At the lighthouse, Ivy continues to reminisce about the past as Sam panics. Sam still can't seem to get a signal on his cell phone. Suddenly, Ivy passes out, and Sam fears the worst. Ivy comes to, and tells Sam that when she thinks about the past, it doesn't really hurt. She remembers one of the notes Sam left her in which he told her that he'd love her forever and a day. She then asks Sam to kiss her like he used to kiss her before.
Out in the shed, Grace and David remain trap, and Grace stirs over David's word that perhaps Sam still loves Ivy. David apologizes, and says he knows what it is like to feel that pain, because that's how he felt when he returned and found her with Sam. Grace says it is different, and she says she's not even sure they are married because she doesn't remember the grooms face at the wedding she recalls. David becomes upset and says they are married, and their marriage is all that counts in the eyes of the church. This in turn upsets Grace. David says this isn't how it was supposed to be, it isn't how he dreamed their reunion would be. David says he thought they would run back into one another's arms and vow never to be separated again, but instead all he's done is hurt her.
Out on the island, an earthquake hits. Jessica is hit by the debris, and knocked out, but the kids save her. Later, the kids realize they are trapped in the cave. Reese thinks the warlocks have trapped them because they want the witch who trapped them in this cave, and then names Tabitha as the witch.
In Bermuda, Gwen and Rebecca run around knocking on doors, while Luis, Ethan, Chad, and Whitney stand out on Theresa's balcony. Ethan swears he heard Theresa call his name, but nobody else heard it. Inside, Julian continues to try and keep Theresa quiet. Whitney knows they are probably in there, so she tells Ethan that he is the only one who heard Theresa, so maybe he is just imagining things. Ethan thinks maybe she is right, so they all leave to search elsewhere. Julian realizes Whitney is working on their side, and though Luis and Co. are gone, Rebecca and Gwen remain in the hallway.
Then the show got interrupted, so I don't know what happened at the end. Sorry!
At the lighthouse, Ivy begs Sam to kiss her, but he can't. Ivy realizes that Sam truly loves Grace. Ivy fears she is going to die, and she tells Sam before she dies, she wants to get all her dirty little secrets out. She tells Sam when she first learned about David, she hoped he was married to Grace because that would make him free to be with her. However, she now sees that will never happen, because even her reminiscing about their past hasn't stirred his love for Grace, and she wonders if he ever really loved her to begin with. Sam tells Ivy not to think that way. The paramedics finally show up, and Sam asks them if they have seen Grace. They say they have been to the church, but Grace isn't there. Sam worries, and Ivy tells Sam that she will be okay, he should go to Grace. Sam tells Ivy to hang in there, and she is taken to the hospital. However, on the way to the hospital, Ivy flat-lines.
In the shed, Grace continues to remain upset over the fact that Sam may still have feelings for Ivy. David apologizes, and realizes that Grace is exhausted. He makes a makeshift bed for her and insists she gets some sleep. Later, Sam shows up, and climbs over the trees and breaks into shed. He is shocked when he finds David and Grace asleep in one another's arms.
In the cavern, a warlock appears in a geyser of steam to the kids and Tabitha. He demands they give them "the sacrifice" or they will never escape the cave. Miguel doesn't understand who they want. He tells him to use his brain! Kay thinks they want Charity, but Reese thinks they want Tabitha because she is a witch. Miguel tells Reese to shut up, and he tells the warlock that he isn't afraid of him, calls him a loser, and dares him to show them what he is made of. The warlock tells Miguel he will regret his stupidity, disappears, and causes another earthquake. Miguel suggests they all split up and begin searching for an exit. As they search, Tabitha and Timmy discover cave paintings detailing the history of the warlocks, and Tabitha sees herself in them! Timmy is shocked and confused when he appears in the paintings as well. Tabitha says they can't let the kids find this or they will hand them over to the warlocks for sure! Tabitha sees some mud, and she and Timmy begin smearing mud all over the paintings. Suddenly, Reese and Jessica show up and wonder what is going on. Elsewhere, Simone and Kay discover train tracks, and light peering down from above. Simone follows the train tracks and looks for an exit while Kay looks upwards for the source of the light. Meanwhile, Charity ends up in a tunnel down below Kay. Upwards where Kay is, Kay isn't watching what she is doing, and begins teeters close to the edge of a canyon. She ends up knocking a railroad tie into it, and when she looks, she sees Charity below. Kay realizes if it hits Charity, she will die!
In Bermuda, Whitney sends the gang on a goose chase, and then gets the maid to give her a key to Theresa's room. She sneaks in and plans on helping Julian for Theresa's sake. The posse shows up and begins banging on the door again, so Whitney and Julian head for the balcony, which turns out to be locked. The posse gets fed up and breaks down the door. They find Theresa out cold in bed, but Whitney and Julian are no where to be found. We soon learn Julian is hiding under the bed, and Whitney manages to slip out while everyone is preoccupied with Theresa, and then returns as if she was behind them in the hall. Ethan and Luis deduce that Theresa has been drugged, and blame Julian!
Sam is shocked when he shows up in the shed and finds Grace and David asleep in one another's arms. They wake up, and Grace is thankful to see Sam is okay. She also tries to explain that nothing happened here. Sam says he knows she is innocent, but he thinks David tried to take advantage of Grace. However, Grace says David was a perfect gentlement. Sam tells Grace about Ivy, and that he hopes she got to the hospital. Grace thinks David should be checked out at the hospital, so they all head there.
Ivy is rushed into the emergency room. Eve informs her she has spinal injuries and needs surgery. Ivy insists on talking to Sam before they operate on her. Later, David, Grace, and Sam show up. Sam is encouraged to go see Ivy. In her room, Ivy hopes Sam comes to see her, and says she has to tell him the truth.
In the cavern, Simone shows up and sees the log about to hit Charity, so she screams at her. Miguel saves Charity's life once again. Meanwhile, Reese and Jessica catch Tabitha covering up paintings on the walls of the cave, the pictures which depict Tabitha's involvement with the warlocks. Tabitha comes up with a flimsy excuse for her actions, she says they were pornographic, probably painted in the sixties, and she didn't want them to see them. Reese thinks he's found proof that Timmy is alive, he sees mud on his hands and thinks Timmy was helping Tabitha, he proceeds to engage in a tug of war with Tabitha over the doll. A warlock appears before everyone again and causes another earthquake when the kids refuse to turn in "the one." The kids try to escape, but Tabitha and Timmy get stuck behind when bolders block the exit. Tabitha tries to get Timmy to climb through the small hole and catch up with the kids, but he refuses to leave Tabitha behind. Tabitha resorts to hurting Timmy by saying she doesn't love him and is tired of him hanging around her. A hurt Timmy runs off, and Tabitha gives herself up to the Warlocks. The Warlocks surround her and chant, and suddenly Tabitha fizzles into nothing! Meanwhile, the earthquakes stop and the kids escape, but then they realize Tabitha was left behind. Charity says Tabitha must be dead, and her death allowed them to live.
In Bermuda, Julian is nearly discovered hiding under Theresa's bed. The resort doctor arrives and reveals he gave Theresa the sedative. Everyone calms down after realizing Julian didn't drug Theresa. Theresa finally awakens and is relieved to be reunited with loved ones who she thought died at sea. Whitney realizes Julian is still trapped in the room, so she convinces everyone that Theresa needs her rest. Everyone leaves, and Julian once again gets horny. He goes over to Theresa, who, thinking he is Ethan, begs him not to leave. Suddenly, Ethan returns to check on Theresa one last time, and catches Julian with Theresa! Meanwhile, Luis gets a call that a woman matching Sheridan's description has been found at sea. A captain is coming to the hotel with more information, and Luis waits for him and the news that Sheridan is alive.
Julian is caught in a compromising position with a heavily-drugged Theresa. A blubbering Julian is about to be pummeled, but Whitney arrives and stops the melee. A flustered Whitney blurts out she can explain what's going on and will reveal the truth. Julian freezes in horror.
Luis waits anxiously when he hears a woman was found at sea and is being brought to shore. He reminisces about his relationship with Sheridan.
On Warlock Island, the kids, who have escaped from the cave, fear the warlocks are going to kill Tabitha. Reese and Miguel want to go back and try and save her, but the others beg them not to because she is probably already dead. A spying Norma yells "No!" The teens are stunned as a crazed Norma rushes past them and vows she will be the one to finish off Tabitha. As the cave closes behind Norma, the kids wonder why she wants to hurt their chaperone. Reese says it must be because she is a witch, but he can't explain what Norma is. Since they can't get back inside the cave to rescue Tabitha, the teens decide to seek shelter from the storm. The kids end up at a huge river, and Miguel says they'll cross it by walking over a fallen tree. Charity lags behind as she ties her shoe. As the other kids cross the log, a dam breaks, and the water sweeps the kids into the river as Charity watches!
Meanwhile, the warlocks torture Tabitha as Timmy helplessly looks on from behind a stack of rocks. Tabitha, who is on the rack, apologizes to Timmy for what she said to him earlier. Timmy knows his princess did not mean what she said. Norma creeps up behind the unsuspecting doll, and it appears as if she is going to axe him, but instead she charges the rocks. Norma breaks through the rocks, and fights the warlocks for the right to kill Tabitha. As Norma battles the warlocks, Timmy runs to Tabitha and tries to free her from the rack.
At the hospital chapel, Grace walks in on Sam praying for Ivy. She overhears him say that he doesn't know what he'll do if Ivy dies. As David quietly observes the couple, Sam admits he feels sorry for Ivy despite her mistakes. He says that it wasn't until today that he realizes how hurt Ivy has been, even though most of the pain she has gone through is her own fault. Sam then asks Grace about their future, and how Ethan fits into it. He tells Grace if she can't accept Ethan in their home, he will understand. However, Grace says Ethan is a part of his life, so he is a part of hers. Grace shares that she sympathizes with David. Sam is upset when she declares David is a permanent part of their lives now. Later, David comes in with coffee, and refers to Grace as his wife, which upsets Sam. David is tired of taking heat from Sam, and tells Sam that he thinks part of him still cares for Ivy. He wonders why Sam didn't leave Ivy to come check on Grace, because that is what he would have done if the situations were reversed. David is convinced that deep down inside, Sam still loves Ivy.
In Bermuda, Julian thanks Whitney for covering for him with Ethan. Whitney spits she did it for Theresa's sake, not his. She presses Julian to get the annulment ASAP. Chad, who is spying on them, notes Whitney and Julian's whispered conversation, but can't make out what they are saying. Later, Chad asks Whitney to please tell him what is going on. Whitney says she can't because he will feel obligated to tell Ethan, which will make this situation a whole lot worse! Meanwhile, in Theresa's suite, the sedative begins to wear off on Theresa, who is happily reunited with Ethan. Theresa begins to tell Ethan about the wild "dream" she had, but fortunately Whitney walks in and stop her. Later, Whitney tells Theresa that it was no dream, she married and slept with Julian Crane! Theresa can't believe this is happening to her.
Down in the bar, Rebecca finally hunts down Julian and demands to know the identity of the "tart" with whom he was fooling around. Julian claims he was not with anyone, he was mourning Sheridan's death. Rebecca doesn't believe him, and sees the maid who saw Julian with a dark haired woman. Rebecca questions her, but Julian manages to bribe her into telling Rebecca that she saw someone else with the woman, not Julian. The maid rushes off, and Rebecca wonders what is going on.
Meanwhile, the army captain informs Luis the woman they found at sea is dead. The captain asks an anguished Luis to identify the body. Later, Luis informs the others that Sheridan is supposedly dead, but he won't believe it until he sees a body. Suddenly, a body bag is wheeled in, and Luis knows he has to go identify the woman.