Tension mounts as David accuses Sam of loving Ivy more than Grace. Before Sam can punch David, Pilar rushes in to announce Ivy is out of surgery and needs him. Sam starts off, but stops when David says Sam's concern just proved his point. Once her husband leaves, Grace blasts David. Meanwhile, Sam is affected by Ivy's weak appearance, as she remains unconscious. Eve informs Sam that Ivy's recovery depends on him.
In Bermuda, everyone gathers around the body bag, and Luis readies himself to identify the body. The army captain suggests it might be easier on Julian to make the ID, but Luis insists on proving it's not Sheridan. Luis slowly unzips the bag and takes a look.
As Norma and the warlocks battle over who gets to kill Tabitha, Timmy unties his Princess and the two sneak off. Tabby and Timmy frantically look for a way to open the cave entrance. Norma arrives with her axe after having defeated the warlocks, and the duo finds themselves cornered.
Charity watches in horror as her friends are swept into torrential waters when the dam they are crossing crumbles. The teens struggle to remain above water as the hurricane causes a strong current. Charity lets out a terrified scream when the dam breaks completely and her friends disappear under the rushing water.
Meanwhile, Rebecca can't shake the feeling that whatever Julian is up to has to do with Theresa. Rebecca tells Gwen to watch Theresa, she's going to go find Julian and figure out what is going on. Julian goes to the bar and orders a dry MarTimmy, but the bartender says he has no idea how to make one of those. Julian says he'll have a brandy then. Julian then begins to wonder if there is a way to keep Theresa as his wife and not be killed by Ethan and Luis. The bartender tells Mr. Crane that he's sorry about his sister, and he hopes he has someone who can help him through this difficult time. Julian says he does have someone in his life. Rebecca finds Julian in the bar and tells him that they have to discuss their wedding. Rebecca says now that he is divorced from Ivy, he is free to marry her, but he seem hesitant. Julian says they can't marry until they know who the body is, because if it is Sheridan he has to make funeral arrangements. Rebecca says they can give her a quick burial and then get married, but Julian says that would seem insensitive. Rebecca says he killed her, so don't play the mourner. Rebecca warns Julian that if he doesn't marry her, he will be one sorry son of a Crane! Rebecca says if Luis investigated Sheridan's death, and he was caught and went to trial, she would have to testify unless they were married!
Julian and Rebecca join the other's in the lobby, and when he makes remarks about planning a funeral, Luis becomes upset and says there will be no funeral! Later, Theresa asks Julian about the annulment, and he tells her that these things take time. Suddenly, Rebecca shows up in a bridal gown! Luis calls her a monster, but Rebecca says she wants to marry Julian right now, and she wants their wedding to be a re-affirmation that Sheridan is still alive. Suddenly, a fax from Harmony is delivered to Luis.
On Warlock Island, in the cave Tabitha and Timmy continues to run from Norma. Timmy tells Tabitha that she is unlike other witches, because she is kind and sweet, at least to him. Tabitha tells timmy that his kind words have warmed her heart. However, she tells Timmy not to go around talking about this too much, she has a reputation to protect. Tabitha and Timmy then make a run for it, and manage to escape from the cave. Back inside, Norma, whose axe was stuck in a bolder, manages to free her axe and runs after Tabitha and Timmy.
Outside, a tree talks to Charity. The tree tells Charity that he knows many things, for example he knows about her powers. The tree tells Charity that she must use her powers to save her friends, only she can do it. Charity looks in the river and sees her friends drowning. Charity tells the tree she'll do anything to save them. The tree asks how important her friends and the boy are to her? She says they mean everything to her, so the tree tells her that if she doesn't use her powers they will all drown. Charity doesn't understand what powers, she only has premonitions. The tree tells her if she is convinced she doesn't have any powers, then this conversation is over. Charity begs the tree to please tell her what powers she has, and how to use them. The tree tells her to use the powers she was born with, the powers she inherited from her mother. Charity doesn't feel like she has any powers. The tree tells her that she must summon them, but Charity doesn't know how to do it. The tree tells her to concentrate, look deep inside herself, and be willing to pay a terrible price. Charity says she will pay anything. The tree tells Charity that she must give Miguel up in order to save his life. Charity agrees, and the tree tells her that she is a very special person. The tree then instructs Charity how to summon the powers to save the kids by stopping the hurricane. Charity tries, but nothing happens. The tree tells Charity that she must believe with every fiber of her being that she can stop the hurricane. Charity continues to try, and begs the hurricane to stop. Suddenly, the wind and rains cease, and the river grows calm! The tree tells Charity that she did it, nature gave to her, now she must give back to nature, she must pay the great price. Charity is amazed that she was able to stop the storm. The kids make it to shore, and Reese can't believe that the storm suddenly stopped like that. Charity tells the tree that she and her friends owe her. The tree says that she must give back to nature, she must hold up her end of the bargain and let Miguel go. Charity asks how Nature could be this cruel? The tree says that she can't break this deal, she will live her life without Miguel. Charity doesn't know how she can do that. The tree tells her that there is no going back now. Charity says she'll never regret saving their lives, and she'll miss Miguel every day for the rest of her life. Suddenly, Charity passes out! Kay watches the entire scene play out, and wonders what her wacky cousin is up to now. Miguel runs to Charity, who comes to. Miguel asks Charity what happened to her? Charity says she doesn't know, she doesn't remember.
On Warlock Island, Tabitha and Timmy escape Norma and the cave, and think they are free. However, Norma frees her axe from the rocks, and runs after Tabitha and Timmy. Tabitha and Timmy wander thtough the woods and stumble on the kids. The kids question Charity as she comes to after fainting. Charity says it is strange, but she remember the tree telling her to use her powers to save them from the storm. The kids wonder how this could be, but a spying Tabitha tells Timmy that this is very bad news. Tabitha says Charity is now aware of her powers, which means they will grow and eventually destroy them! Later, TC and Hank arrive on the island to rescue the kids. They all sit around a campfire as Charity continues to tell her story. She is positive that in exchange for saving them, she agreed to give up something. Tabitha suddenly turns up, and says that she managed to escape the Warlocks and crazy Norma. As TC and Hank prepare to lead everyone to the boat and take them back to Harmony, Norma shows up prepared to kill Tabitha. Hank and TC grab her, but she says she has to kill the witch! Reese is glad that someone else finally agrees that Tabitha is a witch. Norma says that Tabitha is a witch, her doll is alive, and she has proof!
Back in Harmomy, at the hospital David warns Grace that Ivy will always come between her and Sam. He says that he hates to point this out to her, but her rock solid marriage to Sam may not be the fairy tale everyone seems to think it is cracked up to be. Grace walks off and decides to think about David's words. Meanwhile, Eve notes Ivy has lost the will to live, and her pulse seems to pick up when she thinks about the past. She and Pilar urge Sam to make Ivy believe she and him never broke up and that he loves her. Sam is hesitant, but agrees. He begins telling Ivy stories about their wedding, and their life together. Ivy's pulse picks up, and she finally comes to. However, she then realizes that none of that has happened, she has lost Sam and she has nothing to live for. Grace shows up at this point, and overhears Sam tell Ivy that she has everything to live for. He says that she can find a man to love her, but she says she only wants him. Sam says even though he had to move on, he never once stopped loving her.
In Bermuda, everyone is tense as they wait for the doctor to compare Sheridan's dental records and fingerprints with those of the body found at sea. A horrified Gwen chastises Rebecca for showing up in a wedding gown. Rebecca informs Julian she wants to get married as soon as the body is identified as Sheridan, or she will tell everyone he had his sister killed. Julian is threatened yet again when Theresa warns him she'll tell Ethan the truth if he doesn't come through with an annulment right away. The doctor and army captain return with grave news. He says that the body is indeed Sheridan. Luis refuses to believe that and decides to conduct his own exam, so he takes off. Meanwhile, Julian calls his father with the news that Sheridan is dead. Alistair is pleased and orders Julian to have the body creamted. Julian hesitates, and Alistair tells him to suck it up, this is business. Elsewhere, Rebecca goes to the Justice of the Peace and asks him to marry her and Julian. He chockes on his drink, and she asks him if there is something wrong? Is there something that she should know? Later, Luis returns, and says he has checked and double checked, but he can no longer deny it. Luis annouces that the woman is Sheridan, he has lost her.
At the hospital, David argues with Eve and Pilar about Sam's love for Ivy, and their idea that Sam and Grace are a perfect couple. David tells them that Sam showed his true colors tonight, he loves Ivy just as much as he loves Grace. David is sick of being rejected by both Grace and her friends after finally finding the woman he loves. David says if he thought Grace was truly happy, and that Sam loved her as much as he says he does, then he'd suck it up and leave. However, David says that is not what he sees, and he knows Grace is about to be hurt and will need someone. David says he will be around when Sam messes up, and it will be soon.
Meanwhile, Grace overhears Sam tell Ivy that he never stopped loving her. Sam says he waited for her to come back to her, but when she didn't, it broke his heart. Ivy thinks he is just saying that because she could die, but Sam says it is true. Ivy looks into Sam's eyes and realizes he means it. Grace gasps, and Sam turns around to see her standing in the door. A nurse comes in, and checks on Ivy. She tells Sam whatever he told Mrs. Crane worked. Grace runs off, and Ivy tells Sam that she never stopped loving him either. Sam runs after Grace and tries to explain, but Grace tells him not to. Grace tells Sam that she knows why he said those things to Ivy, and it tore her apart to hear him say them. Suddenly, Sam and Grace hear Kay calling out for her mom, so they go running. Later, Pilar goes to see Ivy, who is thrilled that Sam still loves her. Pilar tells Ivy not to get her hopes up, Sam loves Grace and he won't leave her.
Everyone is reunited with their children at the hospital, and filled in what has happened here in Harmony. Kay is relieved that her father and mother were not hurt, and resolves to be good and be happy for Miguel and Charity. Simone is shocked, but Kay says that her family is way more important to her than any guy. Kay says from now on she will send out positive vibes, and that way only good ones will come back. Meanwhile, Tabitha decides to escape while she can. However, Sam stops her! Sam tells her that if she has been involved in any of the bizarre incidents happening in Harmony, or if she's ever done anything to harm his family or anyone else, he will make sure she is locked up for the rest of her life. Grace asks what is going on here? Reese says that Tabitha is a witch, and he says Norma knows it too! Norma tells everyone that she can prove that Tabitha is a witch and that her doll is alive!
In Bermuda, Alistair asks Julian why he doesn't want to marry Rebecca all of the sudden? Julian says he will not be blackmailed into marriage. Alistair orders Julian to make Rebecca his wife immediately to keep her from talking. He also tells Julian to take care of Sheridan's remains and get Luis out of their life once and for all. After their call, Bruce shows up and tells Julian that he looks like hell. Julian tells Bruce to get lost, every time he comes around his life takes a turn for the worst.
Rebecca asks the Justice of the Peace why he can't marry her and Julian, what doesn't he want her to find out? The Justice says it's not that he doesn't want to tell her, he just can't because he could be fired. Rebecca realizes Julian has a secret, and she tells him if he doesn't tell her what it is, she will find a way to get him fired anyways. Rebecca threatens to call Alistair and make sure the only job the Justice will be able to have is as Justice of the PEace on Three Mile Island. Suddenly, Bruce shows up and tells Rebecca that Julian has requested she come to Sheridan's funeral, which is about to begin. Rebecca is upset, but tells the Justice that he is coming to the funeral to marry her and Julian the second the funeral is over!
Elsewhere, Luis tells everyone that Sheridan is indeed dead. Julian shows up and says they will be having a funeral for Sheridan, but Luis wants to do it in Harmony. Ethan suggests to Luis that they have Sheridan buried here where she was happy with him. Ethan says he thinks Sheridan wouldn't want them to drag out her death and funeral. Luis agrees, but says he hates that Julian has anything to do with Sheridan's funeral. He tells Julian to make the arrangements, but treat Sheridan with the respect she deserves. Julian makes arrangements for the funeral, and the others show up at the chapel. Rebecca shows up in her wedding gown, which shocks Julian. Rebecca puts on a black veil, and says that she has dressed appropriately. She also says that right after the funeral, they will be married! The others show up, and Luis is shocked that Julian planned a nice funeral that he feels Sheridan would approve of. Gwen thanks Luis for showing her best friend the kind of love she always searched for, and she places a picture of Sheridan on the casket. The funeral begins, and Julian is disturbed to see Bruce with the Justice of the Peace. Rebecca tells Julian that she told him they are getting married right after the funeral. The priest presiding over the funeral asks people who knew Sheridan to step forward and say some words about Sheridan. Luis gets up and says that he loved Sheridan very much, and breaks down. Ethan steps up and says he knows how Luis feels, and that he is grateful that Sheridan found joy and love with Luis before she died. HE says he always thought Sheridan was an angel, and it makes him feel good to know she is in heaven with all of the other angels. Ethan tells Sheridan that he loves her, and he'll miss her. Luis makes another attempt to speak, and says that something Ethan said has struck him, and he needs to speak. Luis says that Sheridan is not in this coffin.
Elsewhere, Norma says that Tabitha is a witch, and her doll is alive, and she can prove it! Sam asks who she is to make these accusations? Reese, TC, and Hank fill Sam in on Norma's story. Kay and Jessica both defend Tabitha, and Simone realizes that Kay really is trying to be nice. Reese uses his computer to show everyone that Tabitha Lennox has been living in Harmony for over three hundred years. Tabitha says she has explained before that Tabitha is a name that has been handed down in her family. Reese also says that witches never age, and everyone in Harmony will tell you that Tabitha has looked the same for as long as they can remember. Tabitha says so has Dick Clark, so that proves nothing. Reese continues to accuses with proof that she is a witch, but Tabitha explains every one of Reese's accusations. Reese says Tabitha is a witch, but Sam says even so, being a witch isn't illegal. Sam says that the only was he can charge Tabitha is if she put his family or others in danger. The kids all stand up for Tabitha and says she risked her life for them out on that island. Reese then accuses Tabitha of using her powers to bring the hurricane. Sam says even if Reese could prove that, but soon realizes that there is no such thing as witches! Norma says she has seen Tabitha practicing witchcraft with her living doll, and she has another witness who will back her up, a respected business man. Reese continues accusing Tabitha of being a witch, and now he has Norma and her eye witness, and he suspects there are others who could come forward as well. A woman claims she saw a strange glow coming from Tabitha's house one night, and a girl says her doll mashed ice cream in her face once. A man in a wheel chair comes forward and says his ancestors kept diaries and they wrote that they burned a witch named Tabitha at the stake over three-hundred years ago! Reece and Norma tell Tabitha to admit that she is a witch and her doll is alive. Sam tells everyone to calm down because this isn't the sixteen hundreds, they don't burn people anymore. Reese thinks they should, and starts chanting "witch-free Harmony!" Sam tells Reese that is enough, and he has been watching too many late night horror movies. Sam then asks Norma about her evidence. Norma reveals the identity of her eyewitness, her father! Everyone gasps when Norma pulls out her father and begins speaking for him! Tabitha rolls her eyes, as Norma's father speaks. Reese realizes he is NEVER going to live this down. Tabitha thinks she is safe now, because Norma just lost her credibility. Sam tells Norma that he'd like to interview her in a private room, and a man in a white coat comes to take Norma away! Eve escorts Norma off, and Sam tells everyone that they all owe Tabitha a huge apology. Sam forces Reese to apologize to Tabitha. Tabitha tells them all even though they may be different on the outside, they are all the same on the inside, so you shouldn't judge a person on what others say about them. Tabitha walks off, and admits to Timmy that she read that PC dribble on a placement at a dinner somewhere. Later, Norma is hauled off in a straight jacket as she screams for her father. Tabitha sees Norma being taken away and torments her. Norma tells Tabitha that she'll get her and her little doll too!
In Bermuda, Luis tells everyone at the funeral that the body in this casket is not Sheridan Crane. Everyone tells Luis that he has to accept that Sheridan is gone, and she's not coming back. Luis regains his composure, and finally says some words about Sheridan. Luis says this is an unthinkable loss, and that he loves Sheridan so much. Luis says that what he'll miss most about Sheridan is her beautiful heart. Luis goes on to say that even though Sheridan grew up feeling unloved and unwanted, she wasn't hardened or bitter, she welcomed those who felt less than whole. He also says that even though Sheridan came from money and privilege, that is not how her worth was measured. Luis says he just doesn't understand why Sheridan had to be taken away so soon. Luis tells them all that one day he'll join her in heaven, and in heaven they will finally be married. The father finishes the funeral, and the coffin is loaded into the crematorium and burned. Julian says goodbye to his sister, and Luis, who is holding a picture of Sheridan, says he'll always love her. The father says her ashes will be released shortly, and Julian asks for them to be given to Luis. Luis hopes everyone has learned not to take the person they love for granted. Ethan realizes Luis is right, and tells Theresa that he wants to marry her as soon as possible. Ethan and Chad go to check on Luis, and Whitney and Theresa talk about Theresa's marriage to Julian. Whitney tries to calm Theresa down and says nobody will find out the truth, and Julian will get an annulment soon. Still, Theresa thinks this secret will end up blowing up in her face just like her other secrets have. Elsewhere, Rebecca demands the Justice marry her and Julian right away. The Justice finally cracks, and refuses to be a party to this lie anymore, so he vows to tell everyone the truth! Later, Luis is given Sheridan's ashes, and he remembers their times together through flashbacks.