu priesthood. Not only
           within our Buddhist circles, but in society as a
           whole, the greatest challenges lie in the ques-
           tions of how to harmonize forces of tradition
           and modernization, history and progress, as
           well as standards and social development.
           Development without norms, progress without
           respect for tradition are all rooted shallowly
           and cannot last.  Therefore, in promoting
           Nichiren Daishonin's Buddhism with respect to
           our time, in our society and throughout the
           world, we must resolve to advance our activities
           with full consideration of the traditions of
           Nichiren Shoshu and the orthodoxy of its
           doctrine.

           In order to realize this spirit of Nichiren Dai-
         shonin, the Soka Gakkai observes the doctrines
         of Nichiren Shoshu and carries on a religious
         movement for the salvation of mankind.  The
         essential meaning of Buddhism lies in solving
         fundamental human sufferings of birth, old age,
         sickness and death, which can never be dealt with
         through such external approaches as politics,
         economics or college education.



------------------------------------------------------------------------

------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: original posted on Dejanews by Craig Bratcher. I have added html and some links so that I can discuss this document.
Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1