| 2005 American League Playoffs | |||
| Round 1 | Round 2 | Championship | |
| 1. Finest (12-6) | |||
| 1. Finest | |||
| 2. Outlaws (10-9) | |||
| 1. Rockies | |||
| 1. Rockies (15-7) | |||
| 1. Rockies | |||
| 2. Diablos (14-8) | |||
| 1. Rockies | |||
| 1. Redhawks (18-4) | |||
| 1. Redhawks | |||
| 2. Vipers (14-8) | |||
| 1. Redhawks | |||
| 1. Blues (17-5) | |||
| 2. Reds | |||
| 2. Reds (16-6) | |||
| AL North Semi-Final | Game 1: | Finest 15 Outlaws 10 | |
| Game 2: | Finest 19 Outlaws 9 | ||
| AL South Semi-Final | Game 1: | Rockies 17 Diablos 5 | |
| Game 2: | Rockies 10 Diablos 9 | ||
| AL East Semi-Final | Game 1: | Redhawks 15 Vipers 10 | |
| Game 2: | Redhawks 12 Vipers 3 | ||
| AL West Semi-Final | Game 1: | Reds 12 Blues 2 | |
| Game 2: | Reds 15 Blues 11 | ||
| North/South Final | Game 1: | Rockies 23 Finest 5 | |
| Game 2: | Rockies 22 Finest 17 | ||
| East/West Final | Game 1: | Redhawks 10 Reds 8 | |
| Game 2: | Reds 17 Redhawks 4 | ||
| Game 3: | Redhawks 11 Reds 6 | ||
| AL Championship | Game 1: | Redhawks 13 Rockies 5 | |
| Game 2: | Rockies 10 Redhawks 9 | ||
| Game 3: | Rockies 10 Redhawks 6 | ||