At the cave, Miguel continues to bang against the rocks with Norma's axe. Jessica doesn't understand how Charity could be in there. Reese says that he thinks Charity walked in the cave and the rocks closed behind her. Jessica says that doesn't make any sense, but Reese says many things that happen to CHarity don't make sense. MEanwhile, Simone continues to scold Kay for scheming to get Miguel, because she has placed them all in danger. Suddenly, lightening hits the cave, and opens it up for the kids! The kids go into the cave and begin to search for Charity. Once they leave, Norma grabs her axe and decides to go kill Tabitha and Timmy.
In the cave, Charity talks with the Warlocks, who show her images from the past of Tabitha giving them the wrong scepters. Charity refuses to believe that Tabitha is a witch, but the Warlocks says she is, and that she must destroy her! Charity says she can't, Tabitha is her neighbor, her friend! The Warlocks tell Charity that if she won't destroy Tabitha Lennox, than her and all her friends must die! Charity says no, but the Warlocks tell her that she has already seen the future! THey tell her that they will all die unless she uses her powers to set them free! The Warlocks then show her visions of Sheridan's funeral, and they tell her that Luis is gone as well. They then show Theresa living in the lap of luxury. Charity thinks Theresa is happy and married to Ethan, but they tell her things are not what they seem. Charity asks about Miguel and her future, but they warn her that she doesn't want to see. Charity refuses to help them until she sees her future. They show her Miguel on his honeymoon, which Charity thinks is romantic, until she finds out that Miguel is on his honeymoon with Kay!
In Bermuda the man from the army says that the rescue boat has been destroyed, and the men have been presumed lost at sea. Julian tells Bruce that Luis and Ethan are dead and gone, and now there is nothing to stop him from enjoying Theresa! Bruce tells Julian not to get ahead of himself, even if Ethan and Luis are dead, what makes him think that Theresa will want to be with him? Julian is positive that Theresa will come to him for comfort, and then he'll work that old Crane magic! Gwen goes to Julian and begs him to set out a search party to find Ethan. Julian says he can't put other people's lives at risk. Gwen wonders why Julian is acting like he wants Ethan to be dead?
Gwen tells her mother that Julian behaving very strangely. Rebecca agrees, and she knows something important happened on this island before they arrive, and somehow it effects her. Rebecca decides to talk to the Justice of the Peace, because she thinks he knows what went on. Gwen flirts with the Justice, and persuades him to let her see the wedding chapel. Rebecca talks with the Justice about her good friend Theresa, and asks if she was here to marry Ethan. The Justice says yes, but they didn't get married because of the storm. Rebecca then begins questioning him about Julian, and why he is so tense? She asks him what was so strange about Ethan and Theresa's wedding? She begins giving him a massage to loosen him up. The Justice agrees to tell her, as long as it remains between the two of them.
MEanwhile, Whitney and Theresa mourn Ethan, Chad, and Luis. Theresa refuses to believe this, and asks the captain if he saw their bodies? The captain says the boat has disappeared from radar, and a plane spotted bodies floating in the water. Theresa refuses to believe they are dead. Whitney tells Theresa that they have to pray. Julian approaches Theresa and she and Whitney pray, and he attempts to comfort her. Julian asks Whitney to get something hot for Theresa to drink, because she feels cold. Whitney refuses to leave Theresa alone with Julian, but Theresa says it is okay. Whitney leaves, and Theresa assures Mr. Crane that she is okay. Julian asks her to call him Julian, because he is her husband. Theresa tells him that he promised to get this marriage annulled, but Julian says there is no reason not to stay married if Ethan isn't coming back! Theresa tells Julian that they have to get this marriage annulled. Julian says that many marriages are arranged, and they could grow to love one another. Theresa says she could never love him. Julian says he can be flexible, and they can turn the whole Crane Mansion into one big fiesta! Meanwhile, Gwen sees Julian and Theresa together and realizes something weird is going on. Whitney returns and saves Theresa from Julian, and the two of them continue praying for a miracle as they look at pictures of their loved ones. Elsewhere, Julian tells Bruce that tonight he will relive his honeymoon with THeresa tonight! Julian then asks the bellboy to do something for him. Julian gives him the order, but the bellboy refuses, until Julian threatens to have him fired. Julian tells Bruce that tonight, Theresa will be his wife in every way!
Out at sea, the bodies of the victims float on the surface of the water! Suddenly, heroic music plays, and Chad and Ethan spring to life! They swim to Luis, who is barely clinging to life. Ethan tells Chad that they have to find something to help them keep afloat. They find a piece of driftwood, but Luis ends up getting tangled up in some boat wrecked and dragged down to the ocean floor! Ethan and Chad manage to save Luis, who continues to insist they find SHeridan. Ethan tells Luis that SHeridan is gone, they have to let her go.
In the cave, the Warlocks show Miguel and Kay on their honeymoon, and they tell her if she does not destroy Tabitha, she will never marry Miguel! Charity says she can't destroy Tabitha because she is a harmless old woman. The warlocks tells her than she will spend the rest of her life with Kay! Charity refuses to believe this, and says she won't hurt Tabitha. The warlocks say then Miguel will spend the rest of his life making love to Kay! Charity begins screaming no!
Elsewhere in the cave, Miguel hears Charity screaming no, so he runs toward her voice. Simone tells Kay that she better hope Charity is all right, otherwise she will never forgive her! Suddenly, the kids hear Charity scream "No not Kay, please Miguel don't make love to Kay!" Miguel says it sounds like Charity is having another premonition, and he asks Kay why she'd see him making love to her? Simone tells Kay she is busted!
In the pit, Timmy begins to cast another spell with the scepter, but Tabitha stops him and tells him that the spells aren't working, so he should help her dig! Meanwhile, Norma is on her way back to the pit to kill Tabitha and Timmy! Back in the pit, Timmy tries to cast another spell, but before he can, Norma returns! Norma tells them to start saying their prayers, because they are dead. Suddenly, Norma throws man eating bugs into the pit with Timmy and Tabitha. Timmy decides to conjure up some rain to drown the bugs, and the scepter shoots a beam of light up into the sky.
In a weather center, meteorologists are puzzled when the storm in Bermuda suddenly shifts course! The hurricane, and several other storms, suddenly begin moving towards Harmony!
At the church, David tells Pilar, Eve, and Hank that Sam and Grace aren't married, he and Grace are. David says it won't be long before Grace remembers her passions for him, and then she will leave Sam and come back to her true husband! Eve and Pilar say that Grace loves Sam and will never leave Sam! David says he and Grace shared a deeply passionate love, and he understands why they want Sam and Grace to be together. However, David says he has friends who would want Grace with him, and he feels that Sam is better off with Ivy. Hank says that Sam and Ivy broke it off long ago, and Sam will never give up Grace. David says Ivy and Sam didn't break up, they were ripped apart! Hank says Sam and Ivy don't belong together, and if they had been in love, they would have found there way back together long ago!
Outside the church, Ivy continues to spy on Sam and Grace. Sam tells Grace that the way she talks about David it is as if she has feelings for him. Sam asks Grace if she remembers loving David? Does she feel that he is her husband? Grace doesn't remember being married to David, but the proof . . . Sam says all that matters is their marriage. Grace tells Sam they don't have a marriage, at least not a legal one. Suddenly Sam is beeped, so he has to call the station. After he leaves, Grace hears a twig snap in the bushes. Grace asks who is there? Ivy comes out from the bushes, and Grace is furious with her for eavesdropping. She calls Ivy a vulture! Sam returns, and asks what is going on? Grace tells Sam that this woman, no, this bitch, is never going to leave him alone. Grace says she is waiting around like and alley cat in heat to pounce him! Grace tells Ivy "Damn you!" Ivy says the only reason she came here is to decorate the church, and she can ask Pilar! Grace calls her a liar! Sam can't believe Grace doesn't trust Pilar, one of their closest friends, yet she believes David. Sam is shocked, but Grace says she can't trust Ivy as long as she is trying to weasel her way back into his bed! Sam thought he had gotten passed the threat of Ivy, but Grace says she doubt she will ever get passed it! Suddenly the others show up and ask what is going on? Sam says Grace is blaming their troubles on Ivy, when they should be blaming David. Instead, Sam says Grace is defending him. David is touched that Grace has defended him. Hank tells Sam and Grace that they can't let anything come between them, not David nor Ivy. Suddenly, a storm begins to brew, and Pilar says this storm is like Sam and Grace's marriage. Eve has a feeling that Sam and Grace's marriage might be over.
In Bermuda, Julian orders champagne and other stuff for his romantic evening with Theresa. Later, Julian gets news which will make Theresa run into his arms. Meanwhile, Gwen confronts THeresa at tells her that she holds her responsible for what happens to Ethan, and if he is dead, she will make her pay! Whitney tells Gwen to just shut up and go away! Gwen refuses and says this is all her fault, the only reason she came here is to trick Ethan into marrying her! Julian shows up and tells Theresa and Whitney that he has some bad news, BAsil, the captain of the boat, has been found dead. Julian says it is likely that the others are dead as well. Theresa breaks down, and Julian attempts to comfort her. Gwen runs off, and Whitney smacks Julian and tells her to get her hands off of Theresa! Julian says she is his wife, but Whitney says he is supposed to be getting the marriage annulled! THeresa becomes hysterical, and blames herself for everything. A doctor shows up, and Whitney asks him to help Theresa. The doctor says he'll go get his bag. Julian runs after the doctor and asks for some viagra, just in case, but the doctor refuses to help Julian when people need real medical attention. The doctor returns and gives Theresa a sedative. He then asks a bellboy to take Theresa up to her room. Unfortunately, the bellboy takes her to Julian's room, and when Julian learns about this, he rushes upstairs.
Meanwhile, Rebecca is massaging the Justice and trying to get him talk about what happened with Theresa and Ethan. The Justice wants to get something off his mind, but he says it would have to be confidential! Rebecca says of course, it would stay between the two of them. As the Justice is about to talk, Gwen barges in. The Justice panics and runs out. Gwen tells her mom that the captain of the rescue boat is dead, so Ethan . . . Rebecca tells Gwen that she is sorry, but they don;t know anything for sure. Suddenly, the storm stops, and Gwen runs off. The Justice returns, and Rebecca picks up where they left off. The Justice agrees to tell Rebecca everything about Theresa's wedding.
Out at sea, Luis passes out, and Ethan tells Chad if they don't get out of this storm soon, Luis will be dead! Somehow, the three manage to make it to shore, and carry Luis to a doctor. Ethan and Chad carry Luis into the hotel, and the doctor checks him out. Suddenly, Gwen shows up and runs into Ethan's arms. Ethan asks her what she is doing here? Gwen says she came with her mom. Ethan asks where Theresa is? Gwen says she doesn't know. Whitney shows up and is thrilled they are alive. She hugs Chad and says she thought she lost him! Ethan asks Whitney where Theresa is? Whitney says she was in the lobby, but now she's gone, and she has no idea where she went. Meanwhile, Bruce sees the threesome show up, and thinks he should warn Julian. Then he decides to let Julian find out on his own!
Upstairs, Julian thinks Theresa has taken him up on his offer. She is sound asleep in bed and Julian tells her that he will make her a very happy girl, even without viagra! Julian begins to undress, and says tonight they will remember their love making!
Norma continues to flood the pit with more bugs. Timmy once again tries to cast a spell with the scepter. He chants for water to drown the bugs.
The warlocks show Charity a vision of Miguel and Kay making love in the future. The other teens hear Charity cry out for Miguel and Kay to stop making love. Kay is put on the spot. The kids hit a dead end. Meanwhile, a distraught Charity agrees to help the warlocks. She's horrified when the warlocks show her what happened to Sheridan and Luis.
The guilt-ridden Justice of the Peace prepares to tell all to Rebecca, but Bruce purposely interrupts. In private, Bruce warns the Justice to keep quiet or Julian will make him pay. An undeterred Rebecca vows to uncover what Julian is hiding.
In his resort room, Julian gets ready to take advantage of a heavily sedated Theresa. Thinking Julian is Ethan, Theresa asks him to make love to her. A giddy Julian makes his move.
In the pit, Norma continues to dump man-eating bugs on Tabitha and Timmy. Tabitha thinks this is the end, and she tells Timmy that he's proud of her for trying to save them. Timmy begs Norma to let them out, and he says they can all be friends. Norma refuses and says she likes her way better. Timmy tells Norma she's going to be sorry she treated him this way! Timmy grabs the scepter and casts another spell to bring water, but nothing comes of his spell. Tabitha begins to cry how she is a disgrace to witches everywhere, and she wishes she had her powers back. Suddenly, Timmy's spells work, and it begins to pour! The water drowns the bugs, and the celebrate. However, Norma tells them if the bugs don't kill them, this will! Norma then rolls a giant bolder over to the pit! Norma pushes the boulder into the pit, and it narrowly misses hitting Tabitha and Timmy. Tabitha then realizes if they don't get out of this pit, they will end up drowning! Suddenly, the ground begins to give way, and the pit turns into a sinkhole!
At the church in Harmony, Hank begs Grace and Sam to stop fighting, because they belong together. Sam says this is nuts, all the years they have spent together and he's not sure he knows her anymore. Sam asks Grace if he should stay or go? Grace tells Sam that is up to him, but she doesn't want to fight. Sam agrees. Suddenly, TC shows up and says that a hurricane is coming and it will be here soon. TC says Warlock Island and the kids are right in its path, and the boat that took kids to the island is missing. TC says the coast guard has boats out there trying to save them, but the lighthouse beacon isn't working. Eve thinks it could be hours before the kids are rescued. As the storm continues to pick up, the gang heads inside the church. Sam assures Grace that the kids know how to handle storms, they will find shelter. Grace feels like God is testing her. David offers to help, but Sam refuses his help. Grace says they can use all the help they can get, and she accepts David's offer. Hank tells David to back off, Sam can take care of everyone! Hank tells David that he is just getting in the way, but David says that Grace has accepted his offer, so he should respect Grace's choice. Sam asks Hank to go with TC to Warlock Island, he's going to work on getting the lighthouse beacon working again. Eve decides to head to the hospital, and Ivy suggests Sam just let David help them, and she wants to help as well. Sam tells Grace he needs to go out to the lighthouse to fix the beacon, and he tells David and Ivy if they want to help then they should stay put.
In Bermuda, Ethan wonders if Theresa is in Julian's room? Chad refuses to believe Theresa is with Julian, and Luis agrees. Ethan says he doesn't know what he was thinking. Gwen thinks that perhaps Theresa latched onto Julian when she thought Ethan was dead, and Rebecca calls her a little tramp. Ethan tells Rebecca to shut the hell up! Luis begins thinking about Sheridan again, and asks the captain of the guard to send out another search party because Sheridan is not dead! The captain says as soon as they can get a boat and a chopper out there, they will search for Sheridan. Rebecca says there is nothing they can do for Sheridan now, but they can still take care of Theresa. Rebecca is positive that Theresa is with Julian! Gwen also believes Theresa is with Julian just for his money. Ethan refuses to believe Theresa would sleep with Julian! Luis says that Theresa isn't a gold digger, and Julian should know better than to touch his sister. Still, Rebecca still believes something is going on with Julian and Theresa, and she asks Ethan if they have been "cuddling" will he still make her his wife? Luis says that would never happen, because Theresa would never be unfaithful to Ethan, especially with that slimeball. Rebecca says she isn't going to let Julian take the blame, if Theresa is with Julian, she had to have started the whole thing. Gwen says even she doesn't believe that, they know what a letch Julian is. Ethan says the only way Julian could get anywhere near Theresa is if she was drugged! Meanwhile, Chad notices Whitney isn't saying anything, and finds this odd. Luis goes to the front desk to ask about Julian, and learns he is up in his room with company, a pretty young woman with long, dark hair. Rebecca exclaims "aha!" and asks them if they'll believe her now? Ethan and Luis refuse to believe she is with Julian, so Ethan calls Julian's room to prove Rebecca wrong.
In Julian's hotel room, Theresa remains in a drugged state and Julian sucks on her fingers and kiss her hand. Meanwhile, Theresa dreams that she is in bed with Ethan! Julian's phone rings, it is Ethan calling, and he refuses to answer it.
Back down in the hotel, Ethan decides to head up to Julian's room, and the others follow. Rebecca decides to get a gun and kill them both! However, Ethan comes to his senses and refuses to believe Theresa is in Julian's room, and he thinks this is just a waste of time. Rebecca is positive Theresa is in Julian's room, and she tells them that if they won't investigate, she will! They decide to follow Rebecca to prove her wrong, but Whitney stays behind. Whitney calls up to Julian's room, and this time Julian answers. Whitney tries to warn Julian about the trouble heading his way, but he hangs up on her, but not before telling her to leave them alone! As Julian continues to take advantage of a drugged Theresa, the others arrive outside his hotel room!
On the island, Timmy and Tabitha end up being sucked into the sinkhole that has formed in the pit Norma trapped them in, and go zooming down a huge water slide ala the old movie "The Goonies." Meanwhile, in the cave, the kids continue to search for Charity. When Charity hears Miguel calling to her, she screams back. The warlocks zap Charity, and she falls unconscious. They then vanish, and Miguel and the others find Charity teetering on the edge of an abyss. Miguel saves Charity in time, and Kay is disappointed. However, she remains convinced that Charity will die on this island. Charity comes too, and everything is a bit fuzzy. As Reese wonders where Tabitha is, Tabitha and Timmy suddenly fall from a hole in the ceiling and land on Reese's head! Reese recovers, and asks where they came from? Tabitha says she was just walking along when suddenly a hurricane showed up, and she and Timmy were sucked down a river into this cave. Miguel says the weather was supposed to be clear, so where did a hurricane come from? Reese thinks Tabitha cast a spell and conjured it up, but Jessica says that Tabitha is harmless. Charity remembers the warlocks telling her that Tabitha was a witch, and she shouts that Tabitha is not harmless, she is a witch!
In Harmony, Grace goes out to a shed to get some supplies. David shows up to help, and they end up talking. David reminisces about their past, and how much they loved one another. The storm grows worse, and Grace fears something bad is going to happen. David says that the day she left for Boston there was a storm, and she said the exact same thing. Grace tells David that she knows he loves her, but she doesn't remember their past, and the only man she loves is Sam. David tells Grace that she is wrong, he could tell she loved him when they kissed in the church, and that in time she will remember her love for him. Suddenly, there is a huge crash of lightening, and a tree falls down outside the shed. It blocks the door, trapping David and Grace inside!
At the lighthouse beacon, Ivy shows up to help Sam. He tells her to go back home, but she refuses. She says she wants to help because Ethan's family is trapped out on that island, and she couldn't bare for anything to happen to them because Ethan has lost enough as is. Sam agrees to let Ivy help him. He rewires the lighthouse beacon, and climbs up to install it. Unfortunately he drops a part, so Ivy grabs it and takes it up to him. On her way down, she is struck by lightening!
In Bermuda, Whitney calls Julian one more time and tells him that Ethan and Luis are alive, and they are headed up to his room with Rebecca! Julian freaks out, and tries desperately to get Theresa to wake up, but she won't. He then starts dragging her out the door, but hears the others coming down the all. Then he tries to shove her in a wardrobe, but she won't fit! As Julian stands in the middle of his room holding Theresa, Luis grabs an axe from the emergency fire kit in the hotel hallway and begins chopping down the door!