In the Lopez-Fitzgerald backyard, Hank tells Luis that he hasn't given Sheridan a chance. Luis tells him to drop it, they will never agree. Inside, Miguel tells Charity that miracles do happen. Luis and Hank go inside and Luis asks Charity if she found here aunt? Charity says no, and she never will because she has to get home to her mom because they are moving. Charity tells Miguel that she wants to go say goodbye to Theresa and Whitney before they leave. Hank tells Miguel that he's really grown up since he's been gone. Hank says he's missed them both, but he's also missed their mom's cooking. Hank asks if there is any news on his pop and Antoinio, but Luis says don't ask. Miguel tells them later, and leaves to take Charity home. Luis asks Hank to come by the center and teach the kids how to play pool, but Hank says he has to get a job and build up his nest-egg so he can leave Harmony. Charity returns from saying goodbye to Theresa and Whitney, and Luis says Miguel is waiting outback for her. Luis asks her to fax or email him a picture of her mom, if her twin is in Harmony than he will find her. Charity thanks him, but says it will be too late because she is moving tomorrow. Luis tells her not to give up, his brother will be able to help her. Charity thanks them both and heads out back where Miguel is fixing his bike. CHarity panics when she learns it won't start and says she should take a cab. Miguel tells her that he will fix it and she will get her home on time. They talk about their special bond and how they have to fight to be together. Miguel gives his bike another try and gets it to start. Charity hopes on his bike and they prepare to take off.
BAck inside, Luis laughs at Hank because he's shoveling food in his mouth faster than lightening. Luis wishes Charity had an older sister because it's been a long time since he met a girl who made him feel like Miguel does. Luis tells Hank about his date with Beth. Hank says everything thought they would marry after they were named king and queen of the prom, but Luis says his first responsibility is to his family now. Luis asks Hank who his date is with, but Hank doesn't think he wants to know. Luis realizes he is going out with Sheridan Crane. Luis tells him that he's in for a disappointment, she'll never go out with him! Luis says he is from the wrong side of the tracks, he'll never have a relationship with that woman. Hank tells him that he'll make him eat those words, Sheridan will show up for their date tonight. Hank calls Sheridan up to make sure their date is still on. Sheridan totally forgot about their date, but says she will be there as long as he doesn't bring Luis! Luis shines his shoes in the living room when Pilar comes home. Pilar asks if he is going out tonight? Luis says he has a date with Beth at the lobster shack.
Outside, Sam tells Grace that Charity must be her niece, it makes perfect sense. Tabitha and Timmy watch them talk from affair and Tabitha thinks that they have no idea that Charity is Grace's niece. She can't believe what she had to do to keep them from seeing Charity. Timmy tells Tabitha that if their was an Olympic medal for deviants, she'd win the gold medal! Timmy and Tabby go inside and Tabitha says this calls for a celebration. Timmy says he'll make some MarTimmies. Back outside, Grace tells Sam that she has to meet Charity. Sam says maybe they are still at the house, so the rush over there. Grace begins to wonder if there is anything to the evil Faith mentioned, but Sam says there is nothing to that hocus pockus nonsense.
At the Bennett house, Simone lectures Kay on why she should care about what she could be doing to her mom by keeping Charity from seeing her. Kay says Miguel should be hers and she'd trade a cousin for Miguel any day. Simone asks if she would really destroy her mom's chance to find her past? Kay says she is positive that Charity is not her cousin. Grace and Sam show up looking for Charity, and Kay says she is gone. Grace asks if she said where she was going, and Kay lies to her mom and says no. She asks what is going on, and Sam tells his daughter than Charity might be her mom's niece. Kay's eyes widen, and Simone gives her an "I told you so look." Grace explains to her that she has a twin sister and a niece, and Kay freaks out even more because Charity was looking for her mom's twin. Sam logs onto the net to try and find Faith, but she is not online. Grace fears that her sister might have been right about the forces of evil, but Sam thinks Faith's fears are a little out there. Simone tells Kay that everything fits together and she should tell her mom where Charity is. Kay says she will tell her, and Simone says "finally!" Grace goes on and on how wonderful it would be to have her sister and niece here, and how happy Miguel would be if Charity could stay in Harmony. Simone tells Kay to tell her, but Kay says she can't lose Miguel and tells her mom that what she had to tell her wasn't important. Grace feels that something is trying to keep her and Charity apart, and she fears she'll never meet her sister. Grace tells her that it will be a piece of cake to find Faith, and he calls information. Sam learns that Faith has an unlisted number, so it will take time to find her. Simone asks Kay how she could lie to her mother when she can see how upset she is. Simone tells Kay that if she doesn't tell her mom where to find Charity, she will! Kay says she can't tell her mom, so Simone tells her to do it. Kay says she doesn't believe Charity's mom is her cousin, God wouldn't be so cruel. SHe says Charity and her mom are nuts, she is doing this to protect her mom. Simone tells her bull, she is doing this for Miguel. Kay kinda blackmails Simone into keeping quiet by threatening to tell her mom all the horrible things that she has done. When Kay says she is not telling her mom, Grace shows up and asks what she is not telling her? Kay says she just worries about her, and fears Charity and her mother might be taking advantage of her. Grace is positive Faith is her sister, but fears she may never meet her. Simone tells Kay that her mother doesn't deserve this, but Kay says she can't lose Miguel. Simone tells Sam and Grace that she totally forgot, Miguel took Charity to his house to get his motor cycle. Sam and Grace take off, and Kay slaps Simone and calls her a traitor!
Tabitha is sitting on her couch eating chocolates and Timmy serves up two MarTimmies. Timmy tells her that this is a new recipe, these are Hawaiian MarTimmies. She asks what the difference between the two are, and Timmy says it is the umbrella in the drink of course. Tabitha tells Timmy that she wishes he could have seen her when she scared Faith over the computer. Timmy asks how she can do all those amazing things? Tabitha says she is a master of her craft. Timmy asks her if there is anything she is afraid of? Tabitha says nothing because she has the powers. As Tabitha tells him that nothing scares ole Tabby, a red fog seeps out from under the door to the basement. Tabitha goes to the basement where she is bathed in red light, and Timmy wonders what is going on down there. Tabitha tells "it" that there is no reason to be angry, she accomplished her mission, she took care of Faith and Charity. Whatever it is talks to Tabitha via telepathy, and Tabitha says she understands that if she fails it will take away her powers. She then says "You mean there is something worse than not having my powers?" Tabitha's face is overcome with an expression of fear and she says "No, not that, anything but that!" Timmy calls to Tabitha, but she doesn't answer. BAck in the basement, Tabitha promises it that she will finish the job and begs not to be punished. Tabitha screams out "No!" and Timmy yells to Tabitha asking if she is okay and what they are doing to her?
In the living room, Pilar tells Luis that she is glad he is going out with Beth tonight, she really likes her. Luis says it will be nice to get out with a girl who isn't arrogant, like Sheridan is. Pilar tells Luis that she needs to talk to him about Sheridan. Luis asks why? Pilar asks him to please try not to be harsh with Sheridan. Luis thinks Sheridan has manipulated her into talking to him. Despite Pilar telling him that it was her idea, Luis believes that Sheridan threatened to fire his mom unless she talked to him about backing off of her. Pilar says that Sheridan didn't even want her to talk to him. Luis says good because he doesn't want to talk about her. He gives his mom a kiss and says they should talk about something more pleasant.
At the Standishes, Faith is busy packing and while waiting for Charity to return. SHe is worried sick about her daughter and says as soon as she gets home they are leaving and never coming back.
Grace and Sam are on the way to the Lopez-Fitzgerald house to meet Charity. Grace can't bear it if they got away because she might lose her family forever. At the Lopez- Fiztgerald place, Miguel and Charity hop on Miguel's bike. CHarity tells Miguel that after tonight she may never see him again. Miguel tells her that it will work out. Charity puts her helmet on, but Miguel's bike won't start again. She takes the helmet off and Miguel assures her that he'll get her home on time. CHarity says her mom is so set on moving. Miguel tells her that they have to fight for their miracle, but Charity saying it is so hard trying to stay positive. She tells Miguel that she doesn't want to leave him, Harmony, and all her new friends. She fears that if she moves away she may never see him again.
Grace and Sam arrive at the Lopez-Fiztgerald house and Pilar and Luis tell them that Miguel and Charity are out back. Luis asks what is going on, but Sam says they are in a hurry and can't explain right now. Sam and Grace run through the house, only to look out the kitchen window and see Miguel and Charity zoom off on Miguel's bike. Sam asks to borrow Luis' car, but Luis says he left it at the youth center. Grace says they can't let them leave, she may never find her again. Grace explains to Pilar and the others that she found her twin sister and thinks that Charity is her niece. Luis and Hank offer to cancel their dates to help, but Sam says there is nothing they can do right now. Hank decides to go out on his date, and Luis suggests Sam search for Castleton for them. Sam says he doesn't know where in Castleton she lives. Luis says he overheard Charity say they were moving tonight. Grace thinks she'll never see her twin, but Pilar says there is always hope. Pilar and Grace pray, and Sam comes up with an idea, but says it will be risky. Sam and Luis leave the room, and Sam calls a friend who is a computer expert and asks him to get him Faith's phone number and address no matter what the cost. Sam says he is breaking the rules, but he is willing to accept the punishment. Sam tells Grace about his plan to find Faith, and then they leave.
Luis tells his mom that he has to go get ready for his date with Beth, but Pilar says they need to talk about Sheridan. Pilar tells Luis that he knows Sheridan's family is rich and powerful, but her life has never been easy. Luis tells his mom that Sheridan mentioned that she helped her out once, and he asks what that was about? Pilar says it is not important, she just wants him to show Sheridan some kindness for her sake. Luis tells his mom that he loves and respects her, but he is going to do his job and carry out the judge's orders. Pilar asks if he has to be hard with Sheridan? Luis tells her not to worry about Sheridan, she is not a fragile flower. Luis says he has seen the real Sheridan Crane and she is one tough cookie. Pilar knows otherwise and tells him that Sheridan is not as strong as he thinks she is. Luis doesn't care and says he's more worried about Hank, who has gone to pick up Sheridan at the mansion. He hopes Hank doesn't run into Ethan.
At the Crane Mansion, Ethan comes into the living room and learns his aunt has a date at the Lobster Shack. Sheridan tells Ethan that she could use a relaxing night out before she starts her community service tomorrow. However, Ethan is not happy when he learns Sheridan is going out with one of Luis' friends named Hank. Ethan can't believe this news and says they have talked about her only dating members from her own class. Sheridan says it will be fine, Hank is a nice guy and is smart. She tells Ethan that she wants to go out, besides it beats sitting around here. Ethan asks what she knows about this man? Sheridan says he is nice, he helped her out when her car stalled. Ethan tells her that maybe she doesn't need a night out, she just needs driving lessons! Sheridan playfully smacks him on the arm and tells him to stop. Ethan tells Sheridan that he wants to see her happy, but ever since she came home she's acted like the weight of the world is on her shoulders. Sheridan says this house brings back so many bad memories. Ethan tells her to forget about the past and think about her future. Sheridan says that is why she wants to go out with Hank, she needs to get her mind off of things. Ethan doesn't want to see her get involved with another Jean- Luc, but Sheridan says she is not going to get involved with Hank. Ethan still wishes she'd get involved with someone from their own class because local guys like Hank may be out to use her. Sheridan tells him that it is only a date! Ethan makes her promise not to get into any trouble with Hank tonight.
Ethan and Sheridan go out to the cottage where Sheridan lives. Sheridan thanks Ethan for keeping her company while she gets ready. Ethan wishes she would stay in the main house, but Sheridan says she hasn't sleep there since that night. Ethan wishes he could meet Hank, but Sheridan says she told him to meet her at the Lobster Shack. SOmeone rings Sheridan's doorbell, and when she answers it she finds Hank standing there with a red rose. She asks what he is doing here, and Hank tells her "good evening to you to!" Hank hands her a perfectly beautiful rose because she is a perfectly beautiful woman. Sheridan tells him that she said he would meet him at the Lobster Shack, but Hank said he didn't want to give her the opportunity to run out on him if she didn't like him. However, this way he is her ride home, so he can try to convince her what a great guy he is if things don't go well. Ethan, who is on the couch, makes a face like he wants to throw up. Sheridan invites Hank in and introduces him to Ethan. Sheridan leaves to change, and Hank tries to make small talk with Ethan. Hank tells Ethan that he knows a lot of people in town resent the Cranes, but he knows they have given many people in Harmony jobs and thinks it is commendable what his family has done for the community. Ethan thanks him. Ethan and Hank sit down and Ethan talks with Hank about his traveling. Hank says that his mom always told him he was born under a wandering star. Ethan asks Hank if he is staying in Harmony long? Hank says he doesn't know. He says that his original plan was to stay long enough to build a nest egg and then hit the road. However, he says he thinks he'll stick around for a while an see what happens. When Ethan asks him what he does for a living. Hank laughs and says he hasn't been grilled like this before a date since high school. Hank asks Ethan if he gives all his aunt's dates the third degree, or just those who are friends of Luis'? Ethan says he does not respect Luis because he has nothing but contempt for the Cranes. Hank defends Luis and says that he shouldn't judge him based on Luis, judge him based on his own merits. Ethan shakes Hank's hand and tells him that he is a straight shooter, and he likes that. Sheridan returns in a black satin dress, and Ethan leaves for his date with Gwen. He whispers good look in Sheridan's ear and says Hank seems like an okay guy. SHeridan tells Hank that she will let him drive her to the Lobster Shack as long as Luis' name is not mentioned tonight. Hank tells her that they have a deal.
On the way to Castleton, Miguel's bike dies again, but luckily it happens near a garage. Charity calls her mom from the garage and says she is on her way home. Faith tells Charity that they are leaving this place tonight. Charity asks why, what about her twin? Faith says that wasn't her twin, the forces of darkness may have deceived her (Charity) just like they did her (Faith) earlier today on the computer. Faith remembers the computer incident and tells Charity that as soon as she gets home they are leaving! After the phone call, Charity tells Miguel that they are moving tonight. Miguel tells her that if this is their last night together, they should make the most of it. Miguel asks Charity to dance with him, but she says she won't. Miguel asks if he did something to upset her, but she says no. Charity tells him that she won't dance with him because she doesn't know how to dance. Miguel says they danced the samba at his mother's party? Charity says that was different, she was fooling around like Kay and Simone were, they didn't know how to samba either. However, she's never danced with a boy alone. Miguel asks if he can be the first, and she accepts the offer. Miguel and Charity slow dance around the garage. Charity wishes this would never end. Miguel says it won't because they will get their miracle. The mechanic interrupts and tells Miguel that his bike is almost ready. Charity realizes it is all over, but Miguel says he knows a way they can be together. Miguel says he knows who can tell them who her aunt is. Charity asks who, and Miguel says me!
At Faith's place, Faith lights a candle and asks God to spare her daughter. Suddenly, a wind blows out the candle Faith lit. Faith re-lights the candle and says she won't let them take her daughter from her! Grace asks God to give her the strength to survive the evil forces who are after her daughter this night.
Sam takes Grace to the church and leaves her to go to the station to see if his buddy has found out anything. Grace tells him not to get into trouble because of her, but Sam says he would do anything to make her happy. After Sam leaves, Grace kneels before the statue of the little girl, who comes to life! The little girl tells Grace that she will need courage for what will happen tonight. She tells her that if she gives in, all will be lost for her and her family!
Sheridan and Hank show up at the Lobster Shack and Hank tells him not to worry, she won't see Luis here. He says that Luis is out with an old girlfriend from high school tonight. Sheridan jokes Beth is one lucky girl. Hank makes Sheridan promise not to talk about Luis tonight, and she says he is right, she doesn't want to talk about Luis tonight. Fred Barnes, the owner, shows Hank and Sheridan to their table. He apologizes for the wait and says that the crowd has picked up since he started hiring local entertainment. Sheridan says she is looking forward to having fun this night. Hank asks "Just this night? Why?" Sheridan tells him it is just some old memories he doesn't want to know about. Hank says he wants to know everything about her. Sheridan ends up turning the conversation back to Hank and his travels. She asks if he ever plans on settling down? Hank says he wants to create an empire for his family and kids, and the wife he will have one day. Hank and Sheridan order their appetizers, and then go to the tank to choose their lobsters. While they are up, Luis and Beth show up and decide to just take Sheridan and Hank's table! A waiter brings them the appetizers, and even though they didn't order them, they start eatting them! Sheridan and Hank return, and Sheridan says "Oh no!" Luis says "I can't believe it!" Luis and Hank ask for another table, but Fred says he doesn't have any and they should share. When Hank mentions to Luis that Sheridan doesn't want to deal with him this evening, Luis decides that Sheridan will have to have dinner with him whether she likes it or not! Sheridan is not pleased to learn she has to share a table with Luis. Unfortunately, the waiter tells Beth and Luis that there are no more appetizers, they ran out of everything, so they will have to eat what they started to. Another waiter then brings the lobsters for Sheridan and Hank to inspect, and tells them to be careful because one of the bands around the lobster's claw broke. Unfortunately for Luis, the waiter is clumsy and dumps them in his lap! Luis is spared any pain and gives them back to the waiter. A magician takes the stage, and Luis says he thought this night couldn't get any worse. The magician performs a few tricks, but they bore the audience. He decides to perform the highlight of the evening, the world famous disappearance act. The magician chooses SHeridan, and she suggests he make Luis disappear. When Luis says "If your looking for help, you've picked the wrong lady," Sheridan decides to help him. SHe asks what she has to do? Tha magician opens up his magic box, and Sheridan doesn't look pleased. The magician asks her to get in the box to make her disappear. Sheridan remembers seeing the body with the sheet over it being lifted into a coffin when she was a child. She says she can't get in there, but the magician tells her not to worry. People chant out "do it!" Sheridan eventually gets inside, and the magician bolts it shut. Sheridan asks to be let out, but nobody can hear her.
At the garage, Miguel tells Charity that all he has to do is look at her mother, and he will know who her twin is! Charity says that her mom doesn't care that she saw her sister, she thinks they are still in danger and wants to leave tonight. The man at the garage tells them that the bike is fixed, so Miguel and Charity pay him, Miguel was short a dollar fifty. Miguel and Charity hop on his bike and take off.
Tabitha and Timmy are out looking for Charity. Tabitha is driving along and tells Timmy that they are doomed if Charity and Grace reunite. Timmy tells her to burn rubber baby! Tabitha stops at a gas station for gas, the same station Miguel and Charity left moments earlier, and tells the man that she is looking for two teenagers on a motorcycle. The guy asks why, so Tabitha says the girl is her niece and she needs to give her her medication. He tells her that they just took off thataway, and points in the general direction. Tabitha jumps in her car and starts it, and Timmy reminds her that she's still hooked up to the gas pump. Tabitha says she knows that, and drives forward a bit. The gas pump is yanked out of her car, and gas spurts everywhere. She then lights a match, sets the book on fire, and tosses it out the window! The gas station explodes as Tabitha cackles and drives away.
At the church, the lights go out and the angel statue comes to life and tells Grace that she must be strong tonight, if she gives in it will be the end of everything, all will be lost for her and her family. Grace asks her what she means, is her sister in danger? The girl says all will happen tonight, and then turns back into a statue. Grace grabs someone and says "I got you!" When the lights come back on, she is holding Eve. TC comes in and Grace asks why they are here? TC Says Sam asked them to come take her home. Grace explains that the statue came to life and became the little girl again. TC and Eve are puzzled, and Eve says maybe the lights played tricks on her when they went out. Grace says she is not crazy, but Eve says what she is saying is not possible. Eve says perhaps she is overwhelmed by finding and losing her sister, but Grace says she knows what she saw and heard and that something terrible is going to happen to her.
At the Standish home, Faith is still talking to God. She asks him to give her the strength to fight the battle of her life tonight. Faith hears Miguel's bike pull up, but Timmy and Tabitha are right behind them. Charity tells Miguel that she should go in first to make sure her mom is all right. Inside, Faith tells CHarity that she wishes she could believe the person in Harmony was her sister, but it could be an imposter. Faith says she trusts no one in Harmony, not even Miguel. Charity begs her mom to meet Miguel for a few second. Tabitha, who is spying on them through a window, says she can't let this happen and casts a wind spell. The wind begins to blow inside the house and Faith says she will leave right away if they stop the wind. The wind stops, and Faith tells Charity that they can't trust anyone, not even Miguel. Faith thinks Miguel sent the wind, but Charity refuses to believe that. Faith tells Charity that they have to leave right away. Miguel yells "What is wrong?" Faith tells Charity to get rid of him, so she says she will. Charity goes to the door in tears and tells Miguel that his mom won't let him see her. Miguel yells to Faith that he can help her, but she screams "Go Away!" Charity tells him it is over, there is nothing they can do. She tells Miguel that if he cares about her to go. They hug when they realize this is goodbye. Charity says she'll call him when she learns where she will be living, and Miguel says he'll never forget her. Charity says she won't forget him, and asks him to go because the longer he stays the harder it will be to say goodbye. Miguel gets on his bike and drives away. Charity goes back inside and her mother tells her that one day she will realize they had to move as far away from here as possible.
Tabitha thinks that she has succeeded, and after she has rested and restored her powers, she will find Faith and Charity whenever they go and will crush them like bugs. Timmy and Tabby drive home, and Timmy asks her what she has to do to restore her powers. Tabitha says he doesn't want to know, but now that she has taken care of things she doesn't have to resort to emergency measures.
Eve and TC take Grace home, and she asks them not mention what happened to the girls. Inside, Jessica shows her mom the fliers she's making to help Charity find her aunt. Grace tells her that she doesn't think they'll need them because she has found her twin-sister. Jessica realizes that Charity is her cousin, and she is thrilled. However, Grace fears she may never see them again if they don't find them before they move. Jessica says it will all work out. Grace asks where Kay is, she'd like to thank her for trying to help her find Charity. Jessica is shocked to learn that Kay helped, but Grace corrects herself and says Simone actually helped. Jessica doesn't know where Kay is, but says she will look around for her. Jessica returns later, she hasn't found Kay. Sam calls Grace and tells her that he has Faith's number. As she writes it down, Miguel shows up. Miguel knows that her mom is Charity's aunt, his mom told her. Miguel comes inside, and Grace calls Faith. Unfortunately, nobody answers and she fears that Faith has left town. However, Miguel refuses to hang up. Eve and TC have to leave, and Grace tells them not to worry about her.
Back at the Standish home, Faith and Charity are carrying the last of the boxes to their car. Charity hears the phone ringing and wants to answer it, but Faith says it is too dangerous for her to go back inside. Charity goes back inside anyways and answers the phone. Miguel tells Charity that he knows who her mom's sister is, it is Mrs. Bennett!
Back at the church, Father Lonagin feels the angel statue and realizes it is crying. He says that there are souls in jeopardy tonight.
Kay finds Simone sitting alone in the park, and says she wouldn't blame her if she never talked to her again. Kay approaches Simone and says she is sorry, but Simone tells her to just leave her alone. Kay asks her to understand, she lost it when she thought she could lose Miguel forever. Simone tells Kay that she's lost more than Miguel, she's lost her best friend! Kay says she didn't mean it, but Simone tells her that all she thinks about is her feelings, not Miguel's or her mom's. Kay says if her mom's twin loved her she would have found her by now. Kay says she, her brother, sister, and her dad are her real family. Simone can't believe what she is hearing. Kay is positive that she can get Miguel to love her if Charity isn't around, and after he loves her then she'll help her mom find her sister. Simone can't believe she would make her mom wait months or years to find her sister again. When Kay says "She's waited twenty years, what's a few more months?" Simone says "I can't believe you, I don't understand you at all!" Simone says it is pointless, either her mom has found Charity by now, or Charity is long gone. Simone asks Kay if she knows what she did was wrong? Kay admits what she did was wrong and she'll never do it again. Kay says she is not a bad person, and asks Simone if she thinks she is a bad person? Simone begrudgingly says "No of course not." Simone wants to remain friends with her, but tells her that she has a real problem when it comes to guys. She tells her that there are other guys out there, but Kay only wants Miguel. She says she wants to walk into the prom on Miguel's arm to prove she is as good as anyone else, and that someone can love her. Simone says she hopes it happens, but she doesn't want to see her get hurt or hurt someone else for a guy. Kay and Simone make up, and hug. Kay says that she knows her mom missed meeting Charity, and since Jessica isn't here to rub it in her face, she obviously hasn't found out where they live. Kay then asks Simone for some help getting Miguel. She promises Simone to find her a date for the prom after she helps her get Miguel.
At the Bennetts house, Miguel tells Charity on the phone that Grace Bennett is her mom's twin! Sam arrives home, and Grace thinks she's finally going to meet her family. Grace suddenly gets a chill and feels frightened. Grace tells Sam that the little girl warned her about danger and evil, but Sam tells her the little girl was just her imagination. He assures her that there is nothing to be afraid of. At the Standish home, Faith yells at Charity to get off the phone. Charity tells Miguel that her mom doesn't believe her sister is in town and trusts no one. Miguel asks Grace to talk to Charity, and hands her the phone. Grace introduces herself as her aunt Grace, and Charity asks her how she knows she is her aunt for sure? Grace says the woman she saw from the bus was her, she remembers seeing a girl on the bus trying to get off. Faith comes inside and tells Charity to hang up, but Charity says they are not going anywhere! Charity tells her mom that she is talking to her sister on the phone, her name is Grace Bennett and she lives in Harmony. Charity asks her mom to talk to her, but Faith says no. Charity tells her mom that she talked to her before and liked her. Faith still suspects it might not be her sister, but Charity trusts Miguel. She says that if she and her sister get back together, than evil can't hurt them. Back at the Bennett house, Tabitha pokes her nosy little head inside the door and spies on Grace. Faith eventually says hello to Grace, who is suspicious of her. Grace swears on the life of her children that she isn't lying to her. She wishes she could remember something from her past to prove to Faith that she is her sister. Faith says she wants to believe her. Grace asks what happened on the computer to make her doubt her? Faith says she was deceived! Tabitha walks inside and asks what is going on? Miguel fills her in on what is going on. Faith gets a bad vibe and tells Grace that she has to hang up. Grace begins to cough, and Faith asks her if she is sick? Grace says no, she coughs when she is nervous. Faith's face lights up and realizes it is really her sister because Grace used to cough when she was nervous. Faith tells Grace that she'll explain everything to her tomorrow. Grace says she and Sam wanted to visit her tonight, but Faith says she is tired and needs rest, plus there is evil out tonight. Grace says she was warned about the same thing, and tells Faith about the angel girl. Faith asks exactly what the little girl told her, so Grace relays the message. Faith tells her sister that the little girl is very real, she is an angel who has protected them for years. Faith once again tells Grace not to come over until tomorrow, she wants everything to be perfect when they meet. Grace asks if she is going to stay, and Faith says she is because the angels have brought them together again. A very sickly looking Tabitha excuses herself and leaves. Jessica is so thrilled that Charity is their cousin and is staying in Harmony, and she plans to go find Kay and tell her right now! Faith and Grace are about to say goodbye, but Charity asks to talk to Miguel. Charity and Miguel are both thrilled that she is staying. Sam hugs Grace, who is still worried about the little girl's warnings. Sam tells Grace that the little girl was obviously wrong.
Back in the park, Kay tells Simone her plans to make sure Miguel thinks of her as his woman and not his friend. Jessica shows up with a big grin on her face. Jessica says she has very good news, Charity is their cousin! Kay's eyes widen and she screams "No!"
Tabitha goes home to find Fluffy attacking Timmy, she ripped his smoking jacket. Tabitha says they have bigger problems, Faith and Charity are staying. Timmy asks what they are going to do now? Tabitha says she has to destroy Faith and Charity before dawn. Timmy asks how she will do that without her powers? She tells him it is time to instigate emergency measures, she has to go down to the basement! Timmy drops his glass out of fright. Tabitha says going downstairs is the only way she can get her powers back. She tells him that this is a fight to the finish. Tabitha goes to the basement door and warns Timmy not to open the door, no matter what he hears and smells. She says everything she has fought for over the centuries will come to head tonight. Tabitha opens the door to the red lit basement. Timmy, who is at the top of the stairs, asks what the smell is. Tabitha says it is sulphur. Tabitha announces that she is coming down, and descends.
At the Lobster Shack, Sheridan is trapped inside of the magician box and is screaming for help. Sheridan remembers standing over a coffin as a child asking how they will breath in there? A man tells her that they won't because they are dead, and she is a wicked wicked girl. Sheridan cries that she is not wicked. Back in the present, Sheridan says she is not wicked and cries to be let out. Back in the past, a young Sheridan says she didn't mean to do it, but a man tells her yes she did. Luis and Hank hear Sheridan crying for help, so they make the magician open the box. Unfortunately, the lock is stuck! Hank tells Sheridan not to panic, they will get her out. Inside the box, Sheridan continues to cry that she didn't mean to do it and she's sorry. Luis works to pick the lock, but it is stuck. Hank says they should just lift the door up of the hinges, but the magician says the only way to open it is to remove the bolt. Luis goes for an axe to break open the box, and when he returns he breaks the lock. Luis lifts a crying Sheridan out of the box. He tells her that she is safe and takes her outside. Luis and Sheridan sit down on a bench and Sheridan continues to cry that it wasn't her fault. Beth comes out with Luis jacket, which Luis puts on Sheridan's shoulders, and Beth asks why she keeps saying that? Luis says he doesn't know. Hank comes out and says it wasn't her fault, the lock broke. Sheridan says she didn't mean to do it. Sheridan looks at Luis and asks him what he's doing here, he wasn't there that night? Luis asks Hank what she means,and Hank says she is just disoriented. Hank dries her tears and tells her that she was locked in a magician's box. Sheridan snaps to and says she wants to go home. Hank says he will take her home, but Luis wants to know what she meant when she said it wasn't her fault? Hank tells Luis to back off, but Luis wants to know what she was accused of. Hank says whatever it was it wasn't her fault, but Luis says Sheridan thinks it was. Sheridan coldly looks at Luis and says she doesn't have to explain herself to him, and she and Hank leave. Beth thinks that Sheridan has claustrophobia, but Luis doesn't believe that because she wouldn't have climbed into the box. Whatever is going on, Luis finds it very interesting.
Hank drives Sheridan back home, and Sheridan asks if she said anything else when she was in that box? Hank says only that it wasn't her fault and she didn't mean it. Hank apologizes for this night and asks to make it up to her next weekend. Sheridan says she never should have come back.
At the Book Cafe, Whitney is reading a magazine article about how a healthy sex life improves ones tennis performance. In the picture accompanying the article, Whitney sees herself and Frank Lomax kissing. SHe tells herself that she has been spending way too much time with Theresa. Frank shows up and sees Whitney. He says hello to her and asks if she is waiting for Theresa? She says no, so he asks if she's waiting for a boyfriend? Whitney says she doesn't have a boyfriend. Frank asks if he can join her, but she says "you can't!" Frank asks why, and she says she is in the middle of a really good article and won't be able to talk. Frank says he'll take that chance, besides he won't be long. Whitney claims to be reading an article about tennis racquets, but Frank grabs her magazine and sees that she was reading about sex increasing one's tennis game. Frank laughs and asks her if it does? Whitney says they are just saying that to sell magazines. Frank tells her that people in town say she has what it takes to be a champ, and maybe he'll schedule a few lessons. Frank realizes she is nervous and tells her not to be, he was wrong when he thought she knew more about the stalker than she was letting on. Theresa shows up, and Whitney starts to choke on her pizza. Theresa doesn't realize she is sitting with Frank. Frank gets up and performs the Heimlich on her. Theresa sees Frank and runs for it. Theresa hides behind a counter, and Frank pays for his pizza and leaves. Theresa stands up, and ends up getting pizza dough thrown on her head. Frank sees that on his way out and just laughs, not knowing it is the stalker. The pizza guy takes the dough off of her, and Whitney tells her she came so close to getting caught. Theresa just teases Whitney about having Frank's arms around her. Theresa says next time she is around Ethan she is going to fake choking as well. Outside, Frank wonders why Whitney was so nervous, and decides to go back inside and check things out.
In the park, Kay accuses Jessica of pulling another one of her jokes, but Jessica says this is no joke, Charity's mom and theirs are talking on the phone right now. Kay blurts out "You were right Simone! Of all the people who could be my cousin. Why me?" Jessica realizes that Kay knew Charity was their cousin before she told her, and asks how long she suspected Charity was their cousin? Kay claims she didn't, but Jessica remembers that the picture of their mom on the refrigerator is gone and she took it so Charity couldn't see it! Kay claims not to know what she is talking about, but Jessica calls her a liar and can't believe she didn't tell their mom the truth. Kay says she didn't know for sure, and Jessica accuses her of trying to keep the truth from mom and Charity. Kay says it all worked out anyways, so what does it matter? She says everyone is happy but her because she lost Miguel. Jessica tells Kay that what she did is despicable and she is going to tell their parents and Miguel immediately. Kay tells her to stop, if she rats her out it will break mom and dad's heart. Jessica says she won't tell them because it will break their hearts, but she will tell Miguel everything, he will know she is a sneaky little B-I-T-C-H! Simone asks her not to, but Jessica says Kay did this to herself. Kay asks her sister what it will take to keep her mouth shut? She offers her her cell phone and her whole allowance for a year, but Jessica says she is not cutting any deals this time. Kay says at least do it for the people she loves. Jessica says she won't tell Miguel, for now. However, she will have to live with the fear that she could rat on her at any time. Kay tells Jessica that she knows what she did was wrong, but she is too young to understand what people do for true love. JEssica can't believe she is still thinking of herself, and then leaves. Simone tells Kay that she has lost Miguel for good, but Kay says she won't give up on Miguel! Kay says she deserves Miguel, and would go to any lengths to have him. Simone says it is over, but Kay says she still has one more night to try and get Miguel. Kay plans to get Miguel alone and tell him how she feels.
Miguel and Charity are talking on the computer when Grace suddenly gets a chill. Grace says that the little girl warned her something would change her life tonight. Sam says she found her sister, and that there was no little girl, it was just her imagination. Sam tells her that she should get to bed, but Grace says she won't be able to sleep tonight. Sam tells her that if she wants to see her sister tonight, she will. Sam and Grace go out for a drive, but Grace doesn't think this is a good idea. Back at the Bennett house, Miguel is still talking to Charity, telling her all about how they can go to the Halloween dance together. Grace and Sam return, and Sam asks to talk to CHarity. Miguel asks where they went, and Grace says they went to an electronics store to pick up a web-cam for their computer. Grace says if Faith has one, she and her sister will be able to talk to one another. At the Standish home, Charity and Faith hook up their camera to her computer, but Faith still senses evil out there. As Sam hooks up the computer, Grace thinks she should drop by and see how Tabitha is doing. Sam tells her not to go now, he almost has everything ready. They get it all set up, and Charity talks to her aunt Grace. Charity can't believe how much she looks like her mom! Grace tells her that she is as pretty as she imagined. Charity asks if she can call her aunt Grace, and Grace tells her that she better. Charity goes to get her mom, and says she can see aunt Grace now. Faith sits at the computer and they are overjoyed to see one another. Grace tells her that she wanted to see her in person, but Faith says it is better to wait until the morning when the sun is out and the powers of those who want to hurt them is weaker. Grace doesn't understand, and Faith says the amnesia must have wiped out what their mother and grandmother taught them. Faith tells her that she will tell her tomorrow in person, but she wants her to believe that there are powers who want to destroy them, especially if they learned that they found one another. Grace asks what would happen if they did know? Faith says tragedy, disaster, Armageddon! Faith asks her to get here at dawn tomorrow. Grace invites her and Charity to live with them, and Faith says she would like that. Charity blurts out "me too!" Later, Miguel and Charity talk on the computer. Jessica comes home and talks with Charity on the computer. Kay and Simone arrive shortly, and Kay pretends to be happy for her mom. She is sickened when she watches Miguel and Charity talk to one another.
At Tabitha's house, Timmy is afraid for Tabitha, who has gone into the basement to recharge her powers. Downstairs, Tabitha bids her master hello and asks for his help in destroying Faith and Charity. SHe asks her master to help her keep Faith and Grace from meeting. Timmy listens at the basement door as Tabitha casts a spell against Grace and Faith. Back upstairs, Timmy hears Tabitha scream and he yells out "Tabitha, Tabitha, Timmy's sweet princess, are you okay? Timmy says if it wasn't for Faith and her brat, Timmy and Tabitha would be sipping MarTimmies and watching Endora on Bewitched. The door to the basement swings open, and Timmy thinks Tabitha is playing a joke on him. Suddenly, Timmy hears growling come from the basement. Timmy tells Tabitha not to scare him like this. Suddenly, a dog comes up the steps and barks at Timmy, who screams his head off.