26th February 2005:
KIM MEDCALF You Can't Hurry Love
Richard-------------------------- "got potential"
Lesley--------------------------- "wasn't disappointed" "interesting colours"
Craig---------------------------- "confident performance" "do not like
the sound of your voice" "voic
Nick Knowles You've lost that loving feeling
Richard --------------------------"not in tune for first 10 seconds" "he did it well" "it was good"
Lesley ---------------------------- "perfect, tender, passionate" "little of out of tune at beginning" "gravely"
Carrie ----------------------------"out of tune at beginning"
Edith Bowman Hanging on the telephone
Richard ---------------------------"amazed him" "impressed him"
Craig------------------------------ "great attitude" "hated her dance break"
Lesley -----------------------------"nailed it vocally" "socked it to them"
Jon Culshaw Feel
Lesley ------------------------"tough song" "brave" "wants him to change the sound from his nose"
Richard -----------------------"dull, tuneless, lifeless"
Jon retorted in Richards voice "Dull , tuneless, lifeless, like every review you've ever given, Mr Spook"
Richard "freestyle was good at end"
Craig------------------------- "agreed with Richard" "plodding across the stage"
Jon answers back again in Simon Cowell's voice "Mr Orange man, Your not Simon Cowell"
Craig replied "I don't want to be"
Gina Yashere Crazy in Love
Richard -------------------------"beyond Beyonce" "she gave 100%"
Craig ----------------------------"fantastic" "took the stage" "you cannot sing"
Lesley ---------------------------"singing is overrated" "she was fantastic"
Adrian Edmondson Tainted
Love
Lesley -----------------------------------"really interesting" "acting performance rather than singing performance" "interesting to see him sing a ballad, more simple song"
Ade replied "I might not have to.
Lesley "I love what you do"
Richard -----------------------------------"new romantics influence Marc Almond" "very good"
Craig-------------------------------------- "bold choice in staging" "liked the voice" "moved in tune"
Carrie -------------------------------------"fantastic voice how a pop voice sounds"
Konnie Huq Genie in a Bottle
Lesley------------------------- "who would have thought a Blue Peter presenter could look so sexy" "looking fab" "you nearly inhabited it" "it could have been a bit better" "wants to see more"
"Richard ----------------------"didn't sing it very well at all" "lack of confidence, shyness" "work to do"
David-------------------------- "Konnie had one hours rehearsal, give her a chance"
Chris Colquhoun Hey ya
Craig ---------------------------------"really loved it" "great" "falsetto/range needs work"
Lesley--------------------------------- "performance of the evening" "loved his tonal range most" "strong technique, good body"
Richard -------------------------------"extraordinary well" "nothing more to add"
Jenny Ιclair If my friends
could see me now"
Craig ----------------------------------"brave effort" "lost the track" "speechless"
Lesley---------------------------------- "wouldn't give up the day job just yet"
Jenny replied "I haven't got one, what will I do?"
Lesley continues "I couldn't have kept with that track" "big performance" "fab articulation"
Richard-------------------------------- "truly dreadful" "audience enjoyed it" "for comic relief high marks" "vocally poor"
Reggie Yates Mr Boombastic
Richard ------------------------------"didn't work at all, decent effort, didn't happen" Reggie answered back "get the cobwebs out of your eyes"
Craig---------------------------------- "really liked it" "pulled it off" "want to hear more vocal"
David (to Richard)--------------------- "Elvis is dead, it worked for me"
Dawn
Steele Leave right now
Lesley------------------------------------ "difficult song, did really well" "unbelievable standard tonight, hard to criticize" "voice has air in the tone" "lot of potential"
Richard----------------------------------- "Will Young song, sung very well" "we'll hear more of you"
Craig -------------------------------------"innocent, beautiful haunting sound"
Al Murray Stuck in the
middle with you
Richard -----------------------------------"a bit Seaside Special, mike movements" "I know the songwriter and he will not be thrilled" "not too bad" "middle lower marking of tonight's performances"
Craig-------------------------------------- "awkward, cheesy"
Al said "I wanted it like that, I hit my mark"
Lesley------------------------------------- "monotonous" "you had fun, enjoyed it"
Debra Stephenson
Young hearts run free
Richard ------------------------------------"hard to go last, very good performance" "you can do better than that, looking forward to hearing you in next shows"
Craig ---------------------------------------"great performance" "voice does not match your body" "you sing like a six year old girl" "helium"
Carrie --------------------------------------"for this disco song, like Tina Maria, voice perfect for song"
Lesley --------------------------------------"sang well" "more in there" "with work it could improve"
The ten students that had received the most votes and were through to Wednesday's show~ Debra, Dawn, Reggie, Konnie, Adrian, Gina, Edith, Chris, Nick and Kim. The judges then voted, Craig choose Al, Lesley went for Jenny and Richard Park also selected Jenny. She then joined the others to take part in the student vote. Before they voted, Cat asked Jon if he had anything to say to the voting celebs. He said "I'd like another go, easier songs to come, you're all lovely and I want to a bit more time with you" Al asked the same question by Cat answered "I was going to sing a Rolf Harris song next, I was looking forward to it" The students then voted: Debra Jon, Dawn Jon, Reggie Al, Konnie Jon, Adrian Al, Gina Al, Edith Jon, Chris Al, Nick Jon, Kim Jon and Jenny who said she should have been going home on the night bus voted for Al. With six votes to five and keeping his place it was Jon Culshaw.
raised more than £33,000 for Comic Relief
