Elsewhere, Theresa fears that the Justice might talk, but Whitney assures her that the Justice won't talk, and nobody else will ever find out she married Julian. Meanwhile, the Justice tells Bruce that he can't keep this secret anymore, he has to tell the truth. He produces a photo of Julian and Theresa's marriage, which Bruce grabs and burns. Bruce tells the Justice that if he wants to keep his job in this resort than he'll keep his mouth shut! The Justice says he just can't live with this anymore, and he is going to tell everyone the truth! Bruce tells him that he'll do no such thing, and they go over to where Julian and Rebecca are. Bruce asks Julian if he's ready to get married? Julian says he needs to make sure everything in regards to the funeral have been taken care of, and rushes off. A fed-up Rebecca leaves, and Bruce thinks the entire thing is twisted yet entertaining.
Luis sits with Sheridan's ashes and can't believe she is gone. He says they were so close to having it all.
Meanwhile, Ethan and Chad see that Luis is in pain, but realize that Luis needs to be alone right now. Ethan hopes Luis will get over losing Sheridan. Chad says it will just take time. Ethan says Sheridan was such a great person, and Luis' heart must be tearing apart. Ethan and Chad go back inside, and Ethan shows up just as Theresa is telling Whitney it would be a disaster for Ethan to learn the truth. Ethan asks Theresa what would be a disaster? Theresa says she was just saying how this whole situation was a disaster, and she wishes she had never come down to this island. Ethan tells her that none of this is her fault, she came down her with good intentions. Ethan then tells Theresa that he can't spend one more day without her as his wife, and he wants her to get married right away. Theresa thinks they should wait because of Sheridan, but Luis shows up and tells Theresa that Sheridan would want them to be married and not put it off because of her. Luis says they should get married right now, Sheridan would want them to get married. Theresa doesn't think getting married right now is the right thing to do. Suddenly, Julian shows up to see Theresa. Ethan asks what about? Julian says it concerns his divorce from Ivy, Theresa is her personal assistant. Theresa goes with Julian, and tells him that he needs to get their marriage annulled and all the records of it destroyed as soon as possible! Julian isn't in a rush to divorce Theresa, and talks about their wonderful wedding night. Whitney shows up and tells Julian that he is a pig, and if he thinks Ethan and Luis will be a problem for him if the truth comes out, think about what the rest of the town of Harmony will do to him! Julian says he realizes that, so Theresa tells him to make the annulment happen! Julian suggests to Theresa that they just stay married and run away to Europe! Theresa is appalled, and Whitney orders Julian to stay away from Theresa! Julian agrees to get the annulment, and says he'll marry Rebecca in order to please her.
Julian returns to the crowd, and tells everyone that the ceremony can begin. Rebecca is thrilled, and Bruce tells the Justice to just stick to the plan they discussed. Meanwhile, Ethan tells Theresa that he has a surprise for her. Theresa asks him what the surprise is? He tells her to come with him, and leads her away. In the wedding chapel, Julian and Rebecca's wedding is about to begin when Ethan, Theresa, and the others show up. Ethan tells Theresa that if Julian and Rebecca approve, he would like them to get married along with them! Bruce says "the plot thickens!" The Justice tells Bruce that he can't do this. Bruce tells him to think about his career, and the bribe he got. The Justice doesn't care because he can't live with this burden, but Bruce tells him that he took that bribe and agreed to keep his mouth shut! Ethan asks Theresa if she'll marry him, but Theresa says she can't do this, they shouldn't intrude on someone else's wedding. Gwen agrees, a wedding day is special to a woman, so they shouldn't intrude on her mother's wedding. Ethan tells Theresa that he loves her and asks her to please marry him. She agrees, so the double ceremony begins!
Luis takes Sheridan's ashes out to the beach, and remembers how his father said the sea gives and takes equally. Luis wishes there was a way the sea could give him back the woman he loves.
Somewhere at sea, Brian performs CPR on Sheridan. Sheridan clings to life, but Brain doesn't think she'll live much longer if she doesn't get medical attention soon. Brian asks the captain to turn around and go back to shore, but the captain refuses to turn back until he meets his fish "quota." The captain could care less about Sheridan and tells Brian to toss her overboard! Brian refuses, and argues with the captain, who is drunk. The captain continues to refuse to turn back, and pulls a knife out. He orders Brian that if he continues talking about turning around, it will be considered an act of mutiny, and he can and will protect his ship. Brian and the captain soon begin to fight over the knife. Brain beats the tar out of the captain, and then orders that he take this boat back to shore!
In Harmony, Charity tells Grace that she believes their prayer will help someone. Grace does as well, she feels they have sent out a good energy to help someone. Later, as they discuss Charity's visions, Pilar overhears and asks Charity what is wrong with Luis and Sheridan? Charity tells Pilar about her visions of an explosion. Pilar begins to worry about Luis and Sheridan being cut-off from communication in Bermuda because of the storm. Charity didn't know they were in Bermuda, she says that the explosion was on a boat in the tropics. Charity says not all of her premonitions come true, for example her odd premonition about Theresa with another man. Pilar says she didn't tell her about that vision. Charity fills her in on the vision about Theresa, and Pilar worries even more. Pilar worries because Theresa went down to Bermuda as well to talk to Julian about reinstating Ethan into the family. Charity says she can't say who the man was, but Pilar worries that Julian may have taken advantage of Theresa. Charity says that in her vision she saw Theresa making a mistake, a huge mistake that would change her life. Pilar becomes hysterical, so Grace asks Charity to go get Eve. Pilar thinks the worse, and says that if anything happened, Luis might kill Julian!
Meanwhile, Eve comes to see Pilar after Charity told her that she needed him. Pilar says she is just worried about their children, and prays nothing happens to them. Eve and Grace tell Pilar that not all of Charity's visions come true. Pilar continues to worry, she says Luis and Sheridan can't be dead, Sheridan is the only good Crane left. Pilar says all the others are so wicked, she has seen Alistair and Julian at work. Pilar says now Theresa is stuck in Bermuda, possibly with Julian! Pilar swears that if Julian did anything to Theresa, she will neuter him like the dog he is! Eve says the Cranes are evil, God knows they have touched all their lives. Grace says the one thing she can't blame on the Cranes is David, that is the fault of her own amnesia. Grace tells Eve and Pilar what she heard Sam telling Ivy, but Eve says she told Sam to say that to help Ivy. Grace knows that, but sometimes she wonders if she is the only woman in his heart. Pilar and Eve urge Grace to find Sam and talk this over with him. She agrees, and goes to look for Sam.
Grace goes looking for Sam, and hears someone talking to Ivy. She wonders if Sam is talking to Ivy again? She is shocked to find David talking to Ivy, telling her to fight and not give up on Sam. He tells her that if she gets Sam back, Grace will be free to be with him. Grace is furious with David and says that she thought he cared about her and wanted what is best for her. David says she doesn't understand, he loves her and wants to be back with her. David says he doesn't believe Sam has no feelings left for Ivy, and if Ivy can be with Sam, then she is free to come back to him.
In Bermuda, Luis wishes one of the boats out at sea could bring Sheridan back to him. Out at sea, Sheridan lays on a boat which is heading back to shore. Brian and his friend discuss Sheridan, and they notice she doesn't have a ring on. Brian says she may have taken it off, or lost it at sea. He says if there is a husband or boyfriend, he must be worried sick about her. Sheridan begins to come too, but she is shivering. Brian realizes this isn't good. He runs to get a hot water bottle. While gone, the drunk captain returns! The captain decides to get something out of trip, and decides to have his way with Sheridan. Brain return and saves Sheridan again. Brain is positive she has a boyfriend, and he says that man is very lucky to have a woman like her.
Meanwhile, the Justice begins the marriage between Julian and Rebecca, and Ethan and Theresa. Theresa stops, and asks Rebecca if it is okay that she and Ethan marry with them. Rebecca doesn't give a fiddle-dee-dee. Gwen yanks her mother out of the room and asks her why she isn't stopping Theresa from marrying Ethan, she knows she wants Ethan! Rebecca says once she marries Julian, she can get Gwen anything she wants, including Ethan! Rebecca and Gwen return, and Rebecca tells the Justice that he will continue and nothing will stop them until she is Mrs. Julian Crane! Suddenly, Theresa stops the wedding and says Luis should be here! Theresa says she can't get married without her brother. Chad says that's not a problem, he'll go get him. Rebecca thinks Ethan and Theresa should wait, but she wants to be married now. Bruce says they should wait, they don't want to make the Justice perform two ceremonies. The Justice says he doesn't want to perform one, and quickly says that he is just tired from the storm. Chad brings Luis in, and Luis tells Ethan to marry Theresa now, or he may regret it. Rebecca tells the Justice to continue, so he does. Suddenly, a man from the hotel interrupts with news from the States, Ivy Crane has been struck by lightening and is in critical condition. The man says they aren't sure she is going to make it through the night. Julian tells Rebecca that he can't go through with the wedding, he has to go back and check on Ivy. Julian says if he doesn't go the press will have a field day. Gwen agrees, and tells her mother that she plans to marry Ethan some day, and she doesn't want him to remember her mother honeymooning while his mother was on her death bed! Julian asks Ethan if there is anything he can do? Ethan asks if they can borrow the Crane jet to go back to Harmony. Julian says the Crane jet is already back in Harmony, so he asks the hotel manager to make arrangements to have a plane fly them to Harmony immediately. Meanwhile, the Justice refuses to let them leave without telling them the truth. However, the Justice needs a copy of the wedding photo as proof, and runs off. Later, the hotel manager says that it will take time for the jet to be fueled. Rebecca and Ethan realize they can still get married before leaving. Rebecca suggests they find the Justice and have him continue with the ceremony. They all begin searching for the Justice, and Theresa and Whitney find him bound and gagged in a closet, compliments of Bruce. Rebecca shows up, and asks Theresa what she has found?
In Bermuda, Ethan makes his love for Theresa known to a disappointed Gwen. Later, Gwen comforts Ethan as he worries about his mother. He fears they won't get back to Harmony soon enough, and he doesn't want his mother to be alone. Gwen tells Ethan that from what she knows about his father, Sam isn't the kind of man to let the mother of his child be alone during her time of need.
Elsewhere, a quick thinking Bruce has locked the Justice of the Peace in a closet to keep him from revealing Julian and Theresa's marriage. Rebecca almost finds the Justice, but Theresa and Julian manage to stop her by claiming the hotel is crawling with rats, and that is what Theresa found in the closet. Rebecca has no interest in seeing rats, and leaves the closet alone.
Luis continues to mourn Sheridan. meanwhile, Brian takes a still-unconscious Sheridan to a hotel for a doctor to look at her.
Theresa and Whitney agree she must tell no one of the mess she is in. Julian is grateful the weddings have been postponed so everyone can return to Harmony and Ethan can be by his mother's bedside. To please Rebecca, Julian tells her that they will marry in Harmony. Rebecca is pleased, because now she can have a big wedding and show off. Elsewhere, A devastated Luis is not ready to go home yet. His spirits are lifted when a victim of the storm is found at sea, but it turns out not to be Sheridan.
The gang board the plane back to Harmony, and the flight attendant shows up and says "Mrs. Crane?" Both Rebecca and Theresa answer yes, and everyone wants to know why Theresa answered to Mrs. Crane. Theresa says she is just so used to knowing Ethan and Ethan Crane, and she is close to being his wife, so she unconsciously answered yes. Everyone buys her excuse, and the attendant says some luggage has been brought on marked Mrs. Crane. Rebecca says that must be hers, and says she just marked it Mrs. Crane thinking that she would be Mrs. Crane by now.
Back in Harmony, Tabitha and Timmy worry about Charity's powers surfacing. They focus on preventing Charity from sleeping with Miguel so her powers won't increase in strength. Meanwhile, a confident Miguel tries to reassure a worried Charity it wasn't him she promised to give up. Charity suddenly thinks of a way to figure out what exactly she gave up. Charity and Miguel go outside, and as Charity tries to talk to a tree, Tabitha and Timmy spy on her. Charity asks the tree to tell her what she gave up, but nothing happens. As she and Miguel are going back inside, the tree begins to rustle, and it says "Miguel." Timmy and Tabitha smile, and Tabitha says that things are finally going there way!
Elsewhere, David tells Grace that if Sam still loves Ivy, and can't love her with all his heart, then he wants to be the person to give her the love she deserves. Grace tells David that Sam doesn't love Ivy anymore, but David asks what if she is wrong? Grace says that Sam is just trying to save Ivy by giving her hope. Still, David says they both know something more is going on in Ivy's room between Sam and Ivy. David tells Grace that she doesn't have to lie to him, he knows it must be hurting her to see Sam, Ivy, and Ethan together, but Grace says it doesn't because she knows Sam has no feelings for Ivy. Grace says she is also happy for Ethan that he has a father like Sam. David tells Grace that she is not thinking about Ethan, she's thinking about the son she lost. Grace says she can't help but wonder how things might have been if she had had that child. Grace decides to go find Sam, but David says Sam is with Ivy and Ethan. Grace says she knows that. David says he'll take her to see Sam, but she may feel a little left out. Grace tells David that she doesn't know what to do.
Luis, Ethan, Theresa, Whitney, and Chad arrive at the hospital. Ethan goes to find out what room his mom is in, and Luis tells Theresa that she should be with Ethan now, because she will be his wife soon. Whitney agrees with Luis, and tells Theresa that she should be with Ethan now. Ethan and Theresa go to Ivy's room, and see Sam in with Ivy. Theresa thinks that Ethan should go in alone, she doesn't want her being here to upset her. Ethan thinks Theresa is right, and thanks her for being here. Ethan goes inside, and Whitney and Theresa talk once again about Theresa's marrying Julian. Whitney is just glad that nobody here in Harmony knows the truth. In Ivy's room, Ethan talks to Sam. Sam tells Ethan what is going on, and that it depends on Ivy whether or not she will get better. Ethan tells Sam that Ivy didn't risk her life for his half-sisters, he did it for him because she still loves him. Ethan says they are the two most important people in Ivy's life, and when she gets better, she will need them more than anything. Sam tells Ethan that he loves Grace and is married to her now, and he'd never leave Grace for Ivy. Ethan says he understands, and he knows his mom has given up on trying to win him back. A nurse shows up and gives Ethan his mother's belonging, among which is the locket Sam gave to Ivy. Ethan then begins to think that maybe his mother truly hasn't gotten over the idea of them being a family. Sam and Ethan begin talking about Ivy, and the past. Ethan tells Sam that maybe together they can make a difference and help Ivy. Ethan talks to his mother to let her know that he is here with "dad." Ethan tells Ivy that they need her to get better and come back to them. Sam tells Ivy that the three of them are together now as a family, just the way she wanted.
Luis goes to see Pilar, who is glad to see he is okay. She asks how Theresa is? Luis says Theresa is fine. Pilar asks what about Sheridan? Luis says nothing, and Pilar realizes something is wrong. Luis tells his mom that Sheridan is dead. Pilar, and Eve who is there, are shocked. Luis tells them the whole story about the explosion, and the discovery of Sheridan's body. Pilar tells Luis that she is very sorry, Sheridan was like a daughter to her. Luis tells his mom that he still thinks Sheridan is alive and out there. He says in his head he knows it is impossible, but his heart tells him not to give up hope. Pilar says she can understand him not wanting to believe she is gone. Pilar says even if she did survive the explosion, she couldn't have survived the hurricane, that would be a true miracle. Pilar says as good as god his, he doesn't dispense miracles every day. Later, Hank, who showed up and heard the story, asks Luis if he's sure the right woman was cremated? Hank says they know Julian and Alistair can't be trusted. Luis says the body was too decomposed to make an ID, so Sheridan's dental records were used to verify it was her, he even double checked everything himself. Luis says that SHeridan is really dead.
Later, Eve runs into Whitney and Theresa and is glad to see they are back. She then asks "What is this about Julian? Did something happen with him while they were in Bermuda?" Whitney says they had some dealings with him, and they explain why Theresa went to Bermuda. Theresa lies and assures Eve that she and Mr. Crane just talked, and things didn't turn out the way she wanted them to. Eve tells Theresa and Whitney that they need to be careful around him, he is a vile man who just uses vulnerable young girls. Eve then takes the girls for a cup of coffee. Later, Theresa sees her mother, and Pilar is glad to see her. Pilar asks if anything happened to her in Bermuda? Theresa says she is fine, nothing to worry about. Pilar says she is just afraid that the rest of Charity's premonition has come true. Theresa asks what premonitions? Pilar tells her about Charity's premonitions. As Pilar tells Theresa about Charity's premonition, Theresa begins to cry. Pilar knows Theresa is keeping something from her. Pilar threatens to go to Luis and Ethan if she doesn't fess up. Theresa tells her mother that what happened was the worst night of her life! Pilar asks her what happened, did she get involved with another man? Theresa says it is too complicated, she doesn't know where to start. Pilar demands Theresa tell him his name. Theresa says she was only trying to make things right for Ethan, and it was Julian Crane. Theresa tells her mom that they did more then get involved, they got married. Theresa says she is Mrs. Julian Crane! Pilar promptly faints!
In the tropics, Brian takes Sheridan to his friends Doc and Liz. Liz tells Brian that she is a knockout, and damn lucky they were able to save her. Doc looks over Sheridan and says she is alive, barely. Doc says it would help if they knew what happened to her. Brian says he found her in a sarong, so he doubts she was swimming. When Brian says he put the clothes on her, Liz teases Brian and says that was a noble way to see her naked. Brian says he had a blanket over her the whole time. Doc tells them to go argue in the hall because he can't hear himself think. Brian and Liz go outside, and Liz tells Brian that even though that lady is half dead, she is still the prettiest thing he's ever brought back here. Brian says he couldn't let her die, no matter who she turns out to be. Liz realizes that Brian cares about her, and she hopes she lives so she can thank Brian. Brian just hopes she makes it. Doc comes out to see them and says that the girl should be just fine. He says that she has no serious injuries, but how she survived the sea is unimaginable to him. Liz says now they just have to find out who she is. Brian says a beautiful woman like that couldn't have been alone, someone must be looking for her. Doc tells them to call him if she wakes up, and he leaves. Brian stares at Sheridan, and Liz asks him if he can take his eyes off their guest long enough to have a cup of coffee? Brian says he supposes, so he and Liz leave. Brian and Liz talk, and Liz says that there was a big search going on for some big uptown girl, and their mystery girl could be her. Liz asks Brian what he'll do if she turns out to be some society chick? Brian says he'll have to spend the rest of his life wondering what might have been. Later, Brian goes back and sits next to Sheridan and talks to her. As he is talking, Liz shows up and tells him that Doc's boat just pulled in. Doc shows up and tells them that the lady he saved from the sea is Sheridan Crane! Brian looks devastated upon hearing the news.
At the mansion, Julian meets with Harper, his attorney, and arranges for an annulment. He warns Harper to tell no one of his marriage to Theresa, and to file the annulment under John and Jane Doe. Later, Harper tells Julian how Ivy has become the town heroine after helping Sam fix the lighthouse beacon, and Alistair wants Julian to pay her a visit in the hospital. Julian is shocked by his father's request for him to go to Ivy's bedside.
At the hospital, Theresa and Whitney revive Pilar, who fainted upon learning of her daughter's marriage to Julian. Ethan and Luis show up and ask what happened to Pilar? Theresa says she just fainted, so Luis and Ethan run off to get help. Pilar comes to and reprimands Theresa for getting herself into such a mess. Theresa, Whitney, and Pilar try to cover in front of Luis and Ethan, who return. Theresa claims that Pilar fainted because of the heat, but Luis thinks she fainted because of the shock of Sheridan's death, and that they don't need to lie to him. Luis decides to go be by himself, and heads to the chapel to pray. Meanwhile, Julian shows up to see Ivy, and plays with her IV, wondering what would happen if he disconnected it. Ivy wakes up, and monitors begin beeping. She tells him to leave, so he does. Elsewhere, Ethan leaves to check on his mother. Pilar talks to Theresa about her stupid mistake, and Theresa reveals that there is more. She tells her mother that she learned she was married to Julian when she woke up in his room! Pilar can't believe this is happening. Suddenly, Julian shows up, and Pilar slaps him across the face!
In the tropics, Liz, Doc, and Brain argue over whether the girl Brian found is really Sheridan Crane. Brian refuses to believe it is Sheridan, but Doc is pretty sure she is. They debate it for awhile, and eventually decide that it must be Sheridan Crane. Brian decides to call Harmony to let them know that Sheridan is alive, because her fiancee and family will want to know she is okay.