| Jim Connolly (4-5) | ||||
| Opponent | School | Result | Score | Match Notes |
| Tyler Harrison | Titusville | L | Dec 5-2 | Top Hat 1st Round |
| Ryan Kimmel | Central Dauphin | W | Dec 7-6 | Top Hat Consolation |
| Alex Renn | Shikellamy | L | Mdec 13-4 | Top Hat Consolation |
| Barry Tush | Athens | L | Dec 5-3 ot | |
| Jared Brown | North Schuykill | L | Dec 4-3 OT | |
| Zach Wagner | Lewistown | W | Mdec 9-0 | |
| Andy Bullers | Brookville | L | Mdec 12-0 | |
| Zach Wagner | Lewistown | W | Mdec 14-0 | |
| Shane Bonner | Shamokin | W | Pinned :37 | |