In Bermuda, Sheridan answers the phone in Father Frank's office, and can't take it when it is a parishioner calling to ask about Father Frank. Brian tells them that Father Frank passed away. Later, the caretaker brings Sheridan and Brian some tea, and they talk to him about Father Frank. They learn that this parish is where Father Frank was born and raised here, and this is were his parents were married. Sheridan is shocked, and asks to see Father Frank's place. The caretaker takes them to the chapel, and Sheridan has a flashback of her wedding to Brian in another life. Later, Sheridan and Brian go to see their own graves!
At the convenience store, Timmy tries to leave after triggering a silent alarm, but one of the kids refuses to allow Timmy to leave. They think he is up to something, but he insists he isn't. He offers them money if they let him go, and tells them that he wrote Hidden Passions, so he has money back in HArmony. They laugh at him, and then the cops show up! The kids realize Timmy hit the silent alarm. The kids try to flee, but they all get caught. The teens blame everything on Timmy, but Timmy manages to hide from the cops! The cops take the kids away, and Timmy and Toto run for it.
At the mansion, Theresa is shocked to see Ethan kill Julian, and thinks he did it for her. An eavesdropping Rebecca and Ivy are thrilled that Theresa believes the tape, and Ivy says soon she'll be on death row! Ethan shows up and asks who will be on death row? Ivy says they were just discussing a movie. Ethan finds it odd that they are watching movies together, but Ivy and Rebecca insist they are just keeping eyes on one another. Meanwhile, Theresa says she has to get rid of this tape and find out what the man who gave it to her wants. She calls him and asks to see him right away! He says he'll be right over. The man shows up, and he claims he works at the cannery and saw the whole thing. He says he took the tape and switched it with another, so the cops never saw it. She asks how much he wants, and he says 100 grand, for starters. She says she is not going to be a money machine for him, but he says she will be his ATM or he will go to the cops! Theresa pays him the first installment, and she is caught by Ethan! Ethan asks the man who he is, and why is he taking money from her? Theresa says he was just selling her something, that is all. After the man leaves, Theresa asks Ethan if he hated Julian enough to kill him. He says he did for what he did to her. Theresa realizes Ethan killed Julian for her. Meanwhile, Rebecca explains the rest of her plan to Ivy. She says they must convince Theresa that Ethan would be sentenced to death, but a pregnant woman who was basically raped and committed a crime of passion would only serve a very short amount of time. Later, Rebecca's man tells her that Theresa paid up just like she wanted.
At the Book Cafe, Luis' search for answers about Sheridan's past life reaches a dead end when he learns Father Frank just died. Meanwhile, Beth shows Hank the picture of Sheridan's husband from the past life, which looks like Antonio. Hank tries to convince Beth not to tell Luis what she found out about Antonio. Luis takes off to go home, and Beth decides she's going to give Luis a choice as to whether or not he wants see the pictures of Sheridan's former husband or not.
Luis heads home and learns Antonio called. He is angry that Antonio said nothing about the house burning down, and that he is not coming home to help his family. Pilar tries to calm him down. He then shows her the pictures he found of him and Sheridan on the Titanic in a past life. Pilar tells him that reincarnation goes against the churches teachings, and these must just be a coincidence. Luis says maybe, but he wishes he knew more about the man Sheridan ended up with because perhaps he knew him too. Meanwhile, Beth and Hank arrive with the photos of Antonio!
At the mansion, Ethan nearly sees the incriminating tape, but Theresa stashes it in her purse. Whitney shows up, and Ethan lets her in. He returns and wonders where the tape with his and Julian's name, which was sitting on the TV, went to. Theresa claims she has no idea, and he thinks she is lying. Theresa tries to change the topic and says they have to go meet Chad at the studio. They all go there, and Chad is shocked to see them because he didn't expect them. Once again Ethan feels Theresa is lying to him, and he says whatever she is keeping from him will eventually come out. Chad is glad to see them as he plays his latest piece for them. They all like it, and he tells them that the lyrics are about sacrificing everything for love. Ethan says he'd do anything for the woman he loves. Theresa thinks Ethan killed Julian for her, and wonders what she can do for him. Back at the mansion, Rebecca tells Ivy the rest of her plan for THeresa, which we do not hear. Rebecca asks Ivy if she can do it, and Ivy says she will put on the performance of her life if it means ridding them of Theresa.
Timmy and Toto hide in a sewer pipe from the police, and to get out of the wet rain. Timmy then fantasizes about marrying Charity once he saves her.
At the Bennett's, everyone sets up for Charity's 18th birthday party. Kay wonders where Charity is, and Jessica says she thinks she went over to Tabitha's to ask her for a favor. Reese begins ranting and raving about Tabitha being a witch, and Grace asks him if his parents know about his little Tabitha obsession? Meanwhile, Eve and David feel bad about the lies they have told for Ivy. They both wonder what Ivy has on the other. Later, Simone asks her mom if she has any problems with Chad being the DJ at the party tonight. Eve says she is fine with it, and wants to put this all behind them. Simone says Chad isn't the bad person that her dad thinks he is. Eve unfortunately knows this, but can't reveal how she knows it.
At Tabitha's, Tabitha is cleaning up, and is throwing away a bunch of tapes of old NBC shows. She claims she made all these shows bomb, and if she hadn't lost her powers she may have reduced NBC to a low-rated cable network, but now it is celebrating its 75th anniversary. Tabitha names all the hit shows on NBC, and then talks about a ground breaking daytime drama. When the theme for Passion plays, we see Tabitha and Charity dance around. Later, Charity reveals her plans to destroy everyone in Harmony, including exposing Tabitha's past as a witch and Timmy's past as a doll! Zombie Charity also wants Tabitha to come to her party and read everyone's tea leaves.
BAck at the party, Zombie Charity arrives and Kay tells her that she's not going to let her sleep with Miguel.
At the Book Cafe, Ethan and Chad talk about Whitney. Chad says he just has to accept that he has lost any chance with Whitney. Ethan says sometimes love just isn't enough. Ethan begins to worry about THeresa and what she is hiding from him. Chad says maybe it is just hormones, but Ethan says it is bigger than hormones.
On the pier, Whitney asks Theresa what is bothering her? Theresa says nothing is wrong, but Whitney knows when she gets this upset it has to do with Ethan. Theresa says she just can't talk about this. Whitney suggests she talk to Luis, but Theresa says he is the last person she can talk to. WHitney then suggests she go to the church and pray. Theresa thinks she can talk to Father Lonigan, because he can't repeat what she has to say. Later, Chad shows up and thanks them for coming to hear his new song. Theresa asks where Ethan is? Chad says Ethan went back to the mansion because there was a news flash on the radio that the Governor wants Julian Crane's murderer found ASAP. Theresa panics and runs off. Whitney and Chad talk about what is eating Theresa. Chad wonders if Theresa knows who killed Julian Crane? Whitney says she couldn't know, and not to even think Theresa did it. Chad says he just hopes she knows nothing about the murder, he's not accusing her of anything. Chad says whoever killed Julian will probably go straight to the electric chair.
Theresa goes to the church and talks to Father Lonigan about what she knows. Theresa makes Father Lonigan promise to keep what she has to say will keep confidential. Theresa says she knows who murdered Julian, it was Ethan!
At the mansion, Rebecca tells Ivy that they have to convince Theresa that Ethan is in real jeopardy so she confesses to the murder. Ethan shows up and once again searches for the video with his name on it. HE asks his mother and Rebecca if they have seen it. They claims they haven't seen a tape lying around. He asks them if they've done anything to Theresa to upset her lately, and they say the last thing they want to do is get on her bad side.
A cop finds Timmy. Miguel and Zombie Charity anticipate making love after the birthday party. Kay worries about what is going to happen and feels powerless to stop it. Zombie Charity plans to drop several bombshells at the party. The zombie fakes a premonition about an arrest in Julian's murder case.
At the mansion, Rebecca tells Ivy that there are only two copies of the tape, Theresa has one and she has the other. Rebecca opens her purse, and is shocked that the tape is gone! Ivy goes into a panic, and Rebecca fortunately finds it in the bottom of her BIG purse. Rebecca tells Ivy not to worry, Sam will not arrest Ethan. Ivy and Rebecca get a call from Rebecca's henchman, who has been trailing Theresa. They decide to head to the station to see what is going on.
At the church, Whitney finds Theresa in tears. Whitney says that Charity had a premonition that someone would be arrested for Julian's murder today! This freaks Theresa out even more. Whitney then accusses Theresa of knowing who killed Julian. She insists she doesn't, and she asks who Charity said would be arrested. Whitney says Charity only said it would be someone close to Chief Bennett. Theresa begins ranting about the tape, and how it is all her fault. Theresa runs off to the station to fix things.
At the station, Sam continues to go over the murder report. Luis learns he is now off the case because he is too close to the case. Luis says he didn't kill anyone, and neither did his mother or sister. Sam agrees to let him stay on the case, and tells him about Charity's latest premonition. Later, Theresa shows up and overhears Sam talking about having to arrest Ethan. Theresa fears that the police do know Ethan killed Julian, and she has a vision of Ethan being sentenced to die. Theresa says she can't let Ethan die, so she bursts into the station and goes nutso. Sam tells her to calm down, and asks if she knows something about Julian's murder? Meanwhile, Ivy and Rebecca show up and see that Theresa is inside. They spy on her as Theresa as she confesses to murdering Julian!
In Bermuda, Brian and Sheridan/Diana get ready to celebrate Brian's birthday. Brian comes out of the shower in a towel, which turns Sheridan on! Suddenly, thr champaigne Sheridan ordered arrives! They share a toast, and a little kiss. Sheridan then has another past life flashback. Sheridan tells Brian that she's lost so much in her life already, and she's afraid she might lose him. Sheridan begins to feel sorry for herself because she has no memories, so she feels worthless. Brian promises her that she'll never be alone, any man would love to have her as his wife. BRian and Diana then share a real kiss. The phone rings, so Brian answers it. It is the restaurant calling to confirm their dinner resrvation. Later, we see Brian and Sheridan in bed, under the covers, doing the deed!