| John Hartley (3-6) | |||||
| Opponent | School | Result | Score | Match Notes | |
| Jess Probus | Northampton | L | Dec 9-6 | ||
| Rockey Schoenberge | Nazereth | L | Dec 5-1 | ||
| Mike Chatburn | Towanda | W | Pinned 2:58 | ||
| Jay Ohora | Selinsgrove | L | Dec 5-2 | ||
| Derrick Babcock | Northeast Bradford | W | Pinned 3:19 | ||
| Chris Locke | BGA | L | Dec 5-1 | ||
| Rick Posey | Niagra Falls | W | Dec 7-1 | ||
| Jim Sindoni | Waverly | L | Dec 3-2 | ||
| Woody Smith | Danville | L | Dec 4-2 | ||