Episode 23 - Witch Trial

A totally different actor was used to portray the warlock Nicholas this time. Also, they didn't give the original Nicholas such a weird voice.


Just before the sisters open the portal to Abraxas for the first time, Prue uses her power to move a chair across the attic. This would be fine, except that she channeled the power through her eyes, whereas since 'Blind Sided' she has always used her hands! --That Prue's able to move things using her hands doesn't mean she can't use her eyes anymore, she must be able do use both. (Daphne)


Since Prue channels her power through her hands, how did the sisters expect her to use her power on Abraxas when both hands were occupied keeping the portal open?


When the girls are blown back from the portal by Abraxas, you can see a faint wire, pulling them back


Piper says that the spell to get rid of Jeremy was written at the very back of the Book. However in the first episode the spell is taken from the spirit-board and not the Book. The sisters could have written the spell in, yet when Abraxas is reading it backwards, the spell has been written in beautiful calligraphy and illustrated like the spells already in the book - have the sisters been taking lessons in calligraphy? Also if you compare it to the 'Woogyman' spell which was also not originally in the book, it is written in plain handwriting, not calligraphy.


Since Abraxas reads the book backwards and actually reaches the beginning, there would have been a lot more demons released than the ones that attacked the sisters. Piper does make mention of the fact that Abraxas could have released more demons than they know about, but since all the released ones appeared right next to the sisters this seems very unlikely.


Why didn't the sisters investigate the meaning of the triquetra on Kit's collar sooner? In 'The Fourth Sister' Piper mentions that Kit has a very distinctive collar, which means they did see the triquetra before.


Right before Prue goes back home, she goes to the police station to talk with Inspector Morris. When they sit down at the bech you can clearly see Shannen's cross tatoo on her leg. (Vanessa)




Episode 24 - Morality Bites

When Prue and Piper are flipping through the Book of Shadows whilst waiting for Leo to return (when they look at the earmarked pages in the book) they show a close-up of the book as Prue flips through. As she does so, you can see that one of the spells is the 'Return Spell' that had supposedly 'vanished' from the book.


When a wide-shot of the room is displayed, whilst Prue and Piper are looking through the book, a pouch can be seen between the pages. Then on the next close-up shot the pouch has vanished, but reappears in the next wide-shot.


When Prue and Piper first turn to the spell to create a door, there is nothing there, but the next time they turn to it, they find the prison map tucked next to the page.


When Prue tears out the binding spell, the spell on the page next to it (the memory spell) has vanished.


When Piper draws a door on the jail wall she reaches above her head but when she and Prue walk in, they have to duck. (Nadine)


The events at the start and the end of the episode are in the wrong order. Here's what happens at the start: Piper walks in with a dirty shoe, the dog barks and the sisters rush to the window and do the whole freezing thing, then Phoebe sits down to watch tv and gets the premonition. Here's what happens at the end: The sisters arrive back, flick on the tv and see the show that triggered the premonition, THEN the dog barks and they go to the window to do the freezing thing. If you go by the start, the Pratt would already have left the sidewalk before the TV show appeared.


At the beginning, when the sisters are getting to the living room window, Phoebe is the first to get to it, But on the next shot, the one from the outside, Piper is the first one to get to the window. (Virginie)


When Piper unfreezes the people in front of Bucklands, 2 boys on bikes are passing beside them, on Piper's side, but on the next shot, they're passing behind Leo. (Virginie)


In the future, when Piper kisses Leo, her hand often switches from on his neck to on his back. (Virginie)


When Piper freezes Pratt and the guy turning the flames on you see the people outside the room get frozen too but Piper can only freeze the room she is in. (Nikki) --According to Rhys: Piper's powers have grown so that she can now freeze more than just the room she's in - just like she froze the entire street.


Piper's powers have grown so she can freeze everything (as prue states)BUT if she froze everything wouldn't Leo and that screaming lady have frozen too? AND if the lady was inside a building nearby and then came out, surely everyone in the building would have noticed something wrong. (Tacroy1)


In "That 70's episode" after they have gone back in time. Prue clearly states that they threw away their 8 track tapes and typewriter but once they have arrived in the future and Prue and Piper enter the attic the first shot of them in the attic you see, the typewriter is on a desk which is right in front of the camera, when they walk in the door. (tacroy1)




Episode 25 - The Painted World

How did Phoebe manage to get Kit inside the painting without getting sucked in there herself? It's not like the cat can speak Latin or anything! --According to Nikki: Phoebe has a different kind of smarts, simply say the spell, stand back and throw the cat into the vortex!


When the painting is burning, nothing else catches on fire - including the wooden chair that it is sitting on.


Prue was sucked into the painting after she read the word "Help" written on the window - yet when Piper goes to write the word "Nell" on the same window (verified later by Phoebe and a magnifying glass), the "Help" has vanished.


Why didn't Prue use her powers to move the dust on the window rather than physically going up to write her message?


When the warlock was 'blinking' around the room, he was in one place long enough (while he was talking) for Piper to freeze him but she didn't.


When Piper freezes the fireball in the painting for the first time, the candles on the table behind it continue to move.


The warlock didn't freeze either time Piper froze the fireballs - is this a blooper or can her power be directed in some manner? --According to Karena: It is possible for only the fireball to freeze and not the candles as Piper can freeze certain things and leave others moving and vice versa. (Although we only find this out later).


According to the Book Of Shadows, the spell to get out of the painting would cause EVERYONE trapped in the painting to be freed. Why then did it only transport the warlock outside the painting, and later on only the sisters?


Malcolm (the warlock trapped in the painting) gets injured when he and Prue are running to safety. You can see the blood on his temple clearly. Yet in 'They're Everywhere', Phoebe mentions that warlocks don't bleed! (Brittany)


Piper freezes the guy at the auction house in order to take the painting to the manor. Wouldnt he suspect something when she, and the painting are gone in a blink? (Ted)


When Phoebe and Piper are talking in the kitchen, Phoebe's arm are on the table, but in the next shot, her hand are holding her face. (Virginie)


When the painting is moving, the candles on the table stay absolutely still, wouldn't they be sliding off the table? (Virginie)


After Phoebe casts the smart spell, she "reads" through the dictionary, then states: "Abaca: Strong fiber obtained from a banana leaf. Zygote: A cell formed by the union of two gametes." In the first place, she started with the F's. In the second, aardvark (and others) comes BEFORE Abaca. (Kimber)


After Malcolm tells Prue she's in the painting, they go to a wide- screen shot. Prue is alone in the shot, with her arms down. Before and after that shot, Malcolm is very close to her and her arm is up at chin level, on the wall of the alcove. (Kimber)


When Phoebe was at the job interview, all the people in the room were there for the aptitude test. How come then, the man who spoke to Phoebe was reading the newsaper? (Virginie)


When Phoebe turned around when Prue asked for her car key, we can see that they didn't hide Alyssa's tattoo on her shoulder. (Virginie)


When Phoebe is with Jenny, she takes a magnifying glass from Prue's purse. Would you tell me what kind of people would walk on with a magnifying glass in her wallet? (Virginie)


At the end, when Phoebe gets in the painting, she and her sisters are standing in the middle of the room, but no fireballs are released at them. (Virginie)


When Phoebe is in her room creating the smart spell and she pushes the Book of Shadows under her covers when Piper comes in, you can still see the ribbons of the book on the bed. Put after Piper leaves, Phoebe goes to take out the book again and there are no ribbons on the bed. (Anthony)




Episode 26 - The Devil's Music

The numbers on the computer screen displaying P3's expenditures don't add up to the total at the bottom of the screen.


When Piper is looking over the expenses at the club, she is not wearing a necklace, yet when she runs in to tell her sisters about Dishwalla, she is magically wearing a pearl necklace.


When Piper runs out of the kitchen to answer the door, you can clearly see a small black microphone box attached to her jeans.


It's a case of the disappearing and reappearing necklace for Prue in the scenes before (there), during (not there) and after (there) Leo's visit.


When looking at Maslin in the Book Of Shadows, you can see that Phoebe has suddenly gained a second necklace and a charm, which vanishes in the next scene.


The stain on Phoebe's skirt vanishes for a while, and when it reappears it is in a totally different shape. (Virginie)


We know that Darryl is investigatting on the missing women, and he is from the city police. But he mentions that womens are missing from all over the country, so in this case, isn't it supposed to be the FBI's job?


At the end, when Piper is speaking to Leo, we can see that they didn't hide Holly's tattoo on her shoulder, making it a dark spot on her skin.




Episode 27 - She's A Man, Baby, A Man!


Directly after Phoebe gets her vision of the succubus and her eggs, she breaks out in a sweat. The camera shifts to Piper, and when it returns to Phoebe she is nice and dry.


At the beginning, Phoebe drank some ice tea before she took her temperature, but everybody should know that you're not supposed to drink or eat anything for least 15 minutes before taking your temperature because it wouldn't give the right one. (Virginie)


When Piper and Phoebe are at the mixer, we can often see Darla passing behind them as a walker-on. And later, when Phoebe sees throught the succubus, you can see her (the succubus) behind Manny getting arrested! (Virginie)


When the police guy was killed at the coroner's office, we see that there is a security camera behind him, on the wall. So if a camera filmed all this "unusual occurrence", whay didn't we hear about the video evidence later? (Virginie)




Episode 28 - That Ol' Black Magic

Tawatha mentions that the previous Chosen One managed to entomb her. Why didn't he just kill her like Kyle did? It would have saved the sisters and Kyle a whole lot of trouble!


Although there may not be a courage potion, there is a spell to increase self-confidence (which seemed quite appropriate in Kyle's case), that Piper used in 'Feats of Clay' - why didn't they use that?


When Piper, Phoebe and Leo are looking for Kyle, Piper's arms on her hips. Then when we see them from far away, her arms are crossed, then back on her hips when we go to the close-up shot. (Keri86)


When Jack is at the door with all three girls and then Dan comes on the scene, you can see Leo leaving Kyle in the background (behind Piper and Phoebe) and coming straight down the hall. BUT, when he comes over to see what's going on, he comes in from the right side of the screen. Is he abusing his orbing power? Is that even possible??? (Kimber)


In 'That Old Black Magic' Kyle leaves straight from school to the Manor and stays there until way after dark. Wouldn't his parents worry when he didn't come home?? (Brittany)


Why did Tawatha take away the sisters powers instead of keeping them for herself so that she could be stronger when facing Kyle? (Virginie)


Why didn't Tawatha throw the sleeping potion at Kyle instead of Phoebe, so that it would be easier for her to get the wand from him? (Virginie)




Episode 29 - They're Everywhere

The whole thought reading thing - shouldn't Piper and Prue have been able to hear everyone's thoughts all the time. It's pretty hard to stop thinking, you know!


When Eric broke into the museum and destroyed the ancient tablet--how come he was never arrested? He destroyed it in front of tons of witnesses!(HllywdChk)


In this episode, Prue had the knife that had supposedly vanished in "When Bad Warlocks Go Good" (Ted)


When Jack unfreezes after Prue stabs his palm with the dagger, his palm bleeds. They continue talking and he holds up his hand and you can see there is no blood there and you didn't see him wipe it off. (Shay)


Phoebe walks into the manor holding a bunch of flowers. She said they were sitting on the step and they were for Prue. She also said that there was no card. If there wasn't a card on them, how did she know they were for Prue? (Shay)


Right after the warloks took Eric's father, the sisters and Eric are talking outside the building and if you look closely you can see the top of Alissa's tattoo coming out of her pants.(ncl)


At the manor, just as the sisters and Eric are leaving to get Eric's dad from the hospital, Phoebe puts on her jacket as she goes out the door. While she does this, a black microphone cord can be seen extending from her pants up underneath her shirt.


When Prue and Piper do the hearing thoughts spell, the BoS states "Light a blue candle". If they were "just looking", how did they know to have the blue candles ready? (Kimber)


At the hospital, with Eric and the girls, Eric shoots the warlocks. True, bullets don't affect warlocks. but �why does/how can Warlock # 2's SHIRT "heal"? They should have aimed lower so he could have lifted his shirt and shown the wound itself closing. (Kimber)


A note about the tattoo, er, Alyssa's, you can see it again peeking out of her jeans right after Eric smashes the mapstone. (Kimber)


Phoebe calls Japan, but she should have really been using the telephone greeting "Moshi-moshi" rather than "Konitchiwa" (Jamie)




Episode 30 - P3 H20

When Piper is sitting in a chair at the lake - just having been transported by Leo - the wide shots show her hands resting on her knees, but the close-ups show Phoebe holding her right hand.


This happens just after Sam is swallowed by the Water-demon. There is water splashed all over the dock and Prue, who was standing right behind him, is shown in the next shot with her hair absolutely dripping wet. She then uses her powers to flick the power switch. She is then shown kneeling over Sam but her hair is dry and perfectly styled. (Aoife)


When Prue witnesses the first man get killed by the demon, why didn't she just use her power to lift the man out of the lake. She did it in 'Blindsided'. (Steph)


The whole time that they were fighting the demon, how come Piper wasn't itchy anymore? (Steph)


Since when has Phoebe been able to call premonitions? I know that she has been trying and practising and stuff, isn't it a bit funny that she just happens to be able to call this premonition right away? And why did she touch Sam to call it, he was frozen. Wouldn't she be better off touching the dock or something? (Steph) --Phoebe has been able to call her premonitions since the episode with the Alcatraz ghost . For example when Phoebe was at the back seat of Andy's car,when he gave her thr knife to touch. And about the premonition with prue's mom , it would be too risky to go anywhere near the lake untill they were ready to fight the demon. (Sergei)


After the park ranger is taken by the Water Demon you can see ducks calmly swimming in the background. Don't you think they'd be swimming like crazy away from the area where the demon was? (Blake)


When the kids arrive in the buses look at the first bus, it's license plate is different in two different scenes. As the bus arrives it's white and then when the kids are getting off the bus it's blue. I'm pretty sure the number is different as well. (Ian)




Episode 31 - Ms Hellfire

In 'From Fear To Eternity' (the previous episode with Barbus the demon), the sisters never actually mentioned his name, refering to him as 'The Fear Demon', so how is it that they suddenly knew his name in this episode?---Have a close look to the Book of Shadows, you can see it say's : the demon of fear, also known as Barbas


When Phoebe and Morris go to save M. Steadwell, Phoebe ducks into the car to avoid the explosion, but after it if you look closely, she isn't in the car then she appears out of nowhere and says "Oh my god! Everybody ok?" (Dino)


When Piper freezes Barbus in the final confrontation, the clock on the wall is positioned at 11:58, yet when she unfreezes them, the clock strikes midnght. But if Piper's power freezes everything in the room, how could the hands on the clock have moved?


When Barbus 'dies', he vanishes differently to the way he did in 'From Fear To Eternity' - it looks much more like Nicholas' death in 'That 70's Episode'.


When Barbus showed DJ his greatest fear, why didn't the man die from fear like the other victims in 'From Fear To Eternity?'


When Bane tells Prue "You're not going anywhere" you can see that he takes her left arm with his right hand. Yet in the next two shots it switches to his right hand and then back to his left. (Virginie)


When Piper froze Marcie, you can see the frozen woman's arm is up in the air. But when she unfreezes the arm is lower down, closer to her shoulder. Marcie also moves a little when Phoebe pulls the blanket off her. (Virginie)


In the beginning of the episode, Phoebe is sitting at the table eating fake Honey Nut Cheerios and Prue is talking on the phone. Piper comes in a few minutes later, Prue and Phoebe tease her, and Piper says she doesn't care that it's Friday the Thirteenth. Ms. Hellfire starts shooting up the place (as Piper later said), and early in this scene we see the bowl of cereal implode without much Hollywood sparkle. Later in the same scene, we see the same bowl implode with all necessary grandeur, Cheerios flying about two feet in the air. (Saria)




Episode 32 - Heartbreak City

Why was Cupid so cheerful all the time, even when he was dying?


When Cindy went to apologise to Max, why didn't Max yell at her? He should have still been under the influence of Drazi since Phoebe and Cupid hadn't spoken to him!


Piper and Prue are at a club waiting in line to go to the bathroom. While they are standing there talking Piper plays with her necklace. As the camera goes from a close up of Piper to a wide shot of the two, Piper plays with her necklace, and then her hand is immediately down at her side, back and forth. (Hilary)


Before the fight between Jack, Prue, Dan and Piper in the P3, the bottles of beer on the table don't have any label, but after the fight, if you look on the table, they each have one! (Virginie)


When Piper and Dan are kissing and Piper freezes him, he is halfway through saying "Is somthing wrong" but when he unfreezes he says "Is something the matter" instead. (Cian)




Episode 33- Reckless Abandon

When Piper and Phoebe are in the living room, Phoebe says "Yeah I think I know ghosts by now". Her arm is in the pillows, then on the pillows. Once again, this keeps on switching until she gets up! (Keri86)


When the ghost doesn't freeze, Piper says to Phoebe "I've frozen ghosts before, right?". When has she done this? The only episode with Piper and a ghost together was 'Dead Man Dating' and she didn't freeze any ghosts then. The only other ghost episode was 'The Power Of Two', in which Piper was in Hawaii -she didn't even get to see the ghost!


When Prue left Piper alone with the baby in the kitchen, Matthew is looking straight at the camera. (Virginie)


On one of the shots where Prue is using her powers to lift the things from her purse, we can see in the bottom of the screen that Matthew is holding a yellow teddy-bear, but in the next shot, no teddy! (Virginie)


How could Dan get in the house without waking up the sisters? Besides, don't they lock the door at night? (Virginie)


When Matthew was at Bucklands with Prue, he was in his car seat, but when they get back to the manor, they don't have it anymore. And they didn't get it back to the mother with the baby. (Virginie)


After they failed to kill the ghost with the potion, why didn't they think about vanquishing him the same way they did for the Alcatraz ghost? (Virginie)


In one of the scenes Prue is holding Matthew and then she switches him to her other side and he starts to cry, they show him while the crying is going on but if you look he's not crying, he looks perfectly fine but you can still hear crying. (Bakey17)


They very obviously used two different babies. Now I know that in show buisness a child can only work for so long but don't you think that they'd at least try to get a set of identical twins or something. Because they definitely didn't use the same baby. (Bakey17)
Next
Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1